4 ms·
> The Welfare state might become unsustainable It's not "might become", we already know it's unsustainable. It's just that presently we are taking on so much d
by ekianjo 10y ago
> The Welfare state might become unsustainable
It's not "might become", we already know it's unsustainable. It's just that presently we are taking on so much debt to make up for the ongoing costs of it, but at some point the future generations of workers may wonder why they have to pay so much when they don't get any of the benefits.
- sien 10y agoPotentially productive capacity might rise rapidly due to automation. Also the welfare state might be reduced somewhat to make it sustainable. Or a combination of both.
- ekianjo 10y ago> Also the welfare state might be reduced somewhat to make it sustainable. That's already progressively happening, but it's because it's progressive it becomes a problem: you are for example paying for the pensions of folks who are retired now, but not for yours and there will be either no pension for when you reach 65, or they'll push it back to 75 to manage the costs. Folks who will retire in 20 years cannot count on the government's welfare at all.
- lz400 10y agoPerhaps it would be sustainable if most of the wealth wasn't going to a few people with little redistribution. I'm not even talking about communism, just fair taxation and contributing and no loop holes (double irish tricks and the like).
- ekianjo 10y ago> most of the wealth wasn't going to a few people with little redistribution What are you talking about? Corporate profits are nothing compared to the national budget for redistribution. Check your figures.
- lz400 10y agoUS Corporate profits are about 1.6 trillion, total national budget is 3.8 trillion. Looks very comparable numbers, don't they? And this is profit, after everyone already got paid and all the tricks have been performed in the books. I think definitely globalization and global tax dodging is affecting the ability of states to support a welfare state.
- sien 10y agoAnd corporations paid 770Bn in taxes in the US according to USA facts. http://usafacts.org/the-big-picture/revenue?return_to=%2F http://usafacts.org/the-big-picture/revenue?return_to=%2F In addition they employ a lot of the people who pay the 1.7Trn in Income and 1 Trn in payroll tax the US government gets.
- lz400 10y agoYes. I'm not sure what your point is. Do you mean "they already pay a lot of tax!". I think things like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement Point to the fact that global corporations spend a lot of effort making sure they get away with paying less than they should. If there was a fair taxation of corps at the level they should be taxed, they would be paying more. Obviously the corporations keep getting bigger and richer, and the 1% wealthier, yet we see countries struggling with welfare state. Doesn't seem right.
- candiodari 10y agoNope, this is tax avoidance, not tax evasion. In practice, of course, the law across different countries effectively allows for different tax rates. This was decided and entered into law. Of course all of these tax rates are agreed to be what the corporation "should" pay. Corporations simply select the lowest of the choices available to them. Is that not what they "should" pay ? Not a problem: congress can vote laws that make these constructions impossible. They are not doing so. Don't blame corporations here, they're simply responding to incentives congress put there for them. Instead, blame congress. They can change the tax rate, even for international profits and revenues (in fact the US is infamous for doing that in several ways already), and they make the rules about what can be tax deferred and what can't. They're not changing those rules, and you can bet they know what they're doing. I think the bigger issue is that because states are paying for things that are unsustainable (ie. the welfare state, even in the US, is unsustainable) the tax level doesn't matter : it's too low. Changing the tax level simply changes the point in time where the system crashes, but fixing is not possible. We simply cannot put the current level of economic activity into elder care in the future.