10 ms·
Japan's fertility crisis is terrifying and unprecedented
- arkitaip 10y ago"Adult diapers have outsold baby diapers in Japan for the last six years, and many jails are turning into de facto nursing homes, as Japanese elders account for 20% of all crime in the country." Stat of the day right there.
- cm2012 10y agoSouth korea fertility rate is now lower.
- IIAOPSW 10y agoJapan doesn't have a fertility crisis. They are merely in the process of replacing themselves with robots.
- jordanb 10y agoI'm not sure what's supposed to be terrifying about it. This planet has way too many humans on it. We need to figure out how to cause our populations to decline naturally until we can get the number of humans down to the point where everyone can live good, happy, resource rich lives without cooking the planet. Japan is on the vanguard of figuring out how to do that. Obviously there are difficulties involved. Not the least is dealing with the relentless march of Capitalism which requires every year be more, and bigger, than the year before, lest the whole thing fall over.
- angersock 10y ago> This planet has way too many humans on it. Don't cut yourself on that edge there, buddy.
- kyleschiller 10y agoIt's not really terrifying for the rest of the world, but Japan has a huge social welfare program[0] and the world's second highest life expectancy[1], which means this generation will be tasked with providing for an aging population much larger than they are. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_in_Japan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_in_Japan, https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=SOCX_AGG https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=SOCX_AGG [1] https://www.infoplease.com/world/health-and-social-statistics/life-expectancy-countries-0 https://www.infoplease.com/world/health-and-social-statistic... EDIT: Better source for [0]
- toomuchtodo 10y agoEh, Japan will get rich showing/selling the next first world countries in line how to provide for their elders with automation. Good for Japan because of xenophobia towards immigrants (and that cultural phenomenon is definitely not changing anytime soon), good for the US because we're broke and can't afford to keep extracting more for entitlements because we didn't save enough for it and kicked the can.
- jordanb 10y agoThis is exactly my point. Japan has the opportunity to chart the way forward: to show the rest of the world how to do more with fewer people and a smaller impact. To determine what an economy looks like that deals efficiently with resources and provides for its citizens without relentless growth.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 10y ago> to show the rest of the world how to do more with fewer people and a smaller impact Japan has no plan. Let's not write sentences like there is a big mastermind behind everything. Politicians are not even able to take care of the ongoing budget and pressing issues, so let's not assume they know what to do 10 years from now.
- BenoitEssiambre 10y agoOverpopulation is a problem but it is quite a stretch to blame capitalism which requires no particular growth course.
- keerthiko 10y ago> This planet has way too many humans on it. I can get behind this. but... > I'm not sure what's supposed to be terrifying about it. So, so many things. The world is not as unified as it needs to be for this to be a good thing. Population decline is Japan is a) too small to ease overall resource burden on the world, b) increasing resource burden on Japan itself, c) Japan's situation to enjoy/deal with, the rest of the world is hardly going to reward it for it. Trying to maintain a functioning economy is going to get harder with a shrinking able-bodied workforce in the near future, I would not want to be responsible for addressing that. If and when the Japanese economy collapses in the current world immigration climate, people will have little recourse too -- with their language and culture isolation so far, they'll just be stuck in their crumbling economy. One of the reasonable solutions is to increase worker mobility, and encourage economic contributors to migrate to and operate in Japan, and not worry so much about indigenous population decline. But this is a major big cultural, economic and social change to embrace, which is starting to get harder to adopt in today's increasingly isolationist rhetoric.
- ekianjo 10y ago> Trying to maintain a functioning economy is going to get harder with a shrinking able-bodied workforce in the near future, I would not want to be responsible for addressing that. Japan has way too much fluff in its economy: People working with almost zero productivity, or completely useless jobs (purely bureaucratic) or facade kind of jobs (folks just hired to stand around) - it's actually very good to see the worker base shrinking, it will bring a lot more focus in the long run, hopefully. > and not worry so much about indigenous population decline Japan became a major world power when it only had something like 40-50M inhabitants. You don't need 120 Millions folks in Japan to be a powerful country. Like, not at all.
- keerthiko 10y agoGood points. All economies have a lot of fluff, but yeah, it would be exciting if the shrinking workforce meant a focus on optimizing the productivity of individual workers, while the country doesn't have to deal with unemployment at the same time. Really the only issue is the short period of time in the immediate future of providing current levels of welfare to the large elderly population with a much smaller still-inefficient younger workforce facing the burden of doing so. It's possible if they figure out a good short term solution, it could put Japan into a lean diet that is really good for it in the long-run. However they also run the risk of suffering some serious long-term economic damage if this rough patch doesn't go well. Way too many things can go wrong -- if the young decide to also ditch the workforce and rely on state welfare while it lasts, or are not supported enough, or the focus goes too heavily on making babies and not on optimizing economic output, etc.
- krapp 10y agoI may be wrong, and someone will point it out if I am, but I believe a lot of Japan is actually not very population dense. Tokyo, obviously, and other large cities, but the countryside is practically and literally dying out. There is still plenty of room, it's just that no one wants to live there. Even if it were the case that "this planet has way too many humans on it," which is debatable, why is that Japan's problem if there aren't even "way too many people" in Japan?
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoOverpopulation is not the issue so much as said population's individual resource consumption, particularly Westerners'.
- autokad 10y agoThis is not just a Japan problem, much of Europe and the United States is also in the same boat.
- altstar 10y agoChina too. http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/china-now-has-the-lowest-fertility-rate-the-world-18570 http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/china-now-has-the-...
- autokad 10y agoyeah, what a disaster
- ekianjo 10y agoChina will get there much faster because of the 1 child policy, indeed.
- stevenmays 10y agoThe one child policy has been abolished. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-child_policy#Abolition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-child_policy#Abolition
- ekianjo 10y agoI know, but the effects of keeping it for so long will still be felt for a very long time.
- rabboRubble 10y agoFinding childcare is nearly impossible. Sponsoring visas for domestic help (like what professional women in HK do) is nearly impossible unless the sponsor is C-level in a major corporation.
- gumby 10y agoI don't understand why the title was changed to the more clickbaity 'terrifying and unprecedented'. It may be unprecedented (unsure) but why should it be terrifying? The article discusses the solutions: - open up the economy to more people (women, in Japan's male-dominated workforce) - open up the economy to more people (immigrants -- while unpopular in Japan, certainly acceptable in plenty of other places; look at Germany's example of the Gastarbeiter in the 50s/60s to make up for the labor force lost in war) - automation. It's not like these solutions are unavailable to the rest of the OECD. Personally I look forward to a massively automated economy to free human creativity and leisure.
- emmab 10y ago- Subsidize parenting
- ekianjo 10y agoYou know Japan already has more debt that it can handle right? It's not the solution.
- flukus 10y agoThey could increase taxes. If it's really more debt than they can handle the should be declaring bankruptcy, which is probably better than decades of stagnation anyway.
- ekianjo 10y agoThey have already increased taxes, and are planning to almost double to VAT in a few years time. The problem with taxes is that you have very quick diminishing returns and take a dent at consumption very quickly. As for bankruptcy, not going to happen in Japan since the local banks own the debt and declaring bankruptcy would make the banking system in Japan crash, leading to unknown consequences. I think they rather want to keep it under control as long as they can, while they are progressively getting their backs against the wall.
- 10y ago
- ahiknsr 10y agointeresting answer from a japanese teen ( https://www.quora.com/Ive-heard-that-Japan-recently-is-facing-a-population-problem-whereas-most-of-the-teenagers-there-arent-really-interested-in-dating-Why-is-that-so/answer/Kotaro-Hanawa https://www.quora.com/Ive-heard-that-Japan-recently-is-facin...)
- Meekro 10y agoPretty interesting! His answer makes it sound like teen dating in Japan is simultaneously idolized and condemned. I wonder how a contradiction this glaring actually works without making everyone's heads spin. For example, does "the professor [who] endlessly talks about his first girlfriend and how she degraded with age" then try to punish his young students for enjoying what he once enjoyed?
- Double_Cast 10y agoI'd always wondered about the trope "if someone sees my panties I have to marry them". That Quora explanation really put it in context.
- flukus 10y agoWhy is it terrifying? For the first time in history (aside from plagues and disasters) the wealth accumulated by the previous generation will be divided by fewer descendants.
- Double_Cast 10y agoOne reason is that Social Security transfers wealth from the young to the old. The shift in demographics may strain the program.
- m23khan 10y ago+1 for Toronto, Canada. Life is very stressful and free time is very limited. Combined that with a culture that is spend-all and very selfish (me time), voila - you come across a society where people are willing to stay single and not have kids (or have a max of 2 kids).
- eddyg 10y agoNothing wrong with a max of two kids. "According to some, zero population growth, perhaps after stabilizing at some optimum population, is the ideal towards which countries and the whole world should aspire in the interests of accomplishing long-term environmental sustainability." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_population_growth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_population_growth
- swsieber 10y agoBut max 2 kids doesn't lead to to zero population growth - it leads to decline since not everybody gets married, or has the max number of children... But there are probably outiers who have more which even that out.
- rlanday 10y agoYou might be living in a bubble if you think only married couples have kids; in the US, a whopping 40% of births are to unmarried parents: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/unmarried-childbearing.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/unmarried-childbearing.htm
- swsieber 10y agoI definitely am living in a bubble and so it slipped my mind (but not originally from a bubble). That said... if we aren't talking about legislation, yeah, that makes it much more reasonable.
- m23khan 10y agoIncorrect - the fertility rate for a given population in order for that population to 'not decline' is 2.1 (not 2.0). In Canada, we are not even hitting the 2.0 mark (we are at 1.6). source: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ca.html https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/...
- bobsgame 10y agoThis is why we need more anti-aging and longevity research. Reproduction is obsolete.
- Meekro 10y agoWe've had 14 hour workdays in the U.S. and elsewhere during the industrial revolution, and yet people somehow found the time for relationships and babies. What's different now?
- sien 10y agoWomen also work more in the paid workforce. Also people have reproductive control. Also people are richer and have more choice about getting married and having 5 kids (of which only half used to survive to 5).
- nyolfen 10y agomost people didn't have industrial jobs then
- flukus 10y agoPopulation growth used to come from rural areas, it wasn't until around the start of the 20th century that cities created a population surplus. Now we have rural areas in a steep decline world wide.
- sien 10y agoIt's remarkable how when people talk about how there won't be any jobs due to automation they rarely, if ever, look at how there will quite likely be fewer people and people will be older. That's going to take demand out of the system for many things and add demand for things where automation is hardest such as taking care of the old and infirm. Some aspects of automation, like cheap autonomous meal delivery help, but taking care of people is highly labour intensive. That coupled with lower productivity growth is going to have big impacts everywhere. The Welfare state might become unsustainable. Places like Australia and the US with high immigration will delay these issues somewhat, but even there as the countries where immigrants get richer and themselves have fewer children immigration is likely to reduce in the next 20-50 years.
- ekianjo 10y ago> The Welfare state might become unsustainable It's not "might become", we already know it's unsustainable. It's just that presently we are taking on so much debt to make up for the ongoing costs of it, but at some point the future generations of workers may wonder why they have to pay so much when they don't get any of the benefits.
- sien 10y agoPotentially productive capacity might rise rapidly due to automation. Also the welfare state might be reduced somewhat to make it sustainable. Or a combination of both.
- ekianjo 10y ago> Also the welfare state might be reduced somewhat to make it sustainable. That's already progressively happening, but it's because it's progressive it becomes a problem: you are for example paying for the pensions of folks who are retired now, but not for yours and there will be either no pension for when you reach 65, or they'll push it back to 75 to manage the costs. Folks who will retire in 20 years cannot count on the government's welfare at all.
- lz400 10y ago
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoA start to fixing it might be a 40-hour work week. The problem is extremely long hours are surely deeply ingrained in Japanese work culture at this point.
- ekianjo 10y agoMost contracts are 40-hour weeks, but they are not enforced. "Tada-zangyou" (free overtime) is the accepted practice.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoAh, I was thinking such rules wouldn't be enforced. Makes sense that they're already in place.
- anonymous3060 10y agoIt's "terrifying" and "unprecedented" because the Japanese shrewdly plan on compensating for their population's shortfall with automation rather than with mass immigration and multiculturalism. The most up-to-date estimates for Sub-Saharan Africa's population at this century's end now rest at a sobering four billion.[1] If just one eighth of them emigrate, that would be 500,000,000 Africans--roughly the current total population of the EU. It's clear by now that the US and other developed nations (particularly in Europe) are going to be expected to take in much of this surplus, not just out of compassion, but out of some supposed economic necessity, to sustain pension funds and entitlement programs. Japan is just being shamed for refusing to participate, and by its refusal, demonstrating a viable alternative--one that isn't tantamount to national suicide. [1] http://takimag.com/article/four_billion_africans_john_derbyshire/print http://takimag.com/article/four_billion_africans_john_derbys...
- krapp 10y agoThis is a myth which seems to have cropped up recently among the American right wing - that Japan is choosing its population decline as a show of defiance against multiculturalism, and that it would somehow rather die off than taint its racial or cultural purity, or that it has some magical "solution" involving "automation." Japan doesn't, by the way, plan on avoiding immigration. It's doing just the opposite, trying to make it easier[0,1] for skilled foreign workers to immigrate, because they may be xenophobic, but they're not stupid. And most of those immigrants are coming from other China and other Asian countries, not Sub-Saharan Africa. Don't make Japan out to be a martyr for your anti-immigration agenda. That's just another form of Orientalism. [0]http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-04-16/immigrants-flood-japan-record-pace http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-04-16/immigrants-flood-ja... [1]http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/japan-permanent-residency-rules-skilled-foreign-workers-lure-global-talent-ministry-justice-a7616426.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/japan-perman...
- anonymous3060 10y ago> for skilled foreign workers C.f. "Japan took in just 28 refugees in 2016, despite record applications" http://www.reuters.com/article/us-japan-asylum-idUSKBN15O0UV http://www.reuters.com/article/us-japan-asylum-idUSKBN15O0UV