3 ms·
I maintain "talk/paper" as the talk video links to the paper; the opposite happens to not be true, which is why it is so much more interesting to tell people "t
by saurik 9y ago
I maintain "talk/paper" as the talk video links to the paper; the opposite happens to not be true, which is why it is so much more interesting to tell people "there is also a video". FWIW, if your goal is just to link to different landing pages or sub-representations of the same thing, we could also submit the PowerPoint file itself. (I will also say that I guessed it was moderators that made the bump but purposely didn't make that explicit. That to me just underscores the need for a more fundamental fix to the way that content appears, as it makes clear that the twentieth time posted this was also just going to be do poorly again without manual intervention.)
- lmitchell 9y agoI mean... for what it's worth, I'd never seen it before, I would never have seen it without the manual intervention, and I loved it and think it's perfect for HN. I don't think we really need a 'fundamental fix' for anything, seems to be Working As Intended (tm) ;)
- gwern 9y ago> That to me just underscores the need for a more fundamental fix to the way that content appears, as it makes clear that the twentieth time posted this was also just going to be do poorly again without manual intervention. I agree, there's far too much randomness to HN. The two-tier structure is part of the problem; even with mod boosts, it's frequently the case for a link to fall off /newest with no upvotes, while on another occasion, it'll get +100. I see this all the time when checking my submissions: a link will be submitted 5 times previously over many years, and only 1 will do well - obviously, the link quality hasn't changed, yet the ratings are contradictory.