3 ms·
> Trump just let slip some random bit of classified information What was that information? And according to who?
by Chris2048 9y ago
> Trump just let slip some random bit of classified information
What was that information? And according to who?
- foldr 9y ago>What was that information? "Facts pertaining to terrorism and airline safety", in Trump's own words. >And according to who? People present at the meeting with the Russian ambassador in the White House. Sources in the US and Israeli intelligence communities who had to deal with the fallout.
- Chris2048 9y agoTheir names? on the record?
- foldr 9y agoThere are no names on the record for the Obama story either. Why would you expect there to be? Of course people are not going to go on the record talking about the content of private and highly sensitive meetings.
- Chris2048 9y agoNational Security Advisor H.R. McMaster: "The story that came out tonight is false. I was in the room. It didn’t happen."
- foldr 9y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/wp/2017/05/21/mcmaster-does-not-deny-details-of-trumps-discussion-with-russian-officials/?utm_term=.a647a5cd68f8 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/wp/2017/05/21/... "McMaster refused to reveal details of the conversation, which he said was privileged and confidential." http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/politics/ct-hr-mcmaster-trump-classified-information-denial-20170515-story.html http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/politics/ct-h... "McMaster says that 'at no time were intelligence sources or methods discussed.' But The Post's reporting doesn't say that they were. Instead, the report states clearly only that Trump discussed an Islamic State plot and the city where the plot was detected by an intelligence-gathering partner. Officials worried that this information could lead to the discovery of the methods and sources involved, but it didn't say Trump discussed them."
- Chris2048 9y ago> McMaster refused to reveal details of the conversation You don't get rewarded with verified information for publishing fake news. The burden is on the journalist to verify their sources' information. And if they can't, to not publish. The press manufacture loaded questions faster than the administration could answer them - but that's not their job. If you don't agree, then can you first tell everyone why they should listen to you considering you still haven't stopped beating you wife? [0] [0] according to official sources close to foldr. > Officials worried that.. Yet more insidious 'Officials'. So, returning to my original point: who has gone on record to say what Trump said? Presumably no one since anyone in a position to reveal such privileged information would be liable for doing so? So all "well he didn't deny it" double-speak and insinuation, from a press starved of information, and hence resorting to punitive speculation.
- foldr 9y agoNo-one is going to go on record regarding the contents of a private meeting between the US President and the Russian ambassador, and no-one has. It is pointless to keep asking this question.
- Chris2048 9y agoBut since you finally got round to it - then nothing the press has printed is verified.
- foldr 9y agoIt wouldn't be "verified" if people went on the record either. Going on the record isn't some kind of magical truth serum. People can lie on the record or off it.
- Chris2048 9y agoNo, but you could weigh the information against the source/context. You can lie off record much easier, since there is less likelihood of damage to reputation. That's a tangent anyway, if there is no verification, the only value a statement has is the authority and sincerity of the person who says it: we have neither that, nor do we even know the context (we have just the words, or interpreted statement - it's easy to cherry-pick those).
- Chris2048 9y ago> "Facts pertaining to terrorism and airline safety", in Trump's own words. Did Trump describe that information as classified?
- foldr 9y agoIf you look at the context of his statements, yes. He was asked if he leaked classified information and responded by defending his right to do that.
- Chris2048 9y agoNo, this is how it is reported. The context is a hostile press, which he snubs in general. Trump did not answer the question. Who asked Trump if he leaked classified information, in which interview? Anything specific? Or selective reporting? > He was asked if he leaked classified information and responded by defending his right to do that He was defending his right to [release] classified information? He does have that right, but: "I have the absolute right to [share] facts pertaining to terrorism and airline flight safety" I can't see the mention of "classified" in that particular statement. So to summarise; the press claimed Trump gave the Russians classified information - Trump nor McMaster has confirmed or denied this. The press heavily imply this means their original claims are right, but again, the burden is on the press to prove their original claim, by their original source; you don't just get that as a reward for making unverified claims. My original point is no one has gone on record to affirm it, it's just insinuation games.