3 ms·
I think society itself must change. It needs to be more inclusive and forgiving. Having a test implies a success/failure context. That alone is enough for certa
by ianai 10y ago
I think society itself must change. It needs to be more inclusive and forgiving. Having a test implies a success/failure context. That alone is enough for certain psyches to give up. If they perceive their "life as a failure" they won't even try for yet another test. Get rid of the tests.
Maybe ask kids what they want to study? We all know you get further with carrots than sticks.
As for income, who knows. Surely in a world where CEOs make in hours what average people make in a year there are compensation issues.
- appleflaxen 10y agoeverybody fails at something in life (if you don't, then you aren't reaching high enough). to teach (or demonstrate to) kids that the risk of failure means you should choose a different path is a terrible lesson.
- ianai 10y agoI agree.
- pavlov 10y agoThose Scandinavian school systems that have demonstrated good results (e.g. Finland in the PISA comparisons) have spent decades gradually de-emphasizing tests and grades. So I think you're right that the American system should seek to have less tests and especially less standardized tests, instead relying more on the pedagogical expertise of teachers. That will be hard to accomplish because it would require somehow implementing another element of the Scandinavian system: teachers have both high competency requirements and high motivation for the field.
- ianai 10y agoI think motivated teachers would come naturally to that system. Glad to hear there's a workable model.
- mafribe 10y agoAs a (university) teacher myself I feel it should be pointed out that teacher motivation strongly correlates to student quality/motivation. Teachers are humans too, with emotions and feelings, and if students treat us badly that's kind of difficult to ignore.
- mafribe 10y agoScandinavian school systems that have demonstrated good results [...] have spent decades gradually de-emphasizing tests and grades. The Asian systems that have demonstrated good results emphasize tests and grades heavily. What conclusion do we draw from this? One might wonder if different demographics do well with different forms of teaching.
- acjohnson55 10y agoIf by demographic, you mean ethnicity, I think that's dead wrong. But one thing you can say places like Finland and Korea do share is a deeply held cultural belief that everyone in the nation is in it together. What we lack is the same societal norm that it would be unacceptable for children in the suburbs to have all the advantages, while children in cities and rural areas tend to grow up in great disadvantage. Some say that our size and heterogeneity holds us back. I think that's bullshit. It's a cop out that's ultimately self-defeating for the whole nation. Lastly, I don't think it's simply arbitrary, whether we pick the Finnish or Korean models, despite the fact that they both appear to produce great results. I think the pressure culture of Korean education is deeply problematic, and Finnish success proves that you can generate well-educated children without forging them in a crucible.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoWould success in education be reflected in some national metric? Productivity perhaps? Here's a graph of 'productivity' country vs country. But it has no units ... not sure what to think. http://www.tradingeconomics.com/country-list/productivity http://www.tradingeconomics.com/country-list/productivity