3 ms·
The plant doesn’t give a hoot whether the ‘nitrate ion’ it eats comes from a bag of manufactured fertilizer or decomposing organic matter. - Norm Borlaug, inve
by rmason 10y ago
The plant doesn’t give a hoot whether the ‘nitrate ion’ it eats comes from a bag of manufactured fertilizer or decomposing organic matter.
- Norm Borlaug, inventor of the green revolution and winner of the 1970 Nobel Peace prize
- tpeo 10y agoThe issue with injecting nitrogen in the soil isn't about the nitrogen's source, but it's impact on the carbon content of the soil. >There has been some research showing that these high nitrogen inputs are destroying the carbon in the soil. Because the microbes use up the extra nitrogen and then they really tear the carbon out, creating lots of CO2, rather than sequestering it in the soil. So there is evidence that excessive nitrogen actually causes more carbon to leave the system. Whereas we need more carbon in the soil rather than less.
- legulere 10y agoThat's a gross oversimplification of the issue. By using mineral fertilizer you add a big load of nitrates to the soil at once instead of slowly decomposing nitrates bound in organic compounds. The plants can't absorb this ok at once. This leads to a run-off into the oceans and ground-water, and also polluted the atmosphere with nitrous oxide. Finally the soil biology is negatively impacted by this. If you consider phosphor mineral fertilizer you get the problem that you add heavy metals like cadmium and uranium to soil.
- dejv 10y agoWell, since 70s we learned a lot about the soil ecology. We can talk about N, which plant can't access directly. Roots have to produce different substances that are eaten by various organism in soil and they then break the N into form that could be accessed by plant. Commercial fertilisers give the plant N in form that could be consumed directly, so the plant is not motivated in producing compounds for rest of soil organisms. Once they are all dead the plant is reliant to those fertilisers. So this is, simplified version, of how plants gets N, but similar situations are with other compounds, especially K, which kinda change the structure of soil and basically lock it for other type of living organisms and nutrients.