5 ms·
Do ad blockers really solve the problems that this article criticizes AMP for? You've closed one bag of worms and opened another one. How can independent publis
by Buge 9y ago
Do ad blockers really solve the problems that this article criticizes AMP for? You've closed one bag of worms and opened another one. How can independent publishers live in an all adblock world? State publishers like criticized in the article might survive. You're again centralizing journalism, this time into the few organizations that can get their readers to pay a subscription.
- snakeanus 9y agoI think that the ones that will best survive in an ad-blocking world would be hobbyist journalists and bloggers. That does not seem to be that bad to be quite frank as it would probably lead to higher quality content, less copy-paste and less clickbaits.
- candiodari 9y agoNot really unfortunately. The ones that thrive are the ones not doing it for money. Propaganda, state and commercial, are by far the biggest ones.
- fastball 9y agoWhat the heck is a hobbyist journalist?
- sangnoir 9y ago> What the heck is a hobbyist journalist? Shills and Kool-aid-drinking zealots mostly - they are the ones usually motivated enough to do 'journalism' for free. Don't expect any professionalism, depth or any form of investigative journalismbeyond tweet-storms.
- marcus_holmes 9y agoMe. I run http://startupnews.com.au http://startupnews.com.au despite making no money doing it (as the plaintive pleas for sponsorship and donations on the site show). The Perth startup community needs it, so I run it. There's similar blogs for every small community, run by people who care about that community. Usually unfunded, and only covering stories of interest to that community.
- ageofwant 9y agoThey cannot. How can wagon wheel makers live in the age of the car? Their business model is defunct. We outsourced our opinions and fact-finding to journalists for a few hundred years. Now that time has past. Journalists themselves have destroyed their own industry by producing a poor quality product. Maybe in future journalists will re-invent themselves as purveyors of pure factual reporting, and those that care about that kind of thing will pay for it. But it is a niche market. Democracy, decency, enlightenment and society will suffer of course. But those things were never guaranteed with any kind of real safeguards.
- jorvi 9y agoThere's more to the world than the US. The press in, for example, The Netherlands and Finland might be opinionated but they're mostly factual and high quality.
- marcus_holmes 9y agoI wonder if the clickbait and fake news is an English-language phenomenon, because of the huge potential global market for English-language articles?
- tertius 9y ago> Maybe in future journalists will re-invent themselves as purveyors of pure factual reporting If you think this was ever the case, rose colored glasses are in effect.