3 ms·
> The major issue in "letting the humans try" in the AF447 incident is that the pilots did not have the angle-of-attack measurement shown to them. Yes, I agree
by pdonis 10y ago
> The major issue in "letting the humans try" in the AF447 incident is that the pilots did not have the angle-of-attack measurement shown to them.
Yes, I agree, but that's not a reason not to give the humans an override option. It's a reason to provide AOA data directly to the pilots. I am actually flabbergasted that that is not done, since, as you say, AOA is the most critical flight parameter.
> This design decision of hiding critical information from the humans (what AOA is, what the other pilot is doing with their stick) is what scares me most about fly-by-wire.
I agree 100%.
- zkms 10y agoSorry for my wording issues -- I wasn't making a statement about whether giving such an option is good or bad, I was trying to talk about what went wrong in that case when the humans had to take over. We both agree that the humans need to be provided critical data (including AOA) so when they need to take over, they have a proper set of information and aren't missing anything and don't need to reverse-engineer the AOA from the stall warning horn and the airspeed when the aircraft measures it in the first damn place!