3 ms·
Instead of spewing a incredibly short-sighted rhetoric that suggests people kill each other if they have a tribe, perhaps you should stop and think. Let me pos
by shakna 9y ago
Instead of spewing a incredibly short-sighted rhetoric that suggests people kill each other if they have a tribe, perhaps you should stop and think.
Let me pose it this way.
You were born a Native American, your tribe is your family, and your history. For all intents, yhey are a nation that raised you.
Around you are strangers. They come from a different nation.
They butchered your ancestors to steal what they had.
Yet, as is the way of your tribe, you try to be peaceful and considerate.
In response, some are kind to you. But, their leaders steal your water.
Not just sustinence, something special to the stories of your people.
You protest peacefully.
They react with violence.
How do you feel?
Tribes aren't something to give up. They're a part of you. Your history. Do you tell an Irishman to forget his kilt? An Englishman his Coat of Arms? Do you tell someone who's grandfather was a slave that its okay to be poor, because he's equal now?
The tribe is family, history, and nation. When your neighbour tried to sell your grandfather out for diamonds, there will be problems.
If anything, Africa shows us problems we ignore... And that with time and effort, relations can be improved. Sometimes it doesn't work. Bill kills Joe, because Joe bragged that his Da used to eat your family.
But forgetting who you are, isn't going to help.
- throwway390 9y agoWhere there's division, there's conflict. Ordered by number of conflicts, in decreasing amount: Tribes > Nation-states > Unions. There will be more wars when the European Union breaks up. Or when the US does. Conversely, Africa will greatly benefit from becoming more united in the same way the West has. This is now being reverted (see Trump, Brexit), so you just wait and see where that takes us.
- shakna 9y agoThere are thousands of tribes in Australia. Where is their civil war? It isn't as simple as you say, because a tribe is more than you seem to think it is. I can change my country, I cannot change my tribe. Having many tribes does not mean unity is impossible.
- throwway390 9y ago"The Australian Bureau of Statistics estimated the total resident Indigenous population to be 458,520 in June 2001 (2.4% of Australia's total)"[0] You're missing my point. There are no tribes in Australia, for practical purposes. Australia has moved past the concept of tribes. In Australia, people are born into Australia. In Africa, in 2017, people are born into a tribe. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indigenous_Australians https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indigenous_Australians
- shakna 9y ago> There are no tribes in Australia, for practical purposes. That is utter, utter crap. The Tiwi don't associate with the Kimberly kids. Their islands are closed to outsiders. You are given your totem at age of 12 in a smoking ceremony that outsiders are not permitted to witness. You are not born Australian. You cannot marry one. You are Tiwi.
- wordupmaking 9y ago> forgetting who you are You mean, like overwriting my actual life experiences with some sort of "narrative" that becomes more synthetic the more it becomes generalized and massaged? That's exactly what tribalism and group think are to me. "fools in old-style hats and coats, / Who half the time were soppy-stern / And half at one another’s throats" come to mind. > The tribe is family, history, and nation. It's funny though how as babies we start out mostly alike, and happily adopt a lot or even all of wherever we're put. History is kind of irrelevant if you don't actually tell it, it's a story. Yes, knowing why one's parents behaved the way they did is useful, but anything before that isn't really different from stories about other people. Interesting for their content, but with no super special connection to me, giving me identity or anything remotely like that. In so far as they affected me, in so far as I am a result of that chain, I can more accurately examine those current traces in my current me, simply find out who I am, in the flesh, not in dead words and thoughts. Now, don't get me started on "communities", beh. I know all of this sounds so anti-social, but it's not, I hate how the actual people let themselves be buried under essentially religious systems that will spew them out as quickly as they snatched them up.
- shakna 9y ago> experiences with some sort of "narrative" that becomes more synthetic the more it becomes generalized and massaged? We clearly have different thoughts on the matter, so I won't delve deeply here. But I would say the message becoming more generalised isn't what I've seen. Though, the tribes I was immersed with had deep story-telling practices, such as weaving and repeated communal retellings. Resulting in near word-for-word retellings some hundreds of years apart. The moral isn't explained or given. Its just history.
- throwway390 9y ago> the tribes I was immersed with You should have started off with that. There's no point in arguing with you if this is the case. You're too invested in them. This is fine. You're probably more correct that I am anyway, since you've experience on the ground. I'm just armchair quarterbacking.
- deleted 9y ago