4 ms·
I'm sick of people deciding that the problem with the internet is other people. The internet isn't "broken." The internet is the only mass communication and me
by krapp 10y ago
I'm sick of people deciding that the problem with the internet is other people.
The internet isn't "broken." The internet is the only mass communication and media paradigm which doesn't have to present a facade for the sake of commercial interests, but an honest, unfiltered glimpse at the zeitgeist. It's a mirror, an honest mirror. If we don't like what we see, it's because we had a naive understanding of what we are.
- weberc2 10y agoI agree. In particular, the NYT and other large media organizations seem to talk as though the internet became abruptly disharmonious during the election. It wouldn't be an NYT article of it didn't have "Trump supporters are evil" undertones. Our country isn't going to get better if we are constantly demonizing those with whom we disagree.
- elliotec 10y agoOur country isn't going to get better whether or not we continue to demonize these people, and I for one agree with the NYT that yes, they are evil.
- Kholo 10y agoI agree totally agree. This is the same org that told us Bush was right about WMDs, whose reporters didn't know what a CDO was when the financial collapse happened, and spent three years unable to believe Trump could win the election. This is why nytimes.com is pointing to 0.0.0.0 in my hosts file.
- disantlor 10y agowhat's an example of a trump supporters are evil? keep in mind that demonstrating that someone is uninformed, perhaps willfully, is not the same as evil.
- ethbro 10y ago> It's a mirror, an honest mirror. While I partially agree with you, I think there's a tendency of those (us) who work in a deterministic universe to under-attribute technology's ability to shade or shift pre-existing things. In the same way that propagation models matter in neural networks, the nuances of how the internet is consumed, shared, cross-linked, and presented all influence the zeitgeist that it creates. If HN had no moderation or anti-spamming code, our comment threads would look very different. Would that be a reflection of our truer selves? I say yes and no: it would reflect our opinions of the moment more accurately, but by virtue of altering the comment content on the site we would then make different comments to those comments. So an algorithm shifts our HN world, despite the fact that we remain the same people. (At least over the short term) And when it boils down to it, I refuse to live in a world where technology is impotent in reminding us of and appealing to our kinder, aspirational, better natures.
- gavinpc 10y agoThank you, this comment is uplifting and thought-provoking.
- mirimir 10y ago> If HN had no moderation or anti-spamming code, our comment threads would look very different. ... No argument there. > So an algorithm shifts our HN world, despite the fact that we remain the same people. (At least over the short term) Yes, over the short term. But longer term, HN's policies shape its user base. They select for people who prefer them, and against people who reject them. So anyway, I do believe that the Internet is an honest mirror. But I wouldn't want the sort of moderation that some countries impose or plan. Maybe people will eventually learn to use it responsibly. I'm not optimistic, however. It's just ongoing Eternal September.
- philhartmanonic 10y agoI think it's honest in the same sense as a poll with an inadvertently skewed sample. It's honest, but the scope of conclusions that can be justifiably drawn from it is limited. Without the internet, opportunities to be simultaneously social and anonymous are few and far between. Situations where you're also unencumbered by hard-wired social instincts (e.g. being able to say something without any reflexive responses to body language or the sound of someone's voice) are practically non-existent. Having the ability to socially express yourself with such a degree is good and bad, but it certainly isn't natural. One could say that this shows who we "really" are, but I don't know how anyone could argue that our social behavior while isolated from society is the truest definition of the character or the individual. Maybe you could, but absent a convincing argument I'm certainly not taking it as assumed.
- mirimir 10y agoYes, I am arguing that there are far too many sociopaths, and that only fear of consequences keeps them in line. Whether that's in meatspace, or online. But I do agree that the Internet provides more "opportunities to be simultaneously social and anonymous". Overall, that's a good thing, notwithstanding harassment. I worry far more about social control through targeted propaganda.
- cirgue 10y agoThe internet removes individual accountability for your beliefs and ideas, and very much influences the zeitgeist. It's not an honest mirror but a funhouse mirror, because it exacerbates not only genuinely held extreme views, but also the appearance that others hold extreme views.
- skybrian 10y agoYes it's tiresome, but it's not 1995 anymore. Other people are exactly why we can't have nice things. Spam, abuse, and fraud keep the feudal Internet in business - because nobody wants to do it themselves anymore.