6 ms·
Non paywalled article at https://www.macrumors.com/2017/05/18/apple-chinese-chat-apps-disable-tip-functions/ https://www.macrumors.com/2017/05/18/apple-chinese-
by pmontra 10y ago
Non paywalled article at https://www.macrumors.com/2017/05/18/apple-chinese-chat-apps-disable-tip-functions/ https://www.macrumors.com/2017/05/18/apple-chinese-chat-apps...
- MiddleEndian 10y agoAs a former MacRumors regular, I find it interesting to see that the even the Mac fans there are not in favor of Apple's decision, with a notable exception being a user who mentioned that without the app store, the apps would be nothing. WeChat is huge in China. It's used for everything. It's bigger than Apple's or Google's app stores. I expect (and hope for) Apple to lose this battle.
- addicted 10y agoMacRumor regulars have turned quite sour on Apple. Don't get me wrong. It's still a pro Apple site with a pro Apple fan base, but it has a very strong contingent of Mac fans, many of who've been around since well before OSX, who feel, justifiably, completely neglected by Apple. Despite the fact that one could make a strong argument that these Mac fans are the reason Apple existed long enough to even make the iPod in the first place.
- jeff_petersen 10y ago> Despite the fact that one could make a strong argument that these Mac fans are the reason Apple existed long enough to even make the iPod in the first place. There's an interesting pop poli-sci book called The Dictator's Handbook (which despite the name draws examples from corporations and small-town governments in addition to actual dictatorships) which examines how people come to power. It generally works out to keeping the "essential" group happy. At one point the users you mention were "essentials" but they have been supplanted by other users. Apple no longer needs to pander to them, so they don't.
- valuearb 10y agoNo one has time to post on MacRumors unless they are super pissed off. These posters are representative of little to nothing.
- stevehawk 10y agoI'm pretty sure the one guy that was on Apple's side misunderstood the issue. He seemed to think WeChat was taking the tips and not that it was a person to person transfer.
- cefstat 10y agoTwo things. First, it is really troubling if Apple wants to impose a tax on transactions between app users. Tipping is used often in China (for example, in the form of "red envelopes" at Chinese New Year) and a 30% cut for Apple is simply incomprehensible and downright immoral. Second, the day that WeChat gets out of the App Store is the day that Apple becomes irrelevant in China. If the story is true, I am afraid somebody at Apple has not thought this thing through.
- valuearb 10y agoApple doesn't charge for person to person transfers, or buying physical goods. They only charge if you are selling digital products (apps, features, content) through the App Store. Just those things that cost Apple to store and transfer.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- valuearb 10y ago"We don't charge anything as the platform, but Apple gets 30 percent for doing nothing," one of the executives reportedly fumed." Uh, Apple's servers hosted and distributed hundreds of millions of copies of your apps. For free. Apple is clearly doing the right thing here. They can't charge developers 30% to sell apps and content through their platform, then allow one developer to skirt the rule by calling it "tipping". Tencent can just man up and pay the thirty percent like the rest of us have to do.
- pmontra 10y agoThe difference is that if Tencent pulls WeChat from the appstore, Chinese people will (grudgingly) leave the iPhone for some Android model. They need WeChat more than any other app. Actually Tencent could ask Apple money for continuing their app on their platform.
- Oletros 10y ago> Apple is clearly doing the right thing here. They can't charge developers 30% to sell apps and content through their platform, then allow one developer to skirt the rule by calling it "tipping". Tencent can just man up and pay the thirty percent like the rest of us have to do. I think you're confused and you don't know what the case is about. By the way, I didn't knew that Apple Developer Program was free? Guess what it is included in the yearly price.
- valuearb 10y ago$99 a year is about as close to free as you can. And I know exactly what it's about. No one is getting "tips" without providing services or content through the app.
- Oletros 10y ago> And I know exactly what it's about. No one is getting "tips" without providing services or content through the app. So, you would be glad to pay 30% of your banking transactions to Apple, isn't? Because this case is exactly the same as Paypal, banking applications or booking applications