5 ms·
>Btw, by "wire" I just meant "a direct means of sending information". It doesn't have to be a mechanical wire and pulley. I'm just saying that there ought to be
by foldr 10y ago
>Btw, by "wire" I just meant "a direct means of sending information". It doesn't have to be a mechanical wire and pulley. I'm just saying that there ought to be a way of cutting out the flight computer's automated decision making and just letting the pilot's control inputs drive the control surfaces.
This exists already in Airbus aircraft (Direct Law).
- pdonis 10y ago> This exists already in Airbus aircraft (Direct Law). I can't tell from the article whether this mode was activated in the Quantas incident or not. It sounds like it was, but the article doesn't use precise terminology. The question I would have is, what happens to Direct Law if there is a computer crash? Could what is described in the article--pilot giving control input but plane not responding because computer is overriding it--happen under Direct Law? Could it happen under Direct Law if a computer crashed?
- foldr 10y ago>what happens to Direct Law if there is a computer crash? I'm not quite sure what you mean by this. Are you talking about the flight control computers? If all of the redundant flight computers crash then the plane won't be controllable, but that is incredibly unlikely. It is like asking what will happen if all of the hydraulic systems fail, or if one of the wings fall off. If one of the flight control computers crashes, then that is one way of triggering a switch from Normal Law to Alternate Law. >Could what is described in the article--pilot giving control input but plane not responding because computer is overriding it--happen under Direct Law? No. Under Direct Law the pilots inputs are directly translated to control surface deflections.
- pdonis 10y ago> Are you talking about the flight control computers? One out of three of them, yes. That's what happened in the Quantas flight. Would Direct Law still work under those conditions? > If one of the flight control computers crashes, then that is one way of triggering a switch from Normal Law to Alternate Law. Should that have happened in the Quantas flight described in the article? > Under Direct Law the pilots inputs are directly translated to control surface deflections. Hm. If that's true then the obvious thing for the pilots to do would have been to go into Direct Law mode, but I don't see that mentioned in the article.
- foldr 9y ago>One out of three of them, yes. That's what happened in the Quantas flight. Would Direct Law still work under those conditions? Yes, of course. I'm not sure what you're thinking is the alternative. If the aircraft stopped being controllable even under Direct Law when one of the flight control computers failed, then there wouldn't be any redundancy. >Should that have happened in the Quantas flight described in the article? No, because none of the flight control computers crashed. The issue was caused by bad sensor data. >Hm. If that's true then the obvious thing for the pilots to do would have been to go into Direct Law mode, but I don't see that mentioned in the article. It is not what they are trained to do, and probably isn't really a sensible response. Flying the aircraft without any protections isn't particularly safe either.
- pdonis 9y ago> none of the flight control computers crashed. The issue was caused by bad sensor data. I think you're confusing the Quantas flight with Air France 447. From the article on the Quantas flight, after the first dive: "One of the aircraft's three flight control primary computers – which pilots refer to as PRIMs – is faulty. They begin to reset it by flicking the on-off switch." And later: "After QF72's second dive, the number three flight control primary computer faults again."
- pdonis 9y ago> Flying the aircraft without any protections isn't particularly safe either. The plane was flying straight and level when the flight control computer crash caused the automatic control to start doing obviously wrong things. Going to Direct Law at that point would have allowed the pilot to reestablish straight and level flight while they figured things out. That seems like it would have been safer than what happened. If they weren't trained to do that, maybe their training needs to be changed.
- foldr 9y ago>Going to Direct Law at that point would have allowed the pilot to reestablish straight and level flight while they figured things out. That seems like it would have been safer than what happened. It may have been safer in this specific incident. The question is whether it would make things safer to tell pilots to switch to direct law whenever something occurs that they think might be due to a problem with the flight control computer. I suspect you would just see lots of accidents causes by the absence of the protections. It's worth noting that an Airbus has never had a fatal accident as the result of this kind of incident. So the correct response to is probably no response at all. It's easy to get fixated on these kinds of incidents because there's something terrifying about the idea of a crazy computer overruling the pilots, but the actual chance of a fatal accident is way lower than the chance of an accident caused by pilot error owing to an absence of protections. Thanks for the correction about the flight control computer. I'm not sure how reliable the technical info in the article is, though.