8 ms·
Windows 10 S Will Not Support the Linux Subsystem
- simooooo 10y agoHardly surprising
- unixhero 10y agoLet me guess "It's not secure."
- johncolanduoni 10y agoI really love the Windows 10 S page, which almost off the bat says "Microsoft Edge is your default browser since it’s more secure than Chrome or Firefox." with a footnote, referencing a study that focused on social engineering and phishing attacks.
- kevhito 10y agoThis is disingenuous. The report focuses on different browsers' ability to automatically detect and block URLs of phishing pages and malware downloads. All three browsers have some kind of automatic URL blocking, and this report claims that Edge is the best. At a glance, the results don't look immediately credible to me: I didn't see an explanation of how they chose the specific URLs, why there is a difference between the browsers, or the false-positive rate. But the study is, at least, actually comparing browser "security", and isn't comparing user behavior or anything like that. Disclosure: I've never used Edge.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoI didn't think that they were studying user behavior, but saying Edge has better security, full stop, based only on a study that only examines the URL blocking capabilities (and not e.g. protection from malicious JavaScript) is pretty silly.
- paco3346 10y agoI don't understand this decision. I get the argument that it's most likely developers who want the Linux Subsystem but as soon as you say that only some apps in the store work in 10 S you start the trail of platform fragmentation.
- akerro 10y agoEasy, MS loves Linux.* Too much loves turned into rape.
- blackoil 10y agotoo much love normally leads to sacrifice, you are confusing between love and lust.
- rbanffy 10y agoMicrosoft lusts for Linux. They want the attention Linux gets. They want the tooling Linux has. And they want the developers, before all of them switch to Linux or Mac. They desperately want developers to stay. They need it.
- pjmlp 10y agoYou are mixing developers with UNIX developers. There are many kinds of developers in the world, some of us dislike being mixed with UNIX developers all the time on HN.
- 0xFFC 10y agoDo you realize you can upgrade easily to full version of windows with a little bit of extra cost? It perfectly makes sense. S is kinda limited sandboxed version of Windows of only educational environment use.
- II2II 10y agoIt is worth noting that this is a subset of the educational environment. Primary and Secondary schools may find this of limited value due to existing licensing agreements. I used to work in a province which licensed much of the educational software used by public schools and first nations schools (and the scope of licensing ranged from school computers only, to teacher computers, to student computers). While this would probably be addressable with time, the transition would be a rough one. Post secondary education is also a mixed basket. The majority of students may get by with a restricted range of software, yet many departments depend upon specialized applications. This would create barriers for students regardless of whether the software is Windows native (but not approved in Microsoft's store) or Unix software that can run in WSL. While this isn't a huge issue for students with their own computers, who can upgrade to for the nominal price, it is likely going to create many issues for institutions.
- panzer_wyrm 10y agoAdmit it. You don't want people to load external code.
- ktta 10y agoIt has been explicitly mentioned by Microsoft that they don't wan't external code being run on Windows 10 S.
- nannal 10y agoTwo weeks post launch there will be jailbreaks. Happens every time.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 10y agoNot being able to run arbitrary external code is kind of the whole point when building a security-oriented system. You remove (not just hide or disable, but remove) everything that's not absolutely necessary, and the ideal result is a system that cannot run anything but a very small list of whitelisted binaries.
- jarym 10y agothat may be the 'ideal' result but judging by the number of 0-day exploits it will not be the reality. Even Apple let you side load apps onto an iOS device if you're a developer... Microsoft is definitely setting it up for a stumble (again) similar to WinRT.
- muterad_murilax 10y agoI guess if they really wanted to keep WSL, they could just "sandbox" it by disabling access to the Windows filesystem (that is, no /mnt/c and so on).
- johncolanduoni 10y agoThe linux subsystem is implemented via Windows kernel modules. "Just sandboxing" has proved to be a pretty hard problem for both kernels, so I'm pretty skeptical that simply removing /mnt/c would suddenly result in a reasonable secure system. Especially since the WSL code is quite young.
- safeharbourio 10y agoGotta love this. not exactly "embrace,extend,extinguish" but,well,ahem,cough
- johncolanduoni 10y agoRemoving WSL from Windows 10 S is going to extinguish Linux? And what was the extension?
- quickben 10y agoOffering it on cheap laptops?
- safeharbourio 10y agotrue. they (at msft) love linux nowadays, but only if you get a premium windows version..
- rbanffy 10y agoIt's not like you can't install Linux on low-end Windows laptops. The machine I take to hackathons is a very light, very cheap, very replaceable Asus that came with Windows 8. The next one will probably come with Windows 10 S and never actually boot into it (like the Windows 8 before it).
- quickben 10y agoYou can, it's very easy. That's probably why 10S is there, to stopgap chunk of the population before they see how easy it is. Was your first laptop a cheap 10S? or chrome? or did you install it yourself on a thinkpad? It's all marketshare with them.
- rbanffy 10y agoIt's probably harder to install Linux on a Chromebook than on a 10S laptop.
- Kenji 10y agoI hate the fact how Windows S is shaping up to be a completely walled garden. Not even CMD and Powershell?? I hope they still spend enough time on actual versions of Windows which are used by power users.
- nannal 10y agoBut all the power users left at either 8 or 10
- Kenji 10y agoI didn't leave yet. I think Windows is fine. Runs pretty stable. In the last decade, I had like 2 bluescreens on windows, and one was caused by accidentally bumping really hard into my PC, causing a kernel panic because of a voltage drop, and the other was a broken driver. Linux still has a long way to go when it comes to UI, drivers and video games.
- quickben 10y agoYMMV. Across several of my phones, my Linux servers and my Windows desktops; My desktops seems to be 'recovering from graphic card crashed' once every few weeks. It also depends how you count. Numerically, the games produced for Android far outnumber the AAA titles.
- Kenji 10y agoI'm not gonna lie, I think most Android games are very bad and give 1 hour of enjoyment at the most. Gaming on a touch screen is some of the worst UX you can have imho.
- quickben 10y agoOh I agree with you on that one. They are stable games, just not on the production level with your average PC game. About the UX, not sure if it's just me, but I want more character or object control when playing a game. I guess I have played on a keyboard+mouse for far too long. Phones/consoles just don't have the same level of satisfaction for me.
- emsy 10y agoThis is like Surface RT all over again.
- rbanffy 10y agoI hope it's at least possible to install something else on them... It's a shame the Surface RT didn't allow that.
- std_throwaway 10y agoIt's a Pro feature and Microsoft tends to ship a lean distribution tailored to the customers needs in order to provide superior user experience.
- quickben 10y agoThe user experience gets better with more options. A 'superiour' user experience implies lots of options. I.e. luxury car with all the gadgets, etc. A stripped down application, void of options, doesn't provide a 'superiour user experience's. If anything it provides cheap entry model.
- rbanffy 10y ago> The user experience gets better with more options. Not really. Better UX comes from better options, not more, poorly thought out ones. The options available fit the purpose of the device. A luxury car has features tailored for comfort. A real luxury car focuses on the back seat. A sports car has featured tailored for "feeling" and controlling the car. Having more options brings a superior experience only if your goal is to do multiple things, some never done before, sometimes in unexpected ways. Sometimes you use `sed`, others `awk` and there are days `cut` will cut it.
- quickben 10y agoI'll only partially agree to that. In the segment of operating systems, windows differentiated and promoted 'home' 'pro' 'ultimate' , etc. They already paved the terminology and more importantly trained the users to expect it. Many users after, got really annoyed with Windows 7 ultimate being upgraded to only win 10 pro. So in the case of Microsoft Windows, superior means something different than Apples IOS where superior means less (removing of the physical escape key, audio ports etc).
- rbanffy 10y agoApple is a great example of a "luxury computer". Their machines are solid, have decent battery life and don't bother with gimmicks like touchscreens which bring ambiguity to the UI (tooltip shows when you hover, but you can't do that via the touchscreen, only by dragging a pointer through a trackpad - argh). Their most recent bold move was the touchbar, that brought in fingerprint scanning and set of soft keys (esc included) that vary according to the task you are trying to accomplish. The lack of a physical esc key doesn't bother me at all.
- _pmf_ 10y agoBackpedaling is Microsoft's favorite pastime. Promise a huge convergence in platform support, alienate a lot of developers in the process, then artificially refragment it again.
- ryukafalz 10y ago>But the Windows Subsystem for Linux is very specifically targeted at developers, who should be using Windows 10 Pro. And because of the way it’s implemented, it’s almost certainly not in keeping with the reliability, performance, and battery life advantages of Windows 10 S. The stratification of users like this always irritates me. I don't think "developers" should be a special class of users; today's curious kids are tomorrow's developers! But if you lock them out of their own systems, they won't even have a chance to get started.
- jackmott 10y agokids who get these in schools will never get to tinker. this whole trend is a tragedy
- hdhzy 10y agoI agree. Most consumer electronics (phone and tablets) are non developer friendly - you cannot develop anything on them. I find this quote by Russell Kirchner to be really good: > They’re trying to get everyone to use iPads and when people use iPads they end up just using technology to consume things instead of making things From https://impossiblehq.com/an-unexpected-ass-kicking/ https://impossiblehq.com/an-unexpected-ass-kicking/ There is also interesting observation made by Cal Newport in his book Deep Work [1] that teaching kids how to use iPads is counterintuitive as they - consumer products - are designed to be super easy to use and one should rather learn how to master hard things (e.g. programming). [1]: http://calnewport.com/books/deep-work/ http://calnewport.com/books/deep-work/
- rbanffy 10y agoContrast that with an Apple II or a Commodore 64. You turn it on and you are inside a REPL in less than a second.
- ryukafalz 10y agoAs someone who didn't grow up with systems like that, I really wish I had. I was never really introduced to programming until high school, but I feel like I would've loved it at a younger age. GUIs are nice in many ways, but in general they seem to encourage consumption much more than they do creation. I feel like there has to be some way to build a GUI with the same kind of expressiveness as those early PCs, but I don't know how.
- pvdebbe 10y agoMy workplace Windows 10 Pro doesn't support it either. I use cygwin and VM's so I haven't bothered to ask our IT about it.
- rbanffy 10y agoCygwin was the way to have a Unix-like environment on Windows before the Linux subsystem existed. Is Cygwin available in the Windows app store?
- davidgerard 10y ago> Cygwin was the way to have a Unix-like environment on Windows before the Linux subsystem existed. Still is. See LibreOffice's first attempt to build using WSL instead of Cygwin: https://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/libreoffice/2017-April/077558.html https://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/libreoffice/2017-Apri... I'm still entirely unconvinced WSL replaces Cygwin for what Cygwin does and is useful for.
- tkubacki 10y agoI don't get why developers even bother - just don't use Windows as dev OS - if you really need windows use it in VirtualBox - I spent years as .NET dev on Linux desktop that way. Recently tried otherwise with docker for windows and one day after some magical windows update HyperV just killed my docker VM. For me Windows is just not reliable enough to be dev machine primary OS - it's not worth my time.
- ghshephard 10y agoI've used (and loved) VMware Workstation and Virtual Box, but WSL is a whole new level of awesome. There is something about the pureness of it's integration with windows (well, since creators update) that just makes it a joy to use as a client OS. Now, you still need virtualization for a ServerOS - WSL is all running under Bash.exe, so when that exits - everything is gone. But, for client OS - It's the bomb.
- skynode 10y agoWSL is the best thing since peanut butter. Recently moved all of my dev command line work to the Subsystem. Even better, VS Code integrates it perfectly well.
- ams6110 10y agoIs it really any better than cygwin? Cygwin was the first thing I installed on a Windows machine, going back well over a decade. It did a fine job running bash and all the utility and X11 apps that I cared to use.
- ghshephard 10y agoTons better (I say this as a dedicated Cygwin user since at least 2003). Cygwin, bash, and tmux are the first three things I install on any windows system, but with Cygwin, you are limited to whatever Cygwin has repackaged for you. With WSL, 95% of the stuff in Ubuntu is just an "apt-get install" away. Only stuff that relies on special network access, or /proc and other system directories seems to have issues, and they are quickly working away on that. (Serial Support just landed). And now that they are planning on supporting Fedora, Suse, and Ubuntu environments, I can yum install, or just drop in-place any of the Redhat binaries as well. That's the big difference - I don't need cygwin compiled apps anymore - I just drop in the Linux variants and I am good to go.
- dingo_bat 10y agoI don't see any justification to use win 10s on any system for any reason. It's inferior in every way. Why does it exist?
- Sanddancer 10y agoIt's targeting the chromebook market of a curated marketplace for apps.
- dingo_bat 10y agoTo be honest I have the same opinion about Chromebooks ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 10y agoChromebooks have the advantage of keeping state in the cloud. The other day I started editing a document at the office on my desktop and finished it on the train back home. No need to even think where the document was - it's always available no matter the device I'm on. Office 365 is kind of the same, I know. We can think of these machines as Office 365 clients just as much as we can think of Chromebooks as Google clients. But, at least for Chromebooks, you can seamlessly add a fully functional Linux environment.
- T-A 10y agoTo create a captive audience for the Windows Store, so desktop developers decide it's worth their time to make UWP apps.
- Kuraj 10y agoOr to put their win32 app in the Windows Store using the Desktop Bridge (a.k.a. Project Centennial)
- 10y ago
- GlobalServices 10y agoNobody here complains about Apple's OSX vs iOS, where iOS has no shell
- ghshephard 10y agoiOS is a companion device. Except for Federico Viticci, anybody technical has a Linux/Windows/MacOS system to go along with their tablet.
- deno 10y agoPeople using Apple have the mentality of slaves. Of course no one complains.
- rbanffy 10y agoFor a good reason. iOS is not marketed as "macOS for beginners" and doesn't run Mac App Store software.
- GlobalServices 10y agoIt isn't? I'm pretty sure that's exactly how the new iPad Pro with keyboard is marketed.
- blipmusic 10y agoDo you want me to? :) Every single time I fire up Pythonista on an iOS device I soon realise that any meaningful coding I do requires access to external data. And then I give up, until next time some years down the line.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- blackoil 10y agoThis shouldn't be surprising, as 10S is meant to compete with Chromebook/iOS devices, where system is completely locked and you can install apps only approved gateways. This may not be an ideal system for people here, but schools love this and also makes good for home systems by non-technical users. Lesser chances of Virus/Worms, corrupted settings, easy to refresh. Enabling a backdoor to it, would have defeated the purpose
- yellowapple 10y agoTo clarify: Chromebooks are (last I checked) unlockable.
- Lordarminius 10y agoWindows has outlived it's usefulness for everything but games and office apps.
- baconizer 10y agoOne of the fun thing to do on ChromeOS is crouton, which opens door to full blown Linux applications, now before you accuse me of 'pro'/developer user, my 12 year old nephew has more Linux software under crouton with his Chromebook than I do.
- happy-go-lucky 10y agoHere’s the blog post linked in the article. https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/commandline/2017/05/18/will-linux-distros-run-on-windows-10-s/ https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/commandline/2017/05/18/will... > Windows 10 S is not well-suited for many app developers/hackers, admins & IT pro’s! > If you want to run all your dev tools, distros, shells, etc. on a machine running Windows 10 S – like the sweeet new Surface Laptop – then upgrade it to full Windows 10. You’ll then be able to run Linux distro’s, Cmd/PowerShell, install dev tools, debuggers, profilers, packet sniffers, etc. That sums it up.