5 ms·
Schneier on Filming the Police
- jamesbressi 16y agoWho watches the watchers? I see an article about this come up every couple months and I find it plain frightening. Funny how some defend laws and privacy by saying "well if you aren't doing anything wrong, you shouldn't worry about it." but the same is not true for those who serve and protect? Privacy is your right and so is protecting your rights. If it's in public, well, it's not private! And if you are using something as an insurance of protecting or monitoring the governing of your rights, well it is unjust to make that illegal.
- dejb 16y ago> You can think of your existing power as the exponent in an equation that determines the value, to you, of more information. The more power you have, the more additional power you derive from the new data. so P = (i + I) ^ p where p = previous level of power i = old level of information I = new additional information P = new level of power Is that right? How does this even make sense? Does this work out to be a super exponential function? Lets try some numbers Starting out with power = 2, information = 2 and sequentially increasing i by 1 gives (2+1)^2 = 9, (3+1)^9 = 262144 (4+1)^262144 = some really big number You get the idea. Also note that if you drip feed yourself the information in smaller increments (say 0.1) then your power grows much faster. By this reckoning it is amazing that some entity hasn't already irrevocably taken control of the entire world. You can see how ones perspective would be pretty messed up if you thought the relationship was actually like this. Gives me new insight into the thinking of Schneier.
- dejb 16y agoSeriously nobody else can see that this blows a gapping whole in his reasoning in the second part of the article? This is the mental model he is using to argue that sharing information leads to a massive increase in power imbalances and is therefore too risky. That little brother can never really win against big brother in a world of increasing information.
- ck2 16y agoYou do understand that even if it's made perfectly legal by the supreme court, cops will find some other excuse, valid or not, to arrest you for taking a photo/video of them. There's zero punishment to them for abusing authority - I mean they can even shoot/kill someone and often get away with it, including receiving pay while not working or being on trial. Citizen review boards with full authority to punish/fire cops are the only answer.
- mattw 16y agoI agree that it certainly should be legal to record public servants in their duties, but let's get a grip here. There's zero punishment to them for abusing authority - I mean they can even shoot/kill someone and often get away with it, including receiving pay while not working or being on trial. This is an absurd statement. Officers are held to a much higher standard of conduct than you or I. They're also placed into situations demanding much greater responsibility than you or I, and under far greater pressures than you or I face. They make bad calls and mistakes just like anyone else, but by and large they are held accountable for these mistakes. Departments vary, but in my area the bar is very high. Citizen review boards with full authority to punish/fire cops are the only answer. These exist. They're called, broadly, "the judicial branch", or in practice, "courts". They're not run by the police.
- cynicalkane 16y agoGosh, it's almost as though the standards of police conduct and the typical quality of police officers vary from place to place.
- chc 16y agoI don't know where you live, but in the US it's quite common for police officers to be held to a lower standard. I have relatives on the force, and if they're speeding and get pulled over, the arresting officer will let them go. Similarly, a cop can force you to pull over and stop what you're doing for any reason at all and even physically abuse you if you are even slightly uncooperative, but interrupting or resisting a cop will get you arrested, and you're out of your mind if you expect a police officer to be as accommodating to you as you must be to them. You can't even hold a cell phone in their presence. If you want to assert that they are held to a higher standard, I would like you to support that assertion.
- Anechoic 16y agoOnce again: it it perfectly legal to audio and video record in officer in MA as long as the officer knows you're going it (and presuming that the act of recording doesn't interfere with the officer's duties). You can videotape (without audio) an officer (or anyone) without their knowledge, but you cannot audio record an officer (or anyone) without their knowledge. In any case, you do not need consent, that just have to be notified that the recording is taking place. Yes, Simon Glik was arrested but the charges were dismissed. The applicable law is here: http://www.mass.gov/legis/laws/mgl/272-99.htm http://www.mass.gov/legis/laws/mgl/272-99.htm
- ciupicri 16y agoWhat's the so special about audio recording compared to video recording? Also, if the video recording is good, someone could do lip reading.
- Anechoic 16y agoAs I understand it, it's just an old MA law that was implemented in the 1960's (or early 1970's) audio recording was commonplace but video recording was not, and was never updated to account for video recording. The other issue with making secret video recordings is it's use in security applications.
- alextp 16y agoProbably this has something to do with wiretapping telephones or something like that.
- evgen 16y agoBasically, audio recording is older tech and therefore has been around long enough and has been abused often enough to have specific laws drafted. The vast majority of the wiretapping laws and regulations about recording various events in public and private are explicit about how they apply to any and all forms of audio recording.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoUltimately technology will make any attempts at preventing the video recording of police in public completely futile. In another few years nearly everyone will have phones capable of recording hi-def video and streaming it to the internet live. At that point it's Canute vs. the tide.
- mooneater 16y agoThough I agree with what Bruce is saying, I thought he did a very poor job of presenting his argument in a compelling way. Who would ever change their mind on this issue based on that example? There's got to be a better way to convey it.