3 ms·
Is there a site somewhere that attempts to catalog 1) instances where the flight computer prevented an incident due to pilot error 2) instances where the flig
by wahern 10y ago
Is there a site somewhere that attempts to catalog
1) instances where the flight computer prevented an incident due to pilot error
2) instances where the flight computer caused an incident
I understand it's not always (if ever) so black & white, and I'm sure there's a better way to break things down. But it'd be interesting to read something that attempts to keep some kind of score.
- colechristensen 10y agoIt's a question that can't really be answered. It's sort of like asking about 1) instances where your alarm clock prevented you from being late to work 2) instances where your alarm clock failed to wake you up How could you possibly determine how often your alarm clock prevented you from being late? You can certainly tell how often it fails to do it's job, but you can't determine how often it's success is necessary because there aren't any near misses to detect. With no control group there can be no comparison. You could count incidents which the flight computer is helpful, but you cannot count incidents that never happened in the first place because of the flight computer.
- wahern 10y agoOTOH, Airbus and Boeing use different systems. Some alarm clocks kick you out of bed, shower you, and drive you to work. Other alarm clocks just pull the covers off and poor cold water on you, but still require you to do the rest. So you could analyze instances where the latter proved insufficient and try to guess whether the former would have been sufficient. The bigger problem is probably that there just aren't enough useful extreme incidents to be draw any conclusions. Or maybe there are. That's why I'm most curious if anybody has even tried. All I ever hear is that air safety has increased along with an increase in computerization. But that tells me very little. Everything about the aircraft and its ground support has been getting better, not to mention the training of the humans.