3 ms·
It can be just as simple in Japanese as in English, and just as complex. They refer to ways of being implicit + grammatically encoded social deixis, which Japan
by blipmusic 9y ago
It can be just as simple in Japanese as in English, and just as complex. They refer to ways of being implicit + grammatically encoded social deixis, which Japanese is good at (not exclusive to Japanese, though). Grammatically it's quite covert.
But on the whole, no. Just no. I think what's said in the article on this is bullshit. As for wa/ga, one can not necessarily replace the other, so you'd lose a few permutations on that alone. Also, there are more personal pronouns to choose from if that's the game.
I also did not know that just because speech level is grammatically encoded in Japanese, one is not allowed to generate similar meaning in other languages.
Or rather: I'm sure I can find 248,026 ways to say "I love you" in some other language as well.
What is it with Japanese that triggers this kind of ignorance and Sapir-Whorf-ism...?