9 ms·
Ok, honestly, was DNT ever more than a smoke grenade for muddying the privacy discussion? The standard always relied on every single shady data collector out th
by xg15 10y ago
Ok, honestly, was DNT ever more than a smoke grenade for muddying the privacy discussion? The standard always relied on every single shady data collector out there to act against their core interest, facing not even the risk of detection (let alone punishment) if they don't comply, all just because you asked them nicely. You might as well carry a "do not rob me" card in your wallet.
Was there ever a honest belief by anyone (except the Ayn Rand fanboys) this could work?
- Skunkleton 10y agoIt certainly isn't a complete solution, but it probably did reduce the number of ad networks that tracked you. So yes, I guess you could say it works?
- EpicEng 10y ago"probably" doesn't lead to "yes, it works". What's the tradeoff? How many good actors does "probably" imply?
- cmdrfred 10y agoChemotherapy will probably cure your cancer but since it isn't 100% effective you'd decline?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- EpicEng 10y agowell, that's not what I said either, so bad on you for the false analogy. Staying in line with my actual argument and using your analogy; what is the success rate of chemo? This is absolutely a main driver in the treatment decision making process. 5%? Nah, I'll pass; I don't want to spend my last six months in agony, so it's not worth it (i.e., bad trade-off). 95%? Hell yes, sign me up. Your own analogy supports what I said earlier. On a side note, the statement "Chemotherapy will probably cure your cancer" is also not true and shows a bit of ignorance re cancer therapies in general.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Skunkleton 10y agoOk, say you are tracked by google, facebook, adzerk, and twitter. If you set DNT, you are now only tracked by google, facebook, and twitter. Yeah, it was pretty much pointless, but you are being tracked by one less network, so it worked to some extent. It is trash, but at least it is something.
- EpicEng 10y ago>"...pointless", "it's trash..." Compelling arguments in favor.
- jasonkostempski 10y agoAnyone that would check that box would have a tracking blocker installed anyway.
- Skunkleton 10y agoI don't think anyone here is saying it is a great solution. There are plenty of people without Ad blockers that have it checked though, see Internet Explorer users.
- ilogik 10y agoI work in advertising,and we do respect dnt
- omginternets 10y agoOh well in that case I'm no longer concerned /s
- lucb1e 10y agoPosted 1 minute ago and already downvoted. I think it's a valid remark (even if it's sarcastic/cynical): the parent could have given some more information about why it is so, rather than just stating what any representative of such a company would say as well.
- omginternets 10y agoIt's hardly a valid point because (a) nobody in their right mind would take his word for it and (b) even if what he said were demonstrably true, that would just mean he doesn't work for a scummy company. His comment in no way responds to the main argument, here, which is that there exist many scummy companies who ignore DNT.
- vec 10y agoSo if I set the DNT flag on my browser, your advertising network will neither set any cookies nor serve me any beacons or tracking pixels nor collect any other analytics data from me whatsoever? Can I or a neutral third party audit your internal database to verify that my browsing history is not being recorded by you? Do you provide a list of all third parties with which you share information with so I can attempt to audit them as well? What dispute resolution procedures do you support if I have reason to believe that you do, in fact, hold some of my personal information despite my express request? How would you respond to a request to purge an individual's records from your logs? -------------------------------------------------------- I don't mean to put you, personally, on the spot. I'm sure your firm is perfectly ethical, and that you do listen for and take some action to honor DNT requests as far as you see fit. I'm also sure that were I at an advertising firm I wouldn't have any better policies. It's not your fault this is a stupid feature. That said, to almost anyone outside the webdev community "Do Not Track" doesn't mean, "Track, but Anonymize" or "Track, but Don't Personalize", it means "Don't Create A Record I Was Here". I've yet to run across a single company, advertising or otherwise, that interprets it that way, though.
- jasonkostempski 10y agoI'm very conscious of tracking and I've never bothered to check that box. It doesn't do what it's supposed to and adds another data point for fingerprinting. This and that cookie notification thing should just go away.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- djrogers 10y agoIt's a data point for fingerprinting wether you have it on or not. The only way to avoid that would be to randomize it's value.
- taejo 10y agoSince more people have it off than on, the information content of leaving it off is much less than turning it on.
- jasonkostempski 10y agoI know that :) I was saying there's now a new standard who's only useful functionality is to increase finger printing data points.
- qb45 10y agoWhat's up with this "Ayn Rand fanboys" meme? I keep seeing this recently and this time I can't even imagine how it could be relevant.
- quakeguy 10y agoIDK really, but i found this article lately: https://www.salon.com/2016/12/14/fountainhead-of-bad-ideas-ayn-rands-fanboys-take-the-reins-of-power/ https://www.salon.com/2016/12/14/fountainhead-of-bad-ideas-a... Make your own conclusions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rbg246 10y agoI'm not sure one one can make their 'own' conclusions from reading that article it was clearly biased towards reaching the conclusion that Ayn Rand was a writer for 'juveniles' which I don't think is a fair appraisal. I mean I don't agree with her conclusions on the world but I would say the world she has created in her novels are at a higher level than juvenile reading.
- qb45 10y agoWhy, I enjoyed this article, particularly the part about rape and the end: I seriously doubt that Donald Trump is really a fan of Ayn Rand. Her books may be juvenile and shallow, but they’re way too deep for him. Make your own conclusions, indeed. Heather Digby Parton, also known as "Digby," is a contributing writer to Salon. She was the winner of the 2014 Hillman Prize for Opinion and Analysis Journalism. Um, I only hope they don't give awards for that.
- problems 10y agoSalon is a very left-wing site, heavily opinion-based. You get about the same kind of thing when looking at opinion sites from any part of the political spectrum. It's glorified trash talking really.
- csydas 10y agoI don't think it was ever meant to be a comprehensive solution; it was meant as a start to address the rampant issue of tracking. There wasn't a mechanism short of outright blocking for a user to declare intent. The argument has always spiraled around what is the agreement between a user and a site they visit. Implicit agreements, revenue models, etc, but it's always been a unidirectional communication; the website tells the user, after the fact, what the terms and conditions are. Do Not Track was an attempt to give users a voice and the overwhelming response to it by the trackers was to ignore it. DoNotTrack wasn't an effective anti-tracking solution, but for every opt-in, it was a clear message from users. It's why Microsoft's auto-opt in, while probably well meaning, really screwed the whole thing. It had to be a choice. It was a message, and it's still a very strong argument when it comes to the discussion about dishonesty among trackers and advertising networks.
- sangnoir 10y ago> It's why Microsoft's auto-opt in, while probably well meaning... I might be overly cynical, but I think that was pure covert corporate warfare on Microsoft's part: it could reduce Google's income and was good PR.
- lloeki 10y agoEver seen those "here we'll be setting cookies because we're going to track you if you agree (agree/fuck off)" in Europe? A EU directive or something of the best intent mandates that when you're tracking someone beyond technical needs this boilerplate is required before setting a cookie. Guess what if you disagree there's no way to store the user's answer, so the box keeps popping up, forever nagging the privacy conscious. DNT would have solved that so nicely! Header set, no box, easy peasy. Except the difference between theory and practice is that they're the same (in theory). So boxes keep popping up even from good actors.
- jasonkostempski 10y agoThe best solution would be to remove the real problem which is the useless law.
- slau 10y agoAs far as I recall, the EU cookie law is a bit more global than that: a website needs to get permission/consent whenever it wants to store/retrieve information from the visitor's browser---this isn't just limited to tracking. This means that every single website hosted in Europe/targeted at a European audience need to request the authorisation to use the user's browser storage. A number of websites formulate this as "By continuing to use this website, you agree that we will access your cookies," accompanied with a "Dismiss" button, but that's not really what the spirit of the law is. DNT didn't change anything to this, as it was meant for a completely different use. I'd even say using DNT for this is a complete hack, which sort of misses the point of both the cookie law and DNT. You are, however, completely right that it is stupid beyond ridicule that you technically can't store the fact that a user doesn't want cookies on the browser. Edit: paragraph formatting.
- detaro 10y agoNot all information, only those that are not strictly necessary to provide the service (so e.g. a basic session cookie created once a user logs in or starts using the shopping cart, ... should not require consent)
- eli 10y agoI think most companies make an honest effort to abide by their own Privacy Policies. Google might listen to DNT, or it might ignore DNT, but I don't think they'd ever pretend to listen to DNT and then do something different. They'd get sued for sure.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nikcub 10y ago> Was there ever a honest belief by anyone (except the Ayn Rand fanboys) this could work? On the contrary, it was (generally) those in favor of government-mandated privacy and security who heavily supported the DNT efforts. The "Ayn Rand fanboys" just told people to install uBlock Origin