3 ms·
It just so happens there's no real reasons to use AAC over OPUS.
by snvzz 10y ago
It just so happens there's no real reasons to use AAC over OPUS.
- tpush 10y agoApple's devices have no support for OPUS(or Vorbis, or VP8/9).
- snvzz 10y agoApple's part of the group pushing AAC. They do of course deliberate sabotage open codec efforts.
- errantspark 10y agoThere's few real reasons to use anything other than MP3 for audio files. I don't care about having DRM, or conserving bandwidth/space by encoding things at low bitrates. I just care that my music/sound recording will work everywhere. The arguments people make for more "advanced" codecs are mostly completely spurious especially now that MP3 is patent-free. I'm probably just crazy though, after all I still use wired internet whenever possible. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
- phoboslab 10y agoAlmost true. Even Microsoft's Edge supports Opus now, but Safari still does not.
- agumonkey 10y agochicken and egg, without people using opus, safari users will never notice Safari not supporting it.
- carlos22 10y agoBetter then mp3 and embedded devices (e.g. cars) almost never have support for opus (or even ogg)...
- raverbashing 10y agoGet a library for a low-powered device that supports OPUS
- leni536 10y agohttps://www.rockbox.org/wiki/SoundCodecs https://www.rockbox.org/wiki/SoundCodecs
- AstralStorm 10y agoAnd support is available in new Android versions (since 5.0). The harder task would be to get an ASIC that accelerates decoding. Know of any?
- simias 10y agoIs ASIC audio decoding really common these days? I assumed it would be handled on "general purpose" DSPs most of the time, not hardwired ASICs. Audio decoding is really not a challenging task nowadays in my experience, when your average "embedded" processor runs at hundreds of MHz. There's still power consumption to factor in but that's never really been a limiting factor for me in the past decade at least. Maybe I've just been spoiled with powerful SoCs.
- raverbashing 10y agoThat's the main issue ;) Either an ASIC or that uses HW Accel in the processor And yes, the industry is stupid in standardizing in proprietary formats
- Veratyr 10y agoAAC has widespread support, Opus does not. Unless you know what you're doing (have to use the Ogg container and a .ogg extension and use Android >= 6.0), you can't fill an Android device with Opus files and play them back like you can AAC or MP3. I don't believe you can play them back at all on iOS. Mobile devices also often have a hardware codec that allows them to save on battery somewhat, when playing other codecs. Plus desktop support is limited. Browsers support it but widespread desktop apps like iTunes generally don't.