10 ms·
The Circus Leaves Town: Ringling Bros and Barnum and Bailey Circus to Close
- croon 10y agoGood riddance. I've never liked the circus. 1) I know it's very individual, but when it comes to the arts (as opposed to work), I've always liked soulful performance over replicability. I'd rather take Bob Dylans or Tom Waits terrible singing (while excellent songwriting), over kick-ass scales and guitar riffs of Dreamtheater (the circus in this scenario). While I can appreciate the skill behind Yngwe Malmsteens playing (or more current examples), or doing flips 20 feet in the air between hanging in rings, it's not something I enjoy watching/hearing. 2) Clowns are creepy, and I don't like slapstick. 3) The concept of the circus is 250 years old (in its modern form), and just in the last 10 years you can see more impressive feats on youtube (or some street corners), where everyone can get a venue. 4) Animal cruelty. TLDR; It's antiquated and serves no purpose anymore (IMHO).
- narrator 10y agoCirque de Soleil is still around, but they cater to people who want a classy, but more kid friendly, and arguably more consistently entertaining alternative to theater.
- croon 10y agoYeah, they're not for me either, but at least they're trying to evolve the concepts.
- Allower 10y agoand CdS is retarded as well. waste of fucking money.
- baldfat 10y agoMore kid friendly? I would say the opposite they are more adult friendly then Ringling. Also Glob Trotters, Disney on Ice and Marvel Live have taken over and owned by the same company.
- narrator 10y agoMore kid friendly and consistently entertaining than theater, not Ringling. I say more consistently entertaining, because you never know what you're going to get with theater. .
- baldfat 10y agoTheater is NEVER kid friendly unless it is Barney Live. Even the High School Productions are kind of over the top for my taste. The last one I saw and I knew better was "Rent" for High School. Then the next year was "Chicago".
- Matachines 10y agoNice blog post.
- LordKano 10y agoThe only purpose it ever served was entertainment. Now, without one of the biggest draws, people aren't going. On one hand, I'm happy to hear that they'll no longer be mistreating animals but on the other hand, let's not pretend that those of us who wear fur or leather or eat meat are somehow less responsible for animal cruelty.
- 13of40 10y agoI believe that someone who eats chicken is less cruel than someone who enslaves and tortures an elephant for several decades.
- kingkawn 10y agoThe world consumes 50 billion chickens a year.
- 13of40 10y agoChickens are stupid and we try not to torture them. Elephants are smart and we steal them from their mothers, chain them up, break their spirits, beat them, etc. Don't Tell me you can't see any difference.
- chris_wot 10y agoChickens aren't really stupid.
- irrational 10y agoYou've obviously never spent any time around chickens. They are not stupid by any means. They are able to solve problems, they are social, they have individual personalities.
- blincoln 10y agoHave you ever seen how chickens are raised for mass-scale meat production? I used to catch the bus across the street from a chicken-processing plant. They live in cages that are just large enough for the chicken itself, and the cages are stacked quite high, so that except for the top level, all of them are constantly getting waste dumped on them by the chickens further up in the stack. Seems pretty torturous to me.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y agoFrom the article: "In the year since the elephants left, Feld says circus attendance dropped precipitously." This is a great lesson to businesses in general - know if your critics are actually your core customers. The overlap between people who protested elephants and the people who attended the circus was pretty small. The company ended up listening to a very vocal minority and then lost a lot of business from the quiet group of customers for whom the elephants were the major draw and who then stopped buying tickets. This also applies to open source projects and brings to mind DHH's article http://david.heinemeierhansson.com/2012/rails-is-omakase.html http://david.heinemeierhansson.com/2012/rails-is-omakase.htm...
- sweetheart 10y agoI would I think a more valuable lesson would be to not start a business that relies on animal cruelty for success. Vocal minority or not, what's right is right.
- wehadfun 10y agoUnless you are a vegetarian you are being hypocritical.
- urbanj 10y agoI'm sure you know there's a difference between killing an animal for food vs mistreating it for entertainment. So, what are you trying to do?
- tclancy 10y agoGood ol' Whataboutism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_is_the_enemy_of_good https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_is_the_enemy_of_good
- praneshp 10y agoOne could also characterize your (and GP) view as NIMBYism. I want animal happiness, and they should give up what they like for that.
- Allower 10y agogood riddance to this antiquated and pathetic form of entertainment
- issa 10y agoWhether you're an animal rights activist or not, the fact of the matter is EVERYONE thinks it's wrong to abuse animals. People will go to great lengths to pretend animal cruelty isn't happening and the circus relied on secrecy over how its animals were treated to survive. Once video started coming out, it was the beginning of the end. If you haven't seen any of the undercover videos and have doubts, a quick google search will find hundreds. For example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ECspj0daAlE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ECspj0daAlE
- tmat 10y agoSo what you're saying is because some people abuse dogs, no people should be able to own dogs.. TIME TO BAN DOG OWNERSHIP!
- EnFinlay 10y agoWhen did that comment say anything like that?
- Arizhel 10y ago>Whether you're an animal rights activist or not, the fact of the matter is EVERYONE thinks it's wrong to abuse animals. That's not true. There's plenty of people who think animal cruelty and abuse is just fine. There's no shortage of people who abuse animals, for instance, so obviously they don't think it's wrong. They may not be a majority of the population, but they exist.
- issa 10y agoI think "plenty" is debatable. Most people are good at IGNORING animal cruelty (ie: where did my veal dinner come from?), but it is the exception that people actively think it's fine (dog fighting, etc). Once animal abuse is public knowledge (especially against certain more-beloved animals) it is hard for society to forgive. Sea World, the circus, puppy mills, etc. Those things are all going away now.
- 83457 10y agoI don't think elephants actually added much to their show. I have taken my kids twice in last few years... once with elephants and another one more recently without and we definitely preferred the more recent one. If it all comes down to elephants they should really have no problem staying in business IMO. I even saw less protesters at the more recent one. Only reasoning I can think of this not working is if without elephants they have to rely on more humans and effects than before that may be more expensive to produce.
- praneshp 10y agoSerious question: Is the elephant thing your view or your kids' also? I loved the (now discontinued) Aladdin show at Disneyland, and the highlight of the show (judging from the crowd's reaction) seemed to be when the 'elephant' entered.
- SpoilerAlert 10y agoA few of my friends have had similar experiences at the circus. We all went when we were very young, so it's a whirlwind experience for kids. Then as we got older -- like 8 or older -- it was better to go to the Zoo to see the animals.
- wehadfun 10y agoLast time I went to the circus it sucked. Half the show was on some TV with cartoon animals. No one pays $$$ for a ticket $$$ for parking, $$$ for a cup of soda to watch cartoons on a TV.
- tclancy 10y agoIt's just another industry that needs to be disrupted. I'm with you on what we think of as "the circus", but there's no reason traveling entertainment can't change. My daughter is just old enough to be interested so we took her to the circus last year, but it was a circus put on by http://www.smirkus.org/ http://www.smirkus.org/ and it was terrific. There's no attempt at professional gloss and it's not about selling plastic crap (there's a bit but it's fundraising for the camp) ; it was just teenagers from all around the country putting on a great performance.
- smacktoward 10y agoIt's already been disrupted, the disruptor is called Cirque du Soleil.
- Arizhel 10y agoThat's not a circus, it's a dance/art show.
- dragonwriter 10y agoCircus has been an evolving art form for a long time (starting out 250 years ago as pure equestrian shows); the contemporary circus genre of which Cirque de Soleil is one of the more popular examples is a fairly new development with circus, but certainly recognizable as an example of it that has close ties to it's immediate predecessors.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Declanomous 10y agoAn interesting theory I heard for why the circus folded now, rather than at some later date, involves the age of the circus train. Rail cars are 'certified' to run on Class 1 railroads for 40 years post-build, and once they reach 40 years old they need to be inspected and have their running gear rebuilt. This allegedly costs around $150,000 per car, and only certifies the car for another 10 years. Based on the auction of the circus train, the circus owns/owned 127 cars. So while the circus might have been solvent, if a large number of the train cars were coming up on a rebuild it might have been the straw that broke the camel's back. Here is a reddit thread discussing it a bit: https://www.reddit.com/r/trains/comments/5o3ih1/i_wonder_what_will_happen_to_the_ringling_bros/ https://www.reddit.com/r/trains/comments/5o3ih1/i_wonder_wha...
- Naritai 10y agoThis is a great example, though, of why 'EBITDA' is such a terrible metric of profitability. Depreciation (which is the way this rail car certification would likely be accounted for) is a real (if deferred) cost.
- dismantlethesun 10y agoIt's not a terrible metric. It's only bad for companies who have high debt loads, or companies who have to periodically upgrade costly equipment. These downsides to EBITDA are well known and should weigh on the mind of anyone who looks at the metric. For a company that rents all its equipment, EBITDA is a pretty good metric.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> It's not a terrible metric. It's only bad for companies who have high debt loads, or companies who have to periodically upgrade costly equipment. Right, ignoring depreciation and debt service is only horrible for assessing companies with significant depreciation or debt service. > For a company that rents all its equipment, EBITDA is a pretty good metric. Sure, if you don't have significant depreciation/amortization and debt service, EBITDA is just an approximationation of EBT, which is a perfectly good measure. And EBT's a perfectly good measure even for companies with debt service and depreciating equipment.
- clintonb 10y agoI saw the last show for the "red team" in Providence, Rhode Island. While I have seen a number of Cirque du Soleil (CdS) shows over the last 10 years, I haven't seen Ringling Bros. (RB) in about 20 years. The difference I immediately noticed was the ticket price. A CdS show ranges anywhere from $40 to $120. My seat at RB, on the sixth row, cost $55. I understand the desire to keep the show accessible to all families, but the price disparity between the two companies was huge. The production quality was good, but not as high as that of CdS. That said, I enjoyed the show and the fact that it is accessible to people at most income levels. Audience members were permitted to go on the performance floor 30 minutes before the show. We could interact with the performers, who were doing a few mini-shows, and get a much closer look. That sort of access costs over $100 at Cirque du Soleil. Besides ticket price and production quality, another factor working against Ringling Bros. is the fact that everyone lives on the train. Entire families travel to every city. They have a school on the train. When everyone came out at the end of the show, there were at least 200 people of varying ages—babies to adults. That can't be cheap. I'm not sure if Cirque du Soleil does the same for their performers.
- jsrjenkins 10y agoJust my humble opinion, but I think the loss of the circus will actually not be a great help to the conservation of these wonderful animals. Elephants are in the public imagination largely due to the circus and the zoo. We like elephants because we can actually go and see them, which makes us want to keep them around. No one really does anything [donate, protest] about certain endangered species, like the Saola because they aren't in the public eye. Elephants, rhinoceros and Tigers have very extensive programs to protect them, even large national parks, because there is large public support for their conservation. The panda likewise would simply be a curiosity and evolutionary dead end if it wasn't for human intervention. Once the public doesn't even know what an elephant looks like, the public support will diminish. Certainly there has been many abuses in the circus [like in many other things human beings do], but I just hope that people don't forget about the elephants. I would say that one of the reasons that they haven't been hunted to extinction was due to the fact that many children remember with fondness these wonderful animals, and that contact they had with them was from the circus.