11 ms·
Boost – Your personal advisor and career coach
- elfenheart 10y agoThis is awesome!
- ztratar 10y agoHey Elfen! Founder here -- thank you. :) We're always looking to hone in our pitch and improve the product. If you or anyone else here has feedback, let me know.
- pieroapretto 10y agoCool idea! Very much needed in this industry.
- thinbeige 10y agoHow will you scale (if intended)? Why I ask: Wondering if bots or customer support staff can really support this use case.
- ztratar 10y agoHey there! We're looking to scale this in a similar way as Facebook M -- where our coaches on staff have control over specific bots with specific purposes, and can leverage an entire world of data/knowledge to quickly craft personalized responses. At $59/month, unit economics should work as we develop better tech. But for now we're certainly prioritizing quality over speed. :)
- deegles 10y agoHave you thought about freemium models? Maybe have bot-only engagements that are free and then pay for more personalized advice? I just feel like paying on a "session" basis would be more workable for me than a monthly subscription. If the product/advice works well, I should have less and less need of it! :)
- sprice 10y agoThis looks very useful. But it's not clear to me what a "topic" is. Is it a single question from beginning to end? If it dragged on could it become a new topic? More clarity with this would be great!
- ztratar 10y agoThanks for the feedback! There's actually currently an AB test where we remove topics. It seems that most people are confused by this, and it created a strange flow in the conversations. A topic is basically an entire chat engagement, end-to-end, with a specific purpose. As I said though, we're looking to gain data right now to possibly remove them. Appreciate the thoughts!
- ha470 10y agoMaybe just call them "conversations"?
- fecak 10y agoI also provide private career advisory/coaching and resume services to many in the tech sector, and I'm a mod on a Reddit sub that answers compsci career questions (r/cscareerquestions), so this caught my eye. The biggest question I generally have with services like this is "who is providing the advice?". We have an issue in our Reddit sub, where there is little transparency (obviously due to anonymous accounts) as to whether your career advice is coming from someone with twenty years of industry experience or an intern. I think the source of the info is relevant, as the recipient may want to weigh the advice based on the source's experience. It appears Boost is using some AI that might automate some of the response, which will hopefully provide some good answers and perhaps have a few kinks with advice that doesn't quite apply. As a bit of advice for the founder (saw you commenting here), perhaps a bit of info on the source of the advice would be useful to users. Best of luck with the service, and feel free to reach out.
- ztratar 10y agoHey Fecak! Fantastic -- and important -- question. We have trained career coaches on staff, an advisory board for coaching, and an extensive network of experts who are within reach. Through all of this, each conversation acts as a knowledge base that we can pre-fill. We brought in tens of industry experts across product management, design, software engineering, marketing, and more to give crash courses, which were then put into the database as well. We're still refining our coaching process, as what works for one individual doesn't always work for another. I'd be interested in chatting in more detail. Can you reach out? :) -> zach@getboost.io
- fecak 10y agoThat's refreshing to hear that you've got some experienced team members in place or on call, and although career advice is clearly not 'one-size-fits-all' I've learned over the years that there are certainly many pieces of advice that can be applied on a regular basis without much need for customization (negotiation tactics perhaps) which is why AI will be quite useful to you. Happy to discuss with you, will email directly. Again, good luck!
- dtft 10y agoReally cool idea, but I don't know why I would pay a (relatively large) monthly fee for a service that I probably need twice a year, around both my performance reviews.
- ztratar 10y agoHey dtft! Boost can do things that help you daily or weekly such as: - Review communications (inbound and outbound) - Help you develop new skills and stay up to date - Assist you with targeted networking - And much more. Overall, this is a service that can refine every aspect of your professional life. People who only think about refining their habits and practices twice a year are not aiming towards their potential. The bare minimum is too often accepted as normal -- we want to change that.
- ztratar 10y agoOne thing I want to mention is our upcoming event! We'll be hosting Amjad Masad, Founder of Repl.it and former JS Tech Lead at Facebook where they built projects like React Native, BabelJS, and Jest. Tickets are free. Event is in SF on June 1st! https://www.eventbrite.com/e/a-fireside-chat-with-amjad-masad-founder-ceo-of-replit-tickets-34638891858?aff=hackernews https://www.eventbrite.com/e/a-fireside-chat-with-amjad-masa...
- leroy_masochist 10y agoQuick question, trying to get my head around the product: Say I just got an email from my boss that I think is passive-aggressively accusatory (e.g., perhaps it lays out the specifics of what she wants me to do tomorrow in a way that I think she's implying that I can't be entrusted to get things done without detailed instructions). I paste the email into Boost, asking for feedback; am I crazy, or is this an accusatory email, I wonder, eagerly anticipating Boost's response. Perhaps I also want to hear Boost's advice on how to respond to the email. After I do this, who is reading and interpreting the email on Boost's behalf, then giving me advice on how to respond? I'm sure you're feeding it into a sentiment analysis API, but apart from that, what human attention does the email get and what are the backgrounds of the humans doing it?
- ztratar 10y agoThe humans are trained career coaches who are on our full-time staff. They are obliged to follow all privacy and confidentiality agreements that the company follows itself.
- rezashirazian 10y agoRoll eyes. I'm sorry but this is a ridiculous idea. I can see potential use for this once or twice a year, and even at that I wouldn't reach out to anyone unless I know them personally. How insecure and in need of validation someone needs to be to seek career advice from a chatbot four times a month?
- Rmilb 10y agoI think impostor syndrome can be a huge self imposed mental barrier for some software devs. Unsure on the right price point to help over come it.
- wangarific 10y agoIt's a huge mental barrier for a lot of people... but can it overcome by talking to something you know is a bot?
- lazyasciiart 10y agoPeople are willing to accept talking to a rubber duck can be helpful, why not a bot?
- lucasmullens 10y agoWhere does it say this is a bot? To me it looks like it's human coaches who use AI to quickly find answers. Maybe they're doing Facebook's approach of slowly replacing humans with bots, but for right now they seem to be human. Edit: saw another comment by from Boost, they're doing Facebook's approach.
- petergatsby 10y agoBoost is _not_ a bot -- it's a team of AI-enhanced, real-life career coaches. Think Facebook's M.
- skylark 10y agoMy gut reaction was the same as yours because I would personally never use a service like this. That said, the existence of career consultants proves that there are people who do enjoy this sort of advice and direction. I don't see this becoming a unicorn startup, but I could see it becoming a niche service that some people really enjoy.
- scdoshi 10y agoThis might be just me, but the most important thing to me when I get advice is: - who am I getting it from - what do I know about their life/experience - under what circumstances Because that let's me adjust how much importance to put on it. Getting advice is generally not the hard part, figuring out which advice to follow and which to discard is.
- ztratar 10y agoTotally agree. We help people build external social support networks as well. In addition, as is true with all good coaches, most conversations circle around introspection and talking through analysis rather than imposing our own advice. We still give plenty of advice, but we also are aware enough of the nuances that exist and we-don't-know-what-we-don't-know.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- anindha 10y agoAs someone that moved to SF from Sydney and didn't have a strong network here I think this would have helped. One thing is that I have no idea who is on the other side of the chat. If they are giving me advice about one of the most important things in my life is there a guarantee on the quality of that advice? Are you guys in the next YC batch?
- ztratar 10y agoQuality can been self-assessed quite readily, and for tricky situations we usually coach people to develop a supporting network outside of Boost. So far we have paying users who are VPs at large companies all the way to College Students. And our tech revolves around surfacing quality advice, what works/doesn't work, so it will constantly improve. Still, we don't risk anything -- we do extensive training for coaches.
- firloop 10y agoReminds me a lot of StrongIntro's (YC W16) website https://strongintro.com/ https://strongintro.com/
- ztratar 10y agoHey! We are friends with Fouad (founder of StrongIntro) and he let us use the images. :)
- rwc 10y agoMore than just similarity... https://www.getboost.io/4cce970cbfd7f28431e7dd91cb13ff98.png https://www.getboost.io/4cce970cbfd7f28431e7dd91cb13ff98.png https://strongintro.com/images/backgrounds/city.png https://strongintro.com/images/backgrounds/city.png
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tIONTamINariciA 10y agoIn the "Communicate Better" section, did the imaginary employee really attach business confidential information in a Boost topic? i.e. "I've attached a PowerPoint full of sensitive information that I'd love you to read and profide feedback. Soon afterwards I'll be needing job search advice since my employer will fire me for having such terrible judgement." Sounds like a terrible idea and a poor example of how to use the service. Do they really want to advertise Boost as a service which will provide unapproved consultancy of confidential info?
- ztratar 10y agoBoost is 100% confidential. People talk about complex power grabs and political situations all the time. For Boost to work well, people need to be able to trust it with Information thy want confidential.
- patch_cable 10y agoTalking about complex power grabs and political situation is a bit different than encouraging employees to upload confidential information, which is what I think tIONTamINariciA. Would you consider adding anything to the UI to discourage your users from those potential lapses in judgement? And if not, what do you do to protect the sensitive information you may find in your hands?
- ztratar 10y agoSo far we haven't had anyone give us any information that's super juicy, so we're not worried about a built-in UI to discourage it yet. Once we can expand the team further, hiring a full-time security engineering staff will be a priority. As of now, we have the basics down... full E2E encryption, security access privs, etc.
- posixplz 10y ago> 100% confidential Are your coaches licensed professional counselors, therapists or psychologists? If not, those conversations are not actually privileged; any disclosure of legally protected information (like a company's sensitive internal documents) would be highly improper.
- ktal90 10y agoI've watched Zach and his team evolve their business and product over the past few months and years. I'm really impressed by their ability to adapt and build new products guided by user feedback and data. I'm excited to see how many people Boost will help!
- cblock811 10y agoSounds like this would be helpful for a lot of people. I would use it following the same rationale as hiring a personal trainer: some self-imposed level of accountability to push me forward. I know how to exercise, but having someone there to nudge me in the right direction helps me actually do it.
- ztratar 10y ago^^^^ someone gets it!
- gailees 10y agoHow do you manage such an insanely low price point?
- ztratar 10y agoI always love when this advice contrasts with "Why does it cost so much" :P Our entire engineering team is dedicated to building tools that make our career coaches super human. Unit economics can get healthy pretty fast.
- fdsfsafasfdas 10y agoHah—ironically, it's expensive enough it should be advising you to go with a cheaper option.
- tsunamifury 10y agoHave they thought about adding in Motivational Coaching? I would easily pay for that as I need to perform at a very high level for long periods of time with little advice. I would pay probably upwards of 300 a month for regular access to a motivational and strategic coach a la the main character in Showtime's Billions.
- ztratar 10y agoBoost does motivational coaching as well! We brought in some CBTs (Cognitive Behavioral Therapist) who recommended we train our coaches in it. I can't guarantee it'll be as high quality as the Billion's actors though. ;)
- egonschiele 10y agoMy first question on seeing this was "what does the advice look like?" Thanks for having so many examples right on the home page!
- peteretep 10y agoI'm a recruiter who's been a CTO, contract developer, consulted for most of the large international staffing companies, run (very) occasional courses on career development for developers, and have hired many people as a technical interviewer. I give a lot of free advice to developers I represent. I will be curious to see if there's an actual market for this.
- pmiller2 10y agoDo you work in or around the Bay Area? I don't actually know very many recruiters who are more than just salespeople.
- peteretep 10y agoAfraid not. While I've technically got global reach, I focus on London, and a particular niche in London.
- joncrocks 10y agoAny tips for finding 'good' recruiters/filtering out bad ones? And any tips for finding good recruiters in London specifically?
- peteretep 10y agoWhat area are you in? Possible I can make recommendations albeit unlikely. I've found a fairly strong correlation between recruiters whose company I enjoy and their competence. Also: look at the spread of the jobs they're in, do they sponsor conferences and communities?
- ztratar 10y agoRecruiters only give advice to job seekers. Also, most recruiters (sorry) can't be trusted. Their motivation is not aligned with the candidate's best interests -- candidates are their product.
- shahbaby 10y agoPossibly useful for people who have lots of money and no friends.
- ztratar 10y agoHahahaha.
- seem_2211 10y agoMaybe
- seem_2211 10y agoCool idea. I like it overall. I don't know about the idea of having "experts" talk to you. I've spent a lot of time thinking about my career and talked to a few experts and it's a real mixed bag. In some ways I see this in the same way I see most formal mentoring programs - the best way to get an amazing mentor is to arrange it yourself. There's a way to do it, but it's hard. That said, there's a massive amount of potential to change the way that recruiting is done. Traditional job boards suck - they don't work for candidates - it's a blind stab in the dark, they don't work for hiring managers because you get the same 100 applicants who didn't read the job description every time you post up an ad. Getting people to front-load the work before they look for jobs and making that introductions to companies would totally change the game. Recruiters aren't suited for that (I am a sales recruiter). You'd eat LinkedIn's job postings for dinner as well. If you were able to get a userbase of high-quality candidates, who you worked with to improve their careers and then put them into additional jobs you'd be able to charge thousands for each successful hire. There's a market for helping move the smart, overworked, underpaid millennials who are grinding it out at professional services firms from their first jobs at $50k to jobs paying $120k a year (which will more or less happen naturally for a lot of them as they move through their 20s). These people are likely to pay for it, plus their employers would pay on the other end. The hardest bit is making it a habit for young professionals to check into your platform. Right now it's a weird concept, but hey, the idea of dating online amongst 22 year olds was weird until Tinder changed the entire game. If you could turn Boost into a career coach firstly and then into a reliable pipeline of candidates for professional firms, I'm convinced you could make this massive. Damn, I want to work on this now haha.
- ztratar 10y agoHey! Message me -> zach@getboost.io We actually played that game before. We were arbitraging candidates for their job hunt -- taking a % of their salary upon successful new job. The issue was, most frequently, was that you'd have to invest a lot of time/money into people and there are a lot more "talkers" than "doers". So far, the recurring revenue model has been a lot more psychologically pleasing, haha... But yes -- our goal is to really help people become better and move up the career ladder faster. If you're passionate about that, I do think we should chat!
- dboreham 10y agoAnd I came here thinking this was about a C++ class library..
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mifreewil 10y agoI didn't look very deep beyond the main graphic at the top, basically did a quick 5 second test on it. Personally, even though I'm a typical person who avoids phone calls most of the time, I can't imagine texting some stranger for career advice. Some sort of network tool to match with a mentor for a long-term relationship sounds like something I might become interested in once in the shit storm as a founder. Ideally, the match would lead to phone and/or in-person conversations and advice.
- beager 10y agoThanks for sharing. Some notes: 1. Signups go right to waitlist, so it's hard to validate any of this. Is this vaporware? Why waitlist? Are you still in dev, or is this an artificial scarcity play? 2. All I see here conceptually is headhunter lead-gen, so I don't understand why you're charging $708+/yr for chatting. Why not offer your service for free, register orders of magnitude more users, and make your money as an agency by placing users in new jobs? If they are engaged with your platform, you'll know it's time to do that before any other platform or agency does, and you have a qualitative advantage over other agencies because you will have counseled your candidates for a long time prior. Seems like the focus of Jobstart before you rebranded it, n'est pas? 3. Your job functions in registration are constrained to tech and tech-adjacent functions only. Is that a limitation of the advisors you have on your platform, an unconsciously narrow scope, or is it related to your market designs for point 2? 4. How will you not get obliterated in court for encouraging the transmission of proprietary or privileged information? 5. Back to the $708+/yr point, so many alternatives could provide the same use for less. A private curated Quora, a user mentor network with perks (advise other users for incentives), even curated career resources in a newsletter or Amazon book-of-the-month club. I realize that a service like this might pay for itself in boosting one's earning potential, but many less-expensive incarnations of the same are at anyone's disposal. 6. Why chat? Why not email? Why not Hangouts? I feel like chat is such a restrictive medium.
- dimaggiosghost 10y agoDisclaimer, I have gotten much value out of their previous project, jobstart. 1/ it's based on personal advice so needs to scale on both sides. I've spoken w the founders and they legit. 2/ I intend to get my work to pay for it under "high quality outsourced good management". I don't expect to use it for a new job, but to perform better in my current. 3/ it is my understanding that it's a scaling thing. 5/ in my job, a 10% improvement in efficiency Uncompounded is worth thousands of dollars in direct costs per month. Well worth it, based on my jobstart experience w the same team.
- beager 10y agoWith respect to #2, why would any employer pay for their employee to use a service that has a strong financial incentive to place them in a new job?
- lemonsqueeze 10y agoLove this. There are many people that have mentors, and this is an extension of that. Would like to see a 'marketplace', but somehow personal and allowing you to be healthy long term relationships.
- noufalibrahim 10y agoI'm not totally convinced but sufficiently intrigued to give this a go. Are you focussing purely on low to mid level employees inside a company or also catering to freelancers and such people who have similar though not exactly the same needs?
- ztratar 10y agoHey! We have a wide variety of users and are trying to figure out if we want to niche, but so far a lot of the success has been against broad markets. Low/Mid level employees are certainly much easier to help. Less complicated political situations, etc. We have a couple freelancers on the platform... probably about 15 or so. Their discussions usually center around improving their external brand and customer pipelines.
- jv22222 10y agoHere's a similar service for dating advice: https://hermes.social https://hermes.social Shows that this concept can span niches.
- ktta 10y ago@dang: Are influenced submissions investigated? This post was submitted by an account with no other submissions/comments except this. I suspect some mischief, but have no proof. Is is possible to look at the first few votes made for this post?
- lorenzhs 10y agoThe submission link has UTMs: https://www.getboost.io/?utm_source=hackernews&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=launch https://www.getboost.io/?utm_source=hackernews&utm_medium=so... This certainly smells.
- ktta 10y agoThat was something that tipped me off too. They're very specific.
- ztratar 10y agoIt was posted by our head of coaching. Suspicious? People self post all the time. We didn't run an upvote group, if that's your concern. HN algorithms are way too impressive.
- ktta 10y agoI guess we'll have to take your word for it. The account that posted was created about two months ago and this was the only submission which was the red flag. And this was the very first submission. Usually people have to repeatedly post to get the traction this post did because they get ignored sometimes.
- ztratar 10y agoSo what's weird is she actually posted last week too, but only she can see that submission in her submissions page. I can't see it -- I only see this one. Maybe that's why this one was allowed to go up? Not sure.
- DictumMortuum 10y agoGood idea or not - I am worried about the security of this. Some of us have signed contracts that specifically mention that we shouldn't share company information with third parties. Even if a person hasn't signed a non disclosure, how ethical is it to share in-company politics with others?
- ztratar 10y agoWe are too -- that's why we are working close with our lawyer to understand all the implications. We're also working on DB security. Our data isn't large enough yet to really be a big target -- it's pretty boring right now -- but we'll invest in it right when scaling hits promising Series A-style levels.
- gt_ 10y agoI am usually very skeptical, esspecially when it comes to the pitfalls of exchanging personal advice, but this really is not personal advice. This is ethics training. I think the difference changes Everything. This could solve a very real problem: the mysteries of navigating ethical standing. I am concerned about the anonymity, particularly that the advice depends on the info provided while the user is representing not only themselves as a patient but also their ego. Ideally, the user would have comfortable assurance of their anonymity and the concept would have a unique value. If doable and manageable, I would believe in that. Privacy would be a concern for many users (for various reasons) but not all. My thought about anonymity is about usefulness, not privacy.
- gibbiv 10y agoUTMs in the HN link: cheese-a-rific
- satysin 10y agoWhat is your legal protection on giving bad advice? It's all good to say something along the lines of it not being legal advice, etc. But what if some advice you give wrecks that person career? How are you and your mentors protected?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nul_byte 10y ago"Hi again Boost. So I've been working at my job now for about 8 months and don't think I'm getting paid enough as a Lead Designer -- barely making rent in SF isn't fun. Is it too early to ask for a raise?" Would someone really want to confide that much of personal glimpse into their working life to community they barely even know, or even for their current employer or future employer to possibly see one day. Not for me.
- smelterdemon 10y agoI have similar concerns, although I'm shocked the quoted question is where someone would draw the line. That in particular does not seem at all personal, or potentially damaging at all (if an employer regards an employee trying to gauge their value negatively they're probably a shitty company to work for anyway). Personally I wonder how effective any kind of general career advice could be without conferring with a level of intimacy I'd reserve for a therapist or close friend. I feel like only the most practical career advice (which is widely and freely available) could be offered up without delving into things like long term goals and personal motivations. I guess I could see this being useful if you have a well formed idea of where you want to go in your career and have trouble getting from point A to point B, or could use a little encouragement/social pressure, but I think the harder problem is figuring out that destination not the implementation details.
- ztratar 10y agoTo both points: trust is earned over time and we have to actually design our onboarding flows and coaching processes around that idea. It's tricky, but it's how it should work -- we don't expect people to have implicit faith in any system, and actively coach them to question the world around them. More people question too little than too much, so it's great to see you all are the opposite. :)
- bbcbasic 10y agoWould this be suitable for money-making side-project advice and goals?