3 ms·
The flipper mentality played a role. But individual mom and pop flipping profits from actual houses were anecdotal and ad hoc. The systematic and deliberate and
by brudgers 10y ago
The flipper mentality played a role. But individual mom and pop flipping profits from actual houses were anecdotal and ad hoc. The systematic and deliberate and low risk flipping was of mortgages. Mortgage flipping was done at large scale by large players and was moving the market in large increments.
The big changes to the market when the bubble burst was an oversupply of housing. Mom and pop flipping does not create an oversupply. There's one property at the beginning and one property at the end (in most cases, though there are a myriad of edge cases). Instead the oversupply was created because the important product was in the B2B sector.
The bubble created an oversupply because housing was built as a precondition for generating mortgages. Every extra dwelling built during the bubble generated another mortgage or two for the mortgage market. Big national homebuilders built houses to generate mortgage loans to flip. Local and regional banks wrote construction loans to generate mortgage loans to flip.
The buyers of the loans flipped them off to pension funds and institutional investors. Wall Street loved it for very rational reasons. Individual homeowners were not driving loan prices down and real estate prices up. Sure they thought they were savvy rather than lucky when their house appreciated. But they weren't generating the message.
Pointing to an obscure book as causal misses years of nightly news and decades of standard best industry practice advice that buying a home is a way to accumulate wealth.
- ouid 10y agoThe mortgage bubble was exclusively created by the very explicit government subsidy on mortgage interest. Regular people defaulting on homes is both allowed and rational behavior. It's not illegal, and blaming people for it misses the point entirely. The aggregate effect of the mortgage interest tax credit, on the housing market however, is highly dependent on how much income tax can be written off with it, which is itself highly dependent on how much income middle america makes. This is a volatile figure. Banks have to have limited liability in order to function. They accomplish this limited liability through explicit hedges called insurance policies. Insurers, unfortunately, have no such requirements to limit their liability, and in this case were liable for VASTLY more than they were worth. The problem is that this is a rational strategy. As soon as your liability goes beyond what your company is actually worth, it no longer makes any sense to try to limit your liability on other investments. In fact you want to take on as much liability as possible. If someone gives you a loan which you could never repay, then rational behavior dictates that you go to vegas and put the entire sum of the loan on red. If you win, you pay your loan back, and if you lose, you declare bankruptcy. The only problem with this is that it is fraud. This is where the story gets interesting, because the only thing required for the insurers to maintain plausible deniability in the event of a default on their massively overleveraged positions was for an "independent third party" to call the investments that they intended to insure "triple A". Regardless of whether or not those agencies were truly independent, the fact is that they are an unacceptable point of failure.