3 ms·
I, for one, vote for the mesh network.
by ianai 10y ago
I, for one, vote for the mesh network.
- guelo 10y agoThe lag time, and probably bandwidth, on a mesh, especially a wifi one, makes it unacceptable for many uses.
- ianai 10y agoThat sounds like an implementation-bound constraint. Many technologies start out unacceptable for certain uses and mature to competency.
- orthecreedence 10y agoThis is what I figured as well, but I also wonder if that's just because the devices we use haven't been built for this. In other words, if public interest shifted to some kind of mesh network, perhaps the devices could be improved enough to support the load. That said, I don't know much about mesh networking at all, the routing methods it uses, or if it's even possible to support what I'm talking about. It also has to contend with the existing, established infrastructure so probably won't see many large investments any time soon. I still think it would be a decent alternative to what we have now if it could overcome bandwidth/latency limitations.
- russdpale 10y agoYep, but its all we are going to be left with. Of course, at first it will suck, and it will be limited to neighborhood meshes.. from there perhaps it can start to branch out and connect to other neighborhoods, then city to city, until we finally have a decent internet. Its going to be up to the web development community in its entirety- front and back end- to make the push, by showing neighborhoods that mesh nets are worth the investment. Perhaps though, this is what we need to get a true internet. I'm curious as to how Berners-Lee and company would have redone it, perhaps they will have their chance.
- justifier 10y agoHow does a mesh network cross oceans?
- AstralStorm 10y agoVia long hops, just like the rest of the Internet. Either fibre, satellite or old radio relay.
- justifier 10y agohow do you decentralise fibre, satellite or radio relay?
- Qwertystop 10y agoYou end up with bottlenecks. Packets on a mesh will try for the best route - if there's only one big cable across the ocean, everything that needs to cross takes it. Same situation we've got now, for oceans.
- justifier 10y agobut how does that decentralise the system? a central body will need to maintain those lines and would be critical to the mesh
- ianai 10y agoI'm thinking at some point the mesh network abstracts over the current internet. An abstraction that has crossed an entire continent can probably afford a non-crap service line.
- dredmorbius 10y agoIn stationwagons.... More seriously, back in the old days: ... the Usenet link to Australia was a daily batch of tapes flown by 747. High bandwidth, but long ping times. One of the first publicly-accessible network links between the US and Europe ... was a 9600 BAUD line. I'd cite both of these in more detail, but the book is buried somewhere in archives presently. A late 1980s / early 1990s (just prior to the dawn of the public Internet) item. More generally, though, to address your question, oceans aren't the problem. We've got ocean links. It's the last mile, between you and the local on-ramp. That's where Comcast, Verizon, AT&T, and TWC have their monopolies, which need breaking up.