3 ms·
There's no way to determine if your consciousness persists through sleep or unconsciousness. Really, there's no way to determine if your consciousness persists
by mikeash 10y ago
There's no way to determine if your consciousness persists through sleep or unconsciousness.
Really, there's no way to determine if your consciousness persists from one moment to the next. All that we know and experience is perfectly consistent with a world in which every moment in time has a different "you."
- sgift 10y ago> There's no way to determine if your consciousness persists through sleep or unconsciousness. If I remember correctly, that was actually the reason that anesthetics weren't used in operations for a time after their discovery - people believed that if you were out your soul would leave your body. Luckily, we've gotten over that particular idea.
- krapp 10y ago> Luckily, we've gotten over that particular idea. And if teleportation ever becomes a reality, human society will adjust its concept of "self" to adapt as well. The premise of a "persistent" self (essentially a soul) and the fear of death will seem like magical thinking and silliness.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoSleep doesn't involve destruction of your body, however. The kind of teleportation discussed here, does. And while you can't be sure, upon waking, whether you're the same person who fell asleep, if your body is destroyed you can be absolutely certain you won't be the person that wakes up on the other side.
- mikeash 10y agoI strongly disagree with the magnitude of certainty and uncertainty you assign to these various things. We really have no idea how this stuff actually works. For all we know, your consciousness was in my body until a second ago. All we actually have to work with here is memory. Based on this, we have the illusion of continuity of consciousness. But we have no real clue if that actually happens or if it's just something we've made up.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> We really have no idea how this stuff actually works. For all we know, your consciousness was in my body until a second ago. Sorry but that doesn't make sense. By the same token you can start believing in supernatural creators- because, after all "we don't know how [physics] really works". And yes, we do know some things. For instance, if something goes wrong with your brain, your conscious mind is also messed up. That's pretty solid knowledge there. Besides you'll need to jump through some serious hoops before you can explain how my consciousness could be in your body without me knowing anything about it. Not that I'd put that beyond her, the little hussy!
- mikeash 10y agoBefore we talk about potentially jumping bodies, let's examine a simpler question: how do you know that your consciousness is continuous at all? How do you know that the consciousness reading this comment is the same one that wrote the one I'm replying to?
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoBecause I'm aware of having done both. Plus, I don't remember being anyone else and I don't think anyone else remembers being me. Edit: Btw, despite the fact I'm indulging you, I don't find that sort of discussion particularly productive. You might as well argue that parallel lines could eventually intersect. Sure. They could. But we assume they won't. Now what?
- mikeash 10y agoWhy assume that consciousness follows memory? I agree that we can't do much but assume that consciousness is indeed continuous like this. But my point is that it is an assumption. When you get down to the actual facts, consciousness ending due to teleportation is no more or less supported than consciousness ending due to sleep. So I find it weird to worry about one and not the other.