3 ms·
You're cherry-picking pretty heavily: there's a lot of cargo-culted password advice but the current push for user-friendlier password management practices and f
by acdha 10y ago
You're cherry-picking pretty heavily: there's a lot of cargo-culted password advice but the current push for user-friendlier password management practices and fundamental model changes (e.g. two-factor with U2F) has been lead by security experts who have, for many years, been loudly reminding everyone that usability is a security requirement rather than an inherent conflict.
- maxxxxx 10y agoYou are probably right about cherry picking. I know a lot of experts are aware of the problems but from an end user perspective security usability is still horrible and inconsistent.
- acdha 10y agoNo argument there — it's really interesting seeing the divide ultimately becoming users and experts on one side and people who are not experts but are setting policies anyway on the other.
- maxxxxx 10y ago"people who are not experts but are setting policies " That seems to be the key issue.
- apostacy 10y agoI think that the problem is just that the people making these decisions are not security experts, but web designers.
- acdha 10y agoOr often managers who are very concerned about doing the right thing but don't have an expert that they know/trust and so rely on their understanding, which is probably based on the horrible finance sites they use. I once spend several weeks having meetings where people tried to develop a login management process on a whiteboard from first-principles — in the federal government where the right answer was “We'll follow the central security group's required process” – because they didn't have a security consultant but knew security was a Really Big Deal and didn't want anyone to think they weren't thinking about it.