3 ms·
Think of it this way: passwords are a more standard API than OpenID. Since passwords are the standard, they are "implemented" by all your clients. That cannot b
by sanderjd 10y ago
Think of it this way: passwords are a more standard API than OpenID. Since passwords are the standard, they are "implemented" by all your clients. That cannot be said for OpenID.
- dragonwriter 10y agoI'm not suggesting "don't implement passwords" (which are first-party authentication) or "don't support password pasting" (which mainly supports ad hoc third-party authentication with a manual token exchange), but if you are actively choosing to support pasting (and, thus, third-party SSO with a clumsy UI), you should also strongly consider supporting third-party authentication with a decent UI.
- sanderjd 10y agoThe password manager solution is, if you'll allow me to strain your analogy a bit, "second-party SSO". That is, it's SSO that I, the user, manage however I prefer. Password pasting is an extensible API for achieving that. But we don't disagree, folks should definitely implement things like OpenID.