3 ms·
This whole discussion is a good example for everything that's wrong with computer security. Instead of coming up with solutions that make it easy for people t
by maxxxxx 10y ago
This whole discussion is a good example for everything that's wrong with computer security. Instead of coming up with solutions that make it easy for people to follow good practices the "experts" make it even more cumbersome. Most people just want to use the computer and not think about security.
- sanderjd 10y agoYour comment would be interesting if it brought some ideas to the table. Lots of people work hard to come up with ideas that strike a good balance on the really difficult trade off between security and convenience. Comments like yours that seem to imply this should be really easy, but don't provide any ideas, aren't very helpful.
- maxxxxx 10y agoIf I had a good idea I would have provided it. I wish I had one. What I am saying is that from a regular user's perspective there is no viable way to do it right and we shouldn't be surprised if people follow bad practices. We can't just tell people to: - don't write down passowrds - have unique strong passwords for dozens of sites - always type them in It's not going to happen.
- acdha 10y agoYou're cherry-picking pretty heavily: there's a lot of cargo-culted password advice but the current push for user-friendlier password management practices and fundamental model changes (e.g. two-factor with U2F) has been lead by security experts who have, for many years, been loudly reminding everyone that usability is a security requirement rather than an inherent conflict.
- maxxxxx 10y agoYou are probably right about cherry picking. I know a lot of experts are aware of the problems but from an end user perspective security usability is still horrible and inconsistent.
- acdha 10y agoNo argument there — it's really interesting seeing the divide ultimately becoming users and experts on one side and people who are not experts but are setting policies anyway on the other.
- maxxxxx 10y ago"people who are not experts but are setting policies " That seems to be the key issue.
- apostacy 10y agoI think that the problem is just that the people making these decisions are not security experts, but web designers.
- acdha 10y agoOr often managers who are very concerned about doing the right thing but don't have an expert that they know/trust and so rely on their understanding, which is probably based on the horrible finance sites they use. I once spend several weeks having meetings where people tried to develop a login management process on a whiteboard from first-principles — in the federal government where the right answer was “We'll follow the central security group's required process” – because they didn't have a security consultant but knew security was a Really Big Deal and didn't want anyone to think they weren't thinking about it.