3 ms·
I expect this post the become massive, as questions like this are so large a kind of bike-shedding exercise goes on, but my own 2c: I think religious rights sh
by Chris2048 10y ago
I expect this post the become massive, as questions like this are so large a kind of bike-shedding exercise goes on, but my own 2c:
I think religious rights should have never evolved the way it did.
Religion is clearly different from creed color, etc, it also includes belief, personality, motivation etc. Instead of becoming power real estate for established religions to fight over (do 'cults', or atheist institutions get the same protections), it should have evolved into the right to believe anything that doesn't motivate you to break the law; in other words, protection against though-policing.
The flat-earthers should get the same protections as catholics - the right to hold any belief, be it on faith or otherwise.
- maxxxxx 10y agoAgreed. Religion should not even be mentioned. Everybody should have the right to believe whatever he/she wants as long it doesn't violate other laws like not killing other people.
- maxerickson 10y agoIn the US they pretty much do have the same rights.
- Chris2048 10y agothe same rights in terms of outcome? They don't literally use the same legislature, because AFAIK flat-earth beliefs do not qualify for religious protection. In fact, some believers wrap their belief structures in an established religious structure, it seems, just so they have those protections. One specific concern about this: Don't like gays? sorry bub, go to jail. Have a religious basis to not like gays? protected! I choose this contentious example to show that any belief protected by religious rights, should also be protected when otherwise having no religious basis; and also why some beliefs shouldn't be protected, even if religiously based. When all beliefs not barred are permitted, there will be a lot more motivation to bar specific kinds of belief - at the moment, the established religions can push exceptions for their specific beliefs. Put another way - if religion isn't special, then either racist belief is as valid for a neo-nazi as it is a church, or that belief is an invalid for a church as a neo-nazi.
- maxerickson 10y agoNote that I said in the US, where we have openly racist groups that do not claim to be religious organizations.
- Chris2048 10y agoThey have to use different laws if they want to get protection though, and are liable to "hate" laws that religious organisations be more immune to?
- maxerickson 10y agoNo, not really. Our speech protections are pretty universal. There are hate crime laws, but they largely are additional charges in cases of violence. A church probably has an easier time demonstrating that they are a non profit for tax purposes.