8 ms·
I don't know, maybe it's different now, but my generation (went to school in the mid 90s) was not told to "just go to the best college no matter what": We were
by ryandrake 10y ago
I don't know, maybe it's different now, but my generation (went to school in the mid 90s) was not told to "just go to the best college no matter what": We were also advised to consider the cost and carefully choose a major so as to produce a positive expected ROI. Obviously nobody has a crystal ball and you can never tell when huge, industry-wrecking changes are coming, but it was well understood that majoring in Underwater Basket Weaving was not a great idea from a financial point of view. Have we forgotten this lesson?
- austenallred 10y agoI was definitely told to go to the best school no matter what and to not consider the cost. But I graduated in 2008 in a perma-middle-class suburb that probably wished those things were true. I'm sure it's very different for others.
- Meekro 10y agoMy experience was similar to yours. I immigrated from Russia at a young age so we had very little money. I attended a great college mostly on scholarship. My mom had always taught me to work hard and pick a major carefully, taking into account ROI. Thanks to merit-based scholarships and need-based aid, I graduated with minimal debt, despite attending a private college with a $45k per year sticker price. Thanks to a proper choice of majors, I made good money right out of school. I'm always puzzled when people claim that one needs to come from money to succeed.
- austenallred 10y agoI'd venture a guess that helpful and savvy parents matter as much as (if not more than) coming from money
- labster 10y agoYou need luck or connections or wealth to succeed. Connections can include parents, friends, etc. But something has to break your way -- simply attending college is not enough to tilt the odds in your favor.
- vizeroth 10y agoMany colleges are being pressured (by accreditation committees, donors, government, etc.) to provide methods for students to acquire connections that make it easier to succeed. Networking opportunities, guest lecturers from industry, internships, and special programs are fairly common ways that colleges can make a difference for students beyond an education. While some (perhaps many or most in some schools) professors live in the isolation of academia, lecturers or part-time, non-tenure professors often work in a field related to the subject they are teaching, and can be a good source of connections for students. Sure, simple attendance may not be enough for many students, but most colleges do at least try to give you the opportunities and tools you need to succeed.
- labster 10y agoSo that's how they justify the administrative bloat in universities these days. And it's a great excuse to keep hiring lecturers instead of faculty! I'm not trying to be hard on you, it's just that I'm skeptical about whether new non-academic programs in universities improve outcomes enough to offset their costs to individual students. The check on administrative bloat is very weak in the US, and arbitrary ratings like the US News & World Report have more influence than customers do.
- vizeroth 10y agoI realize this is days later, but I felt the need to respond even though I didn't feel the need to check for responses earlier. I do see how it can be easy to believe that ratings have more influence than students. At the same time, many ratings include student surveys as a substantial part of the ratings process. Additionally, I can see how it can be easy to believe that there is significant administrative bloat in universities, even when the reports on funding sources and costs state that the administrative costs have been going down. For many the budgets and administration of public universities simply don't have enough transparency, and even when they strive to achieve transparency there may not be enough historical data to give people any real perspective. Further, it's easy to point the finger at all sorts of practices within a University as sources of said administrative bloat, regardless of whether the budgets support those arguments. When you have a significant reduction in state funding for public universities, you drive those institutions to look for ways to overcome those budget shortfalls. Generally speaking, it's hard to get people to accept salary reductions, so cost-cutting measures come from other directions. Where I work, tenured/tenure-track faculty in some colleges are teaching significantly more credit-hours than they would have ten years ago, so there are fewer lecturers, students, part-time faculty teaching classes. Since the tenured faculty don't get paid more for teaching more classes, this is a pretty effective cost-cutting measure for some colleges, but it has its limits, especially since those faculty are also expected to continue with other intellectual contributions (such as research). Every new staff or faculty member hired anywhere within the University has to be justified. They no longer hire someone simply because a position has been vacated, so when someone retires it's possible that their duties simply get distributed among others and the position goes away. However, if someone's job is basically fund-raising, it's probably going to be easier to get approval for that position, especially if you can find a candidate with a proven history of improving the budget situation for an educational institution. Meanwhile, programs and physical things like buildings and equipment tend to be attractive to donors. You can put up buildings and fill them with equipment by demonstrating a willingness to pay for 50% of the cost and then creating a big push for donors, and with the right people working on the project you can end up paying significantly less (or nothing). Further, you can then leverage the new building/equipment for further facilities/equipment upgrades. Good luck getting someone to pay someone's pension or to pay the salary of any of the staff dealing with the budget, custodial work, IT, etc.
- slackingoff2017 10y agoGoing to college without debt is not always possible. I tried everything to get scholarships to no avail. Picking a major with a good ROI is definitely possible. Assuming everyone can do what you did is foolish because there's not physically enough scholarships to go around. There's probably a much greater number of people equally puzzled why they have to go to community college because they couldn't get a scholarship.
- swimfar 10y agoI think his point was that he went to a college he could afford. It's true that not everyone can get scholarships to pay for their entire education. But no one has to pay $40k+/year in tuition to get a good education.
- ryandrake 10y agoYea, my point was both college selection and major selection should be guided by ROI. This was pretty thoroughly drilled into me by my parents and my high school advisors / guidance counselors. We couldn't afford much so I went to a low cost state school, took advantage of as many scholarships as I possibly could, and picked an engineering major. At no point in the process did anyone ever advise me to "follow my dreams" or "pursue my passions".
- SimbaOnSteroids 10y agoI did this as well, spent my first 3 semesters at a private school that cost 40k a year had a pretty decent scholarship but the kicker was that I was in a major that had a minimum starting salary around 100k. So I felt that going to this particular school was worth the debt I'd accumulate because of 1 the major, and 2 the socioeconomic status most of the students came from. Anyways after 3 semesters I realized that I really didn't like the major I was in so I dropped outta that school and moved home and went to community college until I got myself together and motivated. When that happened I moved into a local state school that is known for being extremely good for its cost. I don't regret going to the expensive school even if most of the credits didn't transfer, I met some great people there who will be valuable friends to have made. I also don't regret not going there anymore because it would have been way too expensive.
- plaguuuuuu 10y agoComing from money isn't a necessity for an individual, but on a statistical basis, the correlation is undeniable - you're so much more likely to succeed if you come from money that the idea is substantially correct. If I had a "small $1 million loan" right now, I'd be able to take much greater risks in terms of quitting my job to create a startup or whatever. Thus I'd be far more likely to be more successful (financially speaking)
- dennisgorelik 10y ago> If I had a "small $1 million loan" right now ... then your fate would be similar to the fate of a typical big lottery winner: having all your money spent in a few years and your life derailed. Children of wealthy people succeed not because of inherited money, but because of wealth management habits they learned from their parents.
- 0xC0DECAFE2020 10y agoThey succeed because of connections, plain and simple.
- askl56 10y agoIt's not zero sum. As somebody who has come from money and made a lot of money in a field entirely unrelated to my parents and with zero financial help from them after university, a lot of the disparities I see between myself and others in my situation who came from more disadvantaged backgrounds is that they spend their money far less wisely because they think that, for example, a house in the country will make them happy. I know from my childhood that is not necessarily the case.
- loeg 10y agoIn the 00's (and admittedly, an anecdote), we were told to "follow our passion" and weren't given much guidance on college affordability (community college for gen. ed. requirements vs in-state vs out-of-state / private). No emphasis on ROI or cost, at least at my school.
- crdb 10y ago> not told to "just go to the best college no matter what" > majoring in Underwater Basket Weaving was not a great idea from a financial point of view I've met many people in places like McKinsey or Goldman Sachs (i.e. "elite" high paying jobs) with degrees from Oxford or Cambridge in Philosophy, English, Arch & Ant or Theology (in "decreasing usefulness"). Many more than, say, graduates in accounting or business administration from Manchester University, although a few might make it. Hell, I know a Harvard philosophy major who co-authored a very useful Haskell library. My conclusions from anecdotal evidence: - these universities, regardless of degree, encourage very hard, focused work, and teach and encourage critical thinking; both critical thinking and hard focused work are useful in all jobs; - people overestimate the "technical" portion of most jobs, and how easily it can be taught (a law conversion course takes a mere few months in the UK, and banks routinely train thousands of fresh unqualified graduates every year); - people overestimate the marketability of skills taught in most "useful" degrees especially outside its area of specialisation (e.g. is a medical major more qualified a strategy consultant than a philosophy major?); - you gain access to a vast alumni network and its reputation (which includes world leaders, the CEO of the companies you apply to, etc.); - the selective nature of admissions sends the market a signal about your "intrinsic" quality. (edited to be more readable on mobile) Obviously, if you want to become a specialist and you are sure of it, it is a better idea to study that field in the best place you gain admission to. But that has not been true of the vast majority of my former classmates. In fact I watched a strange inversion whereby those who were certain they wanted to be engineers are now at McKinsey or banks and those who were certain they wanted to make tons of money in business are now working in "hard" engineering jobs (structural engineering, fluid dynamics for car companies, etc.).
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoThis would be more convincing if McKinsey and GS were genuinely considered to be producing something of value. The reality is - more nuanced. Certainly there are many who consider both GS and McKinsey to be very bad things indeed, and not in any way a professional niche that high quality graduates should aspire to. Perhaps there may be more to "intrinsic quality" than an obsessive work ethic and social connections? My experience has been the opposite to yours. People who don't have technical degrees but have been trained to consider themselves experts in business management generally overestimate their own skills, and vastly underestimate the skills and insights of those (nominally) "under" them.
- iamacynic 10y agoi'm in my mid 30s and my generation was taught that a good option might be going to community college for 2 years and then transferring, because of the reduction in cost by basically 50%, and to keep loans to a minimum if possible. this recommendation was always weighed against the 'freshmen experience'. i think the demographics and expectations of the college-bound is what has changed, not necessarily the advice. getting a good paying job after school was an amazing achievement, even for top schools like university of california's top campuses, not something expected as normal.
- diogenescynic 10y ago>went to school in the mid 90s >but it was well understood that majoring in Underwater Basket Weaving The way you make such a condescending argument and blame the victim takes away any credibility in your comment. The issue is that tuition has ballooned since the 90s. Tuition is outpacing income/inflation and most else, so regardless of what school or major, the ROI is going down for most. Also, even if you went to a top-tier school and had student loans in the 1990s, you could discharge them in bankruptcy--until Bush changed that in 2005. Things really have gotten harder, it's not as you falsely claim that people are picking useless majors.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoStudent loans are one of the biggest and most self-destructively predatory idiocies the "financial industry" has ever invented. Ballooning tuition was an inevitable outcome, as was the speculative financialisation of educational institutions, and the relative loss of value of student teaching and post-grad research. It's really just a form of compulsory loan sharking, and it's politically and economically cancerous. Not only does it have immensely toxic second order effects, it's almost guaranteed to kill, or at least seriously damage, its host economy. As for "useless majors" - one of the foundations of any civilised society is personal freedom, and that includes the freedom for cultural and intellectual exploration. Forcing all activities to compete economically and sweat a profit is not freedom - it's the opposite.
- diogenescynic 10y agoI agree with you entirely. Basing everyone's college major on ROI is why public universities should be free, so that people can pursue knowledge regardless of cost or ROI. Otherwise we wouldn't have artists, musicians, journalists, authors, and dozens of other essential careers that help make life worth living.
- ryandrake 10y agoSorry, bud. I also went back to school for another go after 2005, still focusing primarily on ROI. So I think I can say I'm well aware of and lived through both current and past student loan / tuition regimes. But please feel free to continue to attack the tone of my argument rather than the content.
- lovich 10y agoIt's a little bit of a different situation but when I was in rotc in 2008 we were literally told to take underwater basket weaving if it was an option because all you needed was a high gpa and any degree. The business school was like this as well, you needed something like a 3.8 to get in, so everyone applied in their first or second semester. After that you could stay in the school with a <2.0 gpa for the rest of your time there. The only person who ever told me to consider what sort of job I'd get was the advisor for the law school who said I shouldn't go into law if I ever wanted to make money. At the time I didn't trust her because every other adult in school and my personal life was giving me the opposite advice
- majormajor 10y agoDon't worry, there are a lot of people who still don't go to their first choice school because it's too expensive. But if even the second, third, fourth, fifth, etc, choices also leave you 50K+ in the hole... and nobody will give you a glance without some kind of degree... what the fuck are you supposed to do? IME you're wildly overestimating the number of people who think they're going to make tons of money with a BA in Photography or similar. They just need to tick that degree checkbox to be employable at most places, and everyone has been telling them to go to a 4 year university their entire life, and they're all stupidly expensive.
- edmccard 10y ago>it was well understood that majoring in Underwater Basket Weaving was not a great idea from a financial point of view It's still understood. It's just that, it's not a very useful piece of information, since _all_ degrees are more expensive nowadays -- not just the basket-weaving ones.
- bpchaps 10y agoI think so. It's funny, despite having a relatively damn good career without a degree, I still get constant grief from friends and family. There probably hasn't been a single family visit since leaving home where someone hasn't asked me when I'm going back to college. Even after explaining that it makes no financial sense to put myself into >$100k debt, the degree comes out as more important than anything else. It's not something I really know how to explain, except that the modern expectation of "established person" is someone with a degree. So until that expectation goes away,it seems we're going to be culturally stuck here for a while. /anecdote
- pascalxus 10y agojust get one of those super cheap online bachelors degrees. all you really need is the certificate you get at the end - then you can be cool like everyone else ;)
- grigjd3 10y agoI got that lesson and that school is what you make of it.
- icantdrive55 10y agoYea, but we didn't know much about the world. We were the last truly innocent generation? The Internet was a baby. I had no idea people were hired on what college they graduated from. I had this notion it was about ability. I did know certain schools, like Princeton was kinda a joke. Why? Every over the hill actress/rich kid gets in. I picked a business major, which at the time, was a conservative major. If I had a do over, I would tough out a physics/chemistry program. It was so much more difficult learning math back then. Just a big book, and a bunch of other confused students. That said, if I had a do over today, I would still spend two years at a community college. It's boring, and you're with a lot of older people. Then again, going to a CC is not good advice either. Most never tranfer. I think the best advice is get credentialed in something. Then rob, and steal from the uninformed, and vunerable, because you have a huge barrier to entry? Looking back, I had maybe ten classes, I really learned something from. I really thought college would be exposed for what it is by now. How should companies hire? Test applicants. The brightest people I have run across never got their degree.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>Obviously nobody has a crystal ball and you can never tell when huge, industry-wrecking changes are coming, but it was well understood that majoring in Underwater Basket Weaving was not a great idea from a financial point of view. Have we forgotten this lesson? The most common undergraduate major is Business. The "liberal arts and humanities" make up about, what was it, 12% of all bachelor's degrees?
- lotsofpulp 10y agoIn my experience, a business major is the new communications or psych major. Basically, a last resort for those who can't do anything else.
- geomark 10y agoI worked at a large aerospace company which had a large contingent of business majors needed for all the required compliance reporting. They weren't paid well compared to the engineers. Those business people always joked that if the could have they would have become engineers, but they couldn't handle math so they became business majors.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoIn terms of content, sure, but that's something we know after graduating. You try telling the kids going in that the major marked "business" is a money-loser.