3 ms·
I find this sad. Government should be building the infrastructure of the future. For example, Google Fiber may have been unprofitable, but the government shou
by bsder 10y ago
I find this sad.
Government should be building the infrastructure of the future.
For example, Google Fiber may have been unprofitable, but the government should be laying fiber to every corner of this country.
Sadly, with 1/3 of the US stuck in propagandaland, this is the best we're going to do.
- rhino369 10y agoFiber is a waste of money at this point. I just got gigabit and it has essentially no marginal value compared to my only 75mbit connection. Most consumer hardware can't really do jack shit with it. The killer app is DSL reports speed tests. Money is better spent on anything, but something like low carbon energy would be a much better use of it. Really, we should focus on getting any broadband to areas that don't have any. Rather than upgrading people with cable internet to gigabit.
- bsder 10y ago> Fiber is a waste of money at this point. I just got gigabit and it has essentially no marginal value compared to my only 75mbit connection. Most consumer hardware can't really do jack shit with it. 1) The benefit is to businesses first, not necessarily consumers. Solid telepresence would allow specialists in various fields (medicine, engineering, etc.) to be located away from the big cities. It would also allow businesses to locate away from the big cities. 2) Part of the reason we don't have new applications is that so few people have gigabit (especially upload). Why write an application that requires gigabit when nobody will use it? Every order of magnitude jump in communication upload speed spawned something new in technology usage that we couldn't see at the time. 300 baud -> email, BBS 9.6K baud -> graphical Internet 128K baud -> napster, MP3 1.0M baud -> video So, what is waiting at 10M (we're just getting here in the rural areas and it's patchy), 100M, or 1G upload?
- slilo 10y ago> So, what is waiting at 10M (we're just getting here in the rural areas and it's patchy), 100M, or 1G upload? VR!
- rhino369 10y agoBut all of those things had a previous non-internet use. It's not like people got cable modems and were shocked to discover that video was a good use for the internet. We all saw it coming. We got broadband to do video and large file downloads. Stuff like telepresence doesn't require anywhere near gigabit. I'm sure eventually there will be a need, but it's not today.
- havetocharge 10y agoYou're basically advocating for elements of planned vs market based economy. This general approach has been known for misallocation of resources.
- bsder 10y agoYou stand disproven by the Eisenhower Interstate System and the Rural Electrification Project. When the government invests in something to make access universal, it tends to be a good investment for the country. When the government interferes in markets, it tends to be a bad investment for the country.