4 ms·
That is a common myth, but it's complete bunk. There is no clean flow of "science -> knowledge -> engineering". The flow goes every which way, and there's plent
by jerf 10y ago
That is a common myth, but it's complete bunk. There is no clean flow of "science -> knowledge -> engineering". The flow goes every which way, and there's plenty of engineering that we do without a particular knowledge of the "science".
Heck, we can barely get half of Hacker News to agree that programming is a mathematical endeavor, a close equivalent to the idea. How many programmers are out there just bashing away on engineering despite not knowing the science of what they're doing? How many "cloud" developers don't understand the science papers on consensus algorithms? Yeah, their code hurts for that lack, but it still works to some extent. How many programmers are reading papers with any routineness in their field? Non-zero, but nowhere near 100%. Or even 50%.
- thatcat 10y ago>How many programmers are reading papers with any routineness in their field? Non-zero, but nowhere near 100%. Or even 50%. Yea it's gotta be pretty low. I guess that's a sort of engineering by intuition that, if it lead to a working design, could then be explained with scientific theory. Still, I would expect a licensed engineer not to sign off on a design if they don't understand it theoretically because they are legally liable in a similar way to doctors.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoNo, that's a feature of software engineering, not of other kinds of engineering. No one seriously believes that airliners, bridges, and the electrical grid stay up because of luck, hope, and positive thinking. The last time the flow went "every which way" was during the industrial revolution, when it was still possible to build useful things with a certain amount of guesswork. Sometimes they didn't even explode. CS is roughly in that state now - lots of opinion and proselytising, plenty of cut-and-paste cookbook programming, far too little empirical testing of various beliefs and propositions, and even less interest in the continued refinement of formal methods that have proven to be useful.