3 ms·
The "flipside" is that some of the best minds in AI basically have only 2 choices coming out of school: - AFGAM - Military The period of being able to build
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
The "flipside" is that some of the best minds in AI basically have only 2 choices coming out of school:
- AFGAM
- Military
The period of being able to build your own competitive AI startup was...what, like 3 years between 2010 and 2013?
- nailer 10y agoAs of 2016 investors were still throwing money at 'ML for x' startups.
- pas 10y agoYeah, why not, Google will buy them if they are okay.
- ballenf 10y agoIf AI is the high end of programming, then it's the equivalent of saying that a recent manufacturing grad can't build their own car assembly line and has to go to work for Toyota, Honda, et al. Barriers to entry at the "top" of industries are generally higher than lower down. I'm sympathetic to the sentiment. Consumers might benefit from the conglomeration more than from a lot of independent groups each reinventing the wheel or spending resources on duplicative infrastructure. There are trade offs of course. In particular, I really don't want one single ML platform to have all my data and know me that well.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoThe metaphor would be that no combination of people will ever be able to compete with Toyota, Honda etc... and if they tried would be acquired or beaten to death by Honda because they are leveraging their massive scale.
- inlineint 10y agoBut what about Tesla? It managed somehow to compete with Toyota, Honda, etc, although it had to create a new market (market of electric cars) to do it.
- taway_1212 10y agoKorean cars manufacturers created now mature brands from scratch. All it took was billions of dollars and a couple decades of time. Can a startup do it? No. Is the market locked up? No as well.
- monkmartinez 10y agoTesla isn't competing with Toyota... They are competing with Porsche and Rolls, etc. Further, they are a mess financially and have not proven to have staying power.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoDespite the hype and genuinely great technology and growth it's still nowhere near competitive with the big automotive firms. So while Tesla has definitely driven innovation here, there are still MAJOR hurdles to them being globally competitive. Further it took Billions and someone like Elon Musk to be able to get even this far, so in that context if even Musk and tons of government dollars can't get there then it's safe to say nobody can.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- aub3bhat 10y agoFrankly, I think your belief is due to lack of knowledge. As a current PhD student who knows several ML researchers at Google, there is fair bit of marketing involved in creating perception of Google supremacy. while no doubt Google is a leader in AI, their advantage is not as great as it would appear by reading the comments here. At the same time other companies, Apple /Salesforce / Amazon / Oracle and several other smaller ones are well aware of threat posed by Google and are always on the lookout for ML/CV startup that can fill the gap in products relative to Googles offering. E.g. Amazon acquired Orbeus around same time Google launched Cloud Vision.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoWe fund a ML research arm at the University of Alberta, give me a break with this. I'm not talking about just Google. Its AFGAM: Apple, Facebook, Google, Amazon, Microsoft You can add Baidu in there too probably. That's it though. always on the lookout for ML/CV startup that can fill the gap in products relative to Googles offering Right, acquire. Not compete. That's the point. You can't actually compete with these companies, like they did in the past with HP, Dell, Nokia etc... the best you can hope for is to be acquired.
- aub3bhat 10y agoFunding is not knowing. There are always new markets which get ignored. Apple, Facebook, Google, Amazon, Microsoft did not compete with HP, Dell, Nokia they essentially entered a new market. Most ML startups don't offer a new product but rather just enable features and acquisition is often the intended end goal.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoYou're missing the point. We expect that DNNs will a fundamental thread to computing going forward. AFGAM has effectively locked up all of the talent and data in the broadest markets already. Not only that they are building and deploying the frameworks that new products will be built on in those other markets. So they don't need to create the product, they just need YOU to use Tensorflow or CUDA or whatever they come up with that runs on GoogleCloudGPU or Azure Compute etc... What you're missing is that it's not about making a few million as a startup. It's that they are so far ahead in what is the most fundamental game changing, final human technology that I don't see a future where they are unseated.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]