3 ms·
It's a really good example of what happens when you don't have a good editor (or don't let them do their work). It contains an interesting overview of some of
by ska 10y ago
It's a really good example of what happens when you don't have a good editor (or don't let them do their work).
It contains an interesting overview of some of the ideas and work done in cellular automata, made significantly worse by the authors seemingly pathological need to lay claim to work that was not his, and inflate the importance of work that was. It's entirely reasonable to decide you can't get past the tone and sheer tonnage of blather to dig for the good stuff hidden inside. As you note, it's also not very rigorous (and sometimes worse) but that's mostly forgivable in a lay text like this, and would be entirely addressed if it had a good set of citations.
It's interesting to contrast this with another book that came out around the same time, Stephen J. Gould's "The Structure of Evolutionary Theory". They are of similar size and scope, but Gould does a much better job of presenting some of his own ideas in the larger context, and giving both credit and useful pointers into that context.
As far as ANKS goes, I've always thought that there was probably a very nice 250 page book hidden inside it. It's just well hidden.