3 ms·
Debating whether they are male or female seems rather pointless to me, it's a question of definitions. If they want to be referred to as a she, I don't see tha
by gpm 10y ago
Debating whether they are male or female seems rather pointless to me, it's a question of definitions.
If they want to be referred to as a she, I don't see that it costs us anything to comply with their desire though... so I do.
- myaccountzz 10y agoSo if I told you to address me as a King, you'd do that too?
- hashtagMERKY 10y agoThat's a bit of a false equivalence, really. There's no good reason why someone should call you King, but Chelsea Manning's gender identity is female, so it makes sense to refer to her as female.
- interfixus 10y agoBradly - or Chelsea - Manning's gender identity is male, male, male. Or did they rebuild him?
- CaptSpify 10y agoNo, because being a King would be inaccurate. It is a position with political and social power, which you don't have.
- michaelsbradley 10y agoIn the same way that he lacks the genetic code to be "she", or to be an elephant (either gender); similarly he lacks the ancestry to be a black man (African American), even if he'd really, really like to be accepted socially and legally as a black man. Nor could he be or become a toaster oven, even if a judge in good standing declared him to be one. In other words, it's a form of self-deception, with perhaps many causal factors, even pitiable ones. Beyond the scope of the individual, it becomes a socially enjoined delusion — a kind of "community madness". It's unhealthy for our society and a sign of deeply troubled times. For my part, I would never knowingly refer to a person — in public or private, in written or spoken word — in a manner that is contradictory to his or her biological sex. I wouldn't be a jerk about it, but it's not something I'd be willing to do, even if the consequences of not doing so were most severe and irreversible.
- gpm 10y agoNo, since that implies a certain amount of respect and deference to you over other people that I don't have. But if Tom told me to call him John instead I certainly would...
- StevePerkins 10y ago> If I told you to call me a King, would you do that? These other replies miss the mark. It's not that, "calling a commoner a king is inaccurate, whereas a biological male could accurately be called female". Because that just brings you full circle back to arguing over whether biological gender and gender "identity" can be separated. The more practical answer is that it doesn't hurt anything, and being a dick about it just makes you a dick. If you told me to address you as Lord Commander of the Night's Watch, then I might privately harbor some doubts about your mental health. But I'd likely do it just to make you go away, m'lord. I would not, however, feel bound by any commands to defend The Wall or anything.
- VLM 10y agoA better, almost perfect analogy, is its a religious belief. Even more accurately its a religious belief where its sole purpose is to state group allegiance and declare one's holiness. Kind of like the right has global warming denialism, the left has transgender. The purpose of the talking point is to declare allegiance to a political group in public and count coup against those less politically fashionable. As such any declaration of disagreement benefits the believer, especially when the discussion happens in an echo chamber of true believers. "Its merely a test of faith" "I'm a better believer than you" "He's just a sinner going to hell" etc. Fundamentally the whole mind-virus can be blamed on Protestantism. When the priest (Catholic or, frankly, Pagan or most other religions) was the arbiter of holiness granted by authority, things were stable. Once holiness was granted to anyone in the general public willing to declare themselves holier than thou, that toxic mind-virus spread out of religion and into everything from climate to sexuality and gender. Generally speaking holiness is a weapon and if it slips out of control into anarchy a civilization is doomed to collapse.
- sctb 10y agoYou've been posting mostly ideological and/or unsubstantive comments, often to the point of outright trolling. We ban accounts for that, so please stop.