11 ms·
How the wrong cat litter took down a nuclear waste repository
- wordupmaking 10y ago> We need to tell the story so that hopefully it won’t happen again. And I'll need to bookmark this just for the lack of points and the deafening silence, for the next time I see some grandstanding on HN about luddites being paranoid about nuclear waste and dumb one-off accidents. > LANL generated nearly 700 drums with a similar waste mixture that includes the organic cat litter. Drums with similar mixtures were isolated and are monitored, DOE says. > “Why didn’t more than one drum react as that drum did?” Hobbs asks. “Never to my knowledge did we firmly establish that there is something completely unique about 68660.” It's an interesting puzzle, but not one for you and me to worry about. Vote Vault Tec.
- wbl 10y agoSuppose the drum broke. How many people would die?
- wordupmaking 10y agoSupposed people who otherwise seem very interested in nuclear energy discussed this as the interesting puzzle it is. How many would die? Apparently, all of them. Hence my comment, though its point seems to have escaped you. My concern isn't primarily nuclear radiation, my concern is the weakness of people who weren't even exposed to a lot of it.
- dredmorbius 10y agoIt depends on what's in the drum, now doesn't it. Now, what was the actual problem encountered at the site? And howw would you go about determining that a benign vs. concerning situation had transpired?
- Retric 10y ago99.9% of the time, none. They are stored in a bunker far from people. A large part of why nuclear power is so expensive is because safety is considered so important. It's hard to get good numbers, but chances are more people have died constructing reactors and mining / refining ore etc. than from nuclear accidents. The difference is simply what people are less concerned when a heavy object falls on someone else.
- Teknoman117 10y agoAnd how many people have died inhaling fumes from coal fired plants and mining coal?
- vilhelm_s 10y agoIn 2010 it was around 13,200 deaths/year from particulate emissions[1]. This is actually a big improvement, stricter regulations brought it down from 30,000 deaths/year in 2000 [2]. I should say that these numbers are surely not exact, there are big uncertainties both in the atmospheric modelling (how far the particles propagate) and in how dangerous the exposure is. But it's probably the right order of magnitude, there is a different report from the National Academy of Sciences in 2010 which arrived at a similar (but slightly lower) number [3]. The deaths from particulate emissions are not even necessarily the biggest problem with coal: if you price out the externalities, the cost of climate change (from CO₂ emissions) is the biggest item [4]. [1] http://www.catf.us/resources/publications/view/138 http://www.catf.us/resources/publications/view/138 [2] http://www.catf.us/resources/publications/view/8 http://www.catf.us/resources/publications/view/8 [3] http://www.ourenergypolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/hidden.pdf http://www.ourenergypolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/hi... [4] http://xhxhxhx.tumblr.com/post/157192261427/alright-two-important-corrections-first-the http://xhxhxhx.tumblr.com/post/157192261427/alright-two-impo...
- vilhelm_s 10y agoA drum did break, that's what the article is about.
- wbl 10y agoAnd 0 people died.
- Nomentatus 10y agoThe expense is already ungodly - "at least half a billion dollars" - one dirty bomb went off, and a whole lot more waiting. What we should worry about is how critical systems go wrong in human hands - even in the stupidest of all possible ways - since there are more critical systems by the day. Genghis John's limit on maintenance and attention nears... yell it from the mountain tops!
- jessaustin 10y agoCornered rats fight hardest. Nuclear is already dead. No one can afford to build a plant, and voters are no longer ignorant enough to chip in. [0] The problem of course is that this particular industrial corpse will hang around stinking up the place for the rest of human existence. [1] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14355072 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14355072 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste#Management https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste#Management
- Teknoman117 10y agoWell, this 'dead industry' still supplies 20% of the United States' electricity and 75% of France's electricity. Hell, France is even a net exporter of electricity...
- onli 10y agoNot a good example. France has an elite system making all political decisions, and that elite is formed partly by the nuclear industry. Also, its energy industry is on the brinks of collapse - turns out nuclear energy is expensive and the subventions already too high, at least for a country that sees itself as being in crisis. And there are a constant stream of accidents and safety issues in those nuclear plants. Might be not dead over here, but it certainly isn't healthy.
- thaumaturgy 10y agoI am overall a strong proponent of nuclear power -- but I gave you a point and bookmarked the article and this discussion under the "nuclear" tag for future reference. I am a larger proponent of renewables in almost all forms, but they all share one really critical problem: they can't promise to scale to meet short-term spikes and drops in demand. For that, you need a fuel-based form of energy, and of those, nuclear is still the best we have. (But demand for fuel energy can be reduced by rushing as quickly as possible to large-scale renewables and new energy storage technologies, and I hope that happens.)
- philipkglass 10y agoNuclear is not suited for balancing short-term spikes and drops in demand either. Fast balancing comes from spinning reserve, batteries (early stages still), reservoir-backed hydro power, and open cycle turbines. Take a look here at how little nuclear output ramps up or down over the course of a week, compared to every other source: http://www.gridwatch.templar.co.uk/ http://www.gridwatch.templar.co.uk/ http://www.gridwatch.templar.co.uk/france/ http://www.gridwatch.templar.co.uk/france/ But nuclear generation could improve its economics and reduce the use of inefficient fossil fueled open-cycle turbines/spinning reserve if battery storage becomes more common and nuclear electricity recharges the batteries for meeting daily peaks.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoWhat bothers me about this argument is that there's plenty of evidence that the overall public health damage from nuclear disasters is substantially less than from coal plants working as intended, and as Thaumaturgy pointed out, renewables will not be able to cover 100% of power production for many years. Absolutely we should use as much renewable energy as possible, but there has to be something to pick up the slack until the tech catches up, and between combustion and nuclear, nuclear is much safer even with regular disasters. It seems like a statistical-awareness failure, like the people who won't fly because they're afraid of terrorists even though driving is far, far deadlier.
- wordupmaking 10y agoWhat argument did I make though? I just found it interesting that this genuinely curious story -- why did one of those 700 barrels react that way -- had literally zero comments after 5 hours on the front page, and was being snarky. I mean, let's grant all that, let's say nuclear energy is 100000x more clean and safe and cheap than all the alternatives. Then why not discuss this curious thing about this most lovable of energy forms? Seriously, I thought the best stuff in science happens when someone goes "hey, this is interesting..." If you love or even just like a thing, kick its tires!
- mchannon 10y agoMissing from this article is the most fascinating thing about this story- why someone thought it was a good idea to make the cat litter substitution that made this whole mess possible. In Los Alamos, those charged with repackaging the waste were hearing a speech by an expert on the matter. The expert warned they should be using "INorganic cat litter", which they already were. What a member of the group heard was "AN organic cat litter". The two look very different in print, but when spoken, they're often indistinguishable to a non-chemist. When the discussion made its way to memos and emails, the die was cast.
- Evolved 10y agoThey may be indistinguishable but common sense still applies when asking for clarification. For example, I work with folks of a certain intellect where I have to ask very specific and pointed questions that do not contain substantial detail in each question in order to clarify something or to get an answer I need. When that conversation happened, it should have ended with, "just to clarify, I should, or should not, use organic cat litter?" That would have cleared it up. Furthermore, “It would have been much clearer if they had said an inorganic zeolite sorbent,” Hobbs says. Wouldn't one argue that a better way to explain it would be to specify nonorganic kitty litter since that would clear up any confusion whether written or spoken?
- nkurz 10y agoWouldn't one argue that a better way to explain it would be to specify nonorganic kitty litter since that would clear up any confusion whether written or spoken? I don't know. Spoken, "a nonorganic" doesn't strike me as clearly better than "an inorganic" at differentiating from "an organic". Perhaps if you knew in advance the qualififications of the intended recipient, but in a safety specification like this, you may not know much about who will be (mis)interpreting the directive. Specifying "an inorganic zeolite sorbent" in the context of nuclear waste may make it more likely that someone who isn't sure about the meaning of one of those terms will seek clarification. By contrast, I'd worry that specifying "nonorganic kitty litter" would increase the chances that someone will just ignore the essential qualifier. Worse, the word "organic" is overloaded, and means different things to the general public than to chemists. Juxtaposing the chemical meaning with the vernacular "kitty litter" increases the likelihood that someone will misinterpret, especially when "nonorganic" is more commonly associated with marketing and "inorganic" with chemistry. In cases like this where a seemingly innocuous detail is actually of critical importance, it needs to be emphasis and redundancy. The oft-quoted rule of "omit needless words" is more applicable to fiction and journalism than to safety specifications. For something as crucially important as this, I probably would suggest something like "a chemically inorganic sorbent, such as a 'kitty litter' made from zeolite clay".
- legulere 10y agoThe whole story can be shortened down to two sentences: > Investigators traced a series of internal communications in which the specifications for “kitty litter/zeolite clay” were transformed into “kitty litter (clay),” the report says. Combined with inadequate technical review, this resulted in LANL workers filling waste containers with a mixture of nitrate salts and sWheat Scoop, a cat litter that is 100% wheat, according to its manufacturer.
- brudgers 10y agoRemoving "zeolite" is consistent with just about every popular piece of advice on how to write: 1. Don't use jargon. 2. Remove unnecessary words. 3. Write a third grade level. So someone comes along and sees the phrase "kitty litter/zeolite clay" and decides that its author does not know how to write based on its author not following the rules and applies syntactic rules without understanding the semantics (in this case the semantics of nuclear chemistry).
- jschwartzi 10y agoItem 1 is especially bad because the whole intent of jargon is to be clear to readers of the same or similar technical level. There's an engineer at work who occasionally tries to harangue me into applying these rules to technical documents and emails to other engineers because she thinks they're "unclear." They're not unclear, she just doesn't have the technical aptitude in my field to read them.
- Nomentatus 10y agoAgreed. As anyone exposed to the media in general knows, we do have a very strong preference for "clear but mistaken" and "false as stated" utterances. Any nuance is quickly labeled a "mixed message" and eliminated - as if the universe never contained a mix of anything that one might want to talk about.
- beaconstudios 10y agoyou'd think that at the level of nuclear chemistry, "kitty litter" would be considered a pretty inexact term for a very serious role.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoIt's a wonderful example why people should be educated far beyond their pay grade. Any mildly trained chemist would know that combining nitric acid and organic material is setting oneself up for an explosion. They should have reached for the Andon cord right tbere.
- nkurz 10y agoConfusion about choosing the chemically appropriate kitty litter comes up more frequently than one might expect. While a zeolite clay based litter is the best choice for nuclear waste, the message here isn't that it's the best choice for all purposes. It turns out that different applications require different kitty litters! Oyster mushrooms can be grown on lots of "plant based" substrates. One easily available substrate is kitty litter made from recycled newspaper, such as the "Yesterday's News" brand. If you to use a zeolite based litter here (even if it had organic certifications) your mushrooms would grow poorly if at all: http://www.namyco.org/docs/grow_oyster_mushrooms_on_kitty_litter_illustrated.pdf http://www.namyco.org/docs/grow_oyster_mushrooms_on_kitty_li.... But for bonsai, both clay and recycled newspaper would be a disaster. Here, you need a litter made from "diatomaceous earth", such as Tesco's "Low Dust Lightweight Catlitter": http://www.bonsai4me.com/Basics/Basicscatlitter.htm http://www.bonsai4me.com/Basics/Basicscatlitter.htm. Tomato seedlings have about the same requirements as bonsai: http://www.tomatoville.com/showthread.php?t=22329 http://www.tomatoville.com/showthread.php?t=22329. I mention these partly as a joke, but there actually is a deep commonality here. All of these are real world situations where the specific type of cat litter used has implications, and in all of them, despite the authors' strong desire for precision and clarity, you find forums full of people who take the "shortcut" of using the wrong type of cat litter and then complaining that it doesn't work. I'm not sure what the solution is, but in the future it sure would be great if we could troubleshoot the instructions in the mushroom, tomato and bonsai communities rather than jumping straight to nuclear waste disposal. Does anyone have examples of other communities making odd uses of specific types of kitty litter?
- dandelany 10y agoLitter made of bentonite clay can also be used as a refractory clay for cheaply lining the inside of a DIY blacksmithing forge! https://aaapirateblacksmith.com/2012/09/12/building-the-trench-forge-and-a-dirt-cheap-clay-recipe/ https://aaapirateblacksmith.com/2012/09/12/building-the-tren...
- cr0sh 10y agoIt can also be used to make sugar rocket nozzles (google "Grant Thompson", "The King of Random", "sugar rocket" for details)...
- nathanvanfleet 10y agoKind of funny that I have actually had the same problem. I collect succulent plants and when you get to a certain point you need to start making your own soil mix. One of the best ways for that is to use soil and hot-fired clay / diatomaceous earth. Which is not really easy to find as a product. Funny enough cat litter can be just that. However, there are many cat litters out there which are made from a wide variety of things. So it's really difficult to eek out the right stuff. Like the article says it can be organic material, or it can be clay that turns to mush when it gets wet. There are other materials out there though, like Turface, which is always high fired clay, or oil-dry materials from auto supply stores, which varies a lot like the cat litter. Either way it kind of seems insane that they are acquiring this material instead of finding a direct and reliable source for the exact material they want.
- prbuckley 10y agoThis mistake cost over half a billion dollars! "An October 2014 report from the Department of Energy’s Office of Inspector General points to a change in the packaging procedure at LANL that specified organic cat litter, when an inorganic sorbent was likely intended. Investigators traced a series of internal communications in which the specifications for “kitty litter/zeolite clay” were transformed into “kitty litter (clay),” the report says. Combined with inadequate technical review, this resulted in LANL workers filling waste containers with a mixture of nitrate salts and sWheat Scoop, a cat litter that is 100% wheat, according to its manufacturer. “It would have been much clearer if they had said an inorganic zeolite sorbent,” Hobbs says. “It’s been a very expensive mistake, costing at least half a billion dollars.”