4 ms·
I'm late on commenting on this. Saw the story passed around here and on social media and figured it'd be worth waiting until the evening to read... I actually
by danso 10y ago
I'm late on commenting on this. Saw the story passed around here and on social media and figured it'd be worth waiting until the evening to read...
I actually ended up reading Tizon's piece after seeing this Tweet from someone I follow, which pointed out sanitized obituary, which Tizon played a part in informing:
https://twitter.com/WendyBrandes/status/864655516227784704 https://twitter.com/WendyBrandes/status/864655516227784704
http://o.seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/localnews/2016807437_pulidoobit20m.html http://o.seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/localnews/2016807437...
I greatly appreciate Tizon's life work and his decision to write about Lola, but I'd be lying if I didn't admit to feeling a great sense of disillusionment, in some ways greater than I've felt about any recent purported journalism scandals, or even the classic infamous ones [0].
It's a complex story and well-told, one in which I simultaneously feel great hatred for Tizon's mother while also seeing Tizon's conflicted perspective. I know how I'd want to act if I were in Tizon's shoes, but (assuming a reasonably reliable narrator) I empathize with how he was constrained to take what seems like obvious moral action. Journalists, even Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative reporters, are just human, I suppose. But to know that someone could have the moral impetus to do such important investigative reporting on behalf of the victimized in our world, yet could not himself call out the modern-day slavery present in his life...that is deeply unsettling.
[0] https://www.cjr.org/the_feature/the_fabulist_who_changed_journalism.php https://www.cjr.org/the_feature/the_fabulist_who_changed_jou...
- abalashov 10y agoWell, like you said, he's only human. And in order to write about his own family's story in a compelling and provocative way, one has to have some journalistic thesis to offer, not just to give a matter-of-fact descriptive account. That requires reaching some conclusions and finding some closure on one's own first. Don't underestimate the psychological escape velocity required to overcome the pull of that which has been presented to you as normal--and which you believed in some measure to be normal--for much of your life, notwithstanding occasional misgivings and questions. That pull can persist well into middle age, and long after you've realised the problem intellectually. And of course, there are practical questions to consider, such as how such a revelation might tank one's career or credibility as a journalist. That might seem unprincipled, but remember that any moral position is diluted by one's own ongoing deliberations. Finally, writing about people who are still alive and who may be impacted by your story is an often overlooked source of sensitivity. Imagine how this story might have impacted Alex Tizon's own mother if published while she were still alive.