3 ms·
> where's the experiment that tests a prediction of this paper I am nonplussed by this question. Did you even bother to read the first post I referred you to?
by lisper 10y ago
> where's the experiment that tests a prediction of this paper
I am nonplussed by this question. Did you even bother to read the first post I referred you to? Because that is all about a (thought) experiment.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoA thought experiment, built on a foundation of assuming which interpretation of QM is correct. That's not the same as an actual experiment, you know. Yes, we can gain insight from a thought experiment. If the underlying assumptions are correct, we can even learn something true about reality. It's that "if" that I'm questioning. And without an actual experiment, you don't know. And with that assumption for a foundation, your experiment becomes a way to experimentally distinguish which interpretation of QM is correct. I'm not saying that such an experiment is impossible, but it's going to be really hard.
- lisper 10y ago> A thought experiment, [i]s not the same as an actual experiment, you know. Yes, obviously. But special relativity was developed almost exclusively on the basis of thought experiments. So basing a scientific conclusion on a thought experiment has a venerable history. BTW, the EPRG experiment is not a thought experiment. That experiment has actually been done (despite the fact that the outcome was never in doubt, which is why it is not particularly noteworthy). > And with that assumption for a foundation, your experiment becomes a way to experimentally distinguish which interpretation of QM is correct. No, it's not possible to experimentally determine which interpretation is correct. But this is not unusual in science. There are an infinite number of theories that are consistent with any finite data set. To choose among them you need some criterion other than consistency with the data.