4 ms·
I'm apparently old enough (just 44) to remember this exact same narrative spoken about Japan, and then Korea. I just don't buy that $NEW_DEVELOPING_COUNTRY is g
by stickfigure 10y ago
I'm apparently old enough (just 44) to remember this exact same narrative spoken about Japan, and then Korea. I just don't buy that $NEW_DEVELOPING_COUNTRY is going to eat the world, for all the reasons that it didn't happen before - as countries develop, it gets a lot harder to grow, and cheap labor stops being cheap.
China has a massive population climbing out of poverty in a single generation. For every steel worker who loses his job in the US, there are thousands of human beings going from subsistence life to one that you and I might merely consider unexciting. I think this is pretty healthy and I wouldn't call it a "negative effect of globalization" - sure, it's not a pareto improvement but it's clearly positive overall.
- 1_2__3 10y agoI'm your age and to draw comparisons between the fear of Japan and the real threat of globalization is laughable.
- hiram112 10y agoAgreed. Japan is the size of California, demographically dying, and can't even feed itself as it's a net importer of food / energy. It's also basically a protectorate of the US. Globalization, the rise of China, and the dismantling of the West's manufacturing (and now intellectual) supremacy in exchange for quarterly profits is a real problem.
- refurb 10y agoAgreed. I remember seeing on the new Americans smashing up Japanese VCRs on the Whitehouse lawn. Japan is going to take all of our jobs! In 20 years they'll be 4x the US economy. Turned out different huh?
- mistermann 10y ago> I just don't buy that $NEW_DEVELOPING_COUNTRY is going to eat the world, for all the reasons that it didn't happen before Other than Japan, when did it happen before? This isn't exactly a common historical occurrence.
- intended 10y agoSince when has the aggregate human being in one country, been happy with a reduction in income, for the upliftment of millions in another? The only reason this has happened, is because they got back some of those pennies in terms of cheaper goods. The issue today, is that the average person is losing their purchasing and earning capacity in the western world. The only people benefiting are people capable of straddling the complex legal and financial networks that span multiple countries and regulatory systems. This provides them with a significant arbitrage opportunity, which they are abusing. You could say that this whole conversation is about how political entities - countries themselves (!) - are now trade barriers. If we let ourselves imagine - tomorrow every country in the world has some geo adjusted minimum wage, and all countries can compete in any geographic position while creating a single globally valid corporation. Then, all the infrastructure which the 1% enjoy - lawyers, financiers, legalesse authors - it disappears. Their ability to extract rents from the system drops as their advantage vanishes. Of course, mercantilism is also bad, but at least rent extraction and arbitrage disappear. - Thanks, your comment helped me spark off an idea that I didn't know had been nagging me. I can now give a better example of why brexit is bad for the UK. The biggest loss is to new firms. A firm in the EU can start up and is valid across the entire region. They don't have to make new entities, or spend on lawyers, tax consultants to tap the full range of their market. A UK firm, has only their own market to target. When I argue this topic out, most of the focus is on big established firms.
- mistermann 10y ago> This provides them with a significant arbitrage opportunity, which they are abusing. The proceeds of which flow into some offshore tax haven so they don't have to share via taxes with anyone in the environment overall society have built.