3 ms·
You think China, an authoritarian government run by a dictator and billionaire party members, that farm its own people out for cheap wages and horrendous pollut
by throwaway0477 10y ago
You think China, an authoritarian government run by a dictator and billionaire party members, that farm its own people out for cheap wages and horrendous pollution, and suppresses free speech, silences reporters and jails people without trials, is A BETTER STEWARD OF THE WORLD???!!
My god, what has this world become
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> that farm its own people out for cheap wages and horrendous pollution I feel it bears reminding that this is all done so that the west can have lots of cheap stuff. You should blame China for being the factory of the world no more than you should blame western companies (big and small) for outsourcing manufacturing to China. As for the other things, the West does more-less the same, just with slightly different methods.
- Cyph0n 10y agoHe said that it might be. No need to get worked up mate.
- mistermann 10y agoActually yes, I think they very well might be a better steward of the world. I don't think it would be terribly difficult to put their historical behavior on the world stage up against that of others and conclude that they are a more ~moral culture. Indeed, they are in many ways sacrificing (working to death and discarding) a couple generations of people in exchange for world dominance, but they are doing an incredible job of it in my opinion. During the last election in /r/the_donald there was this recurring them of Donald playing chess while everyone else was playing checkers. Whether or not that was true (he did win the election), I feel the very same thing is playing out on the world stage. But really, it isn't that complicated when everything in the west is run by corporations that have no concern for anything but themselves, and a typical time horizon of a few quarters. Western society seems to me to have the tendency to completely ignore long term ramifications in exchange for short term benefits (see: the environment). Meanwhile, "racial guilt" from past transgressions is such that it's near impossible to even have a conversation about some of these issues. Despite what the majority of the west believes, the people running China are fucking smart, but you don't even need that when you're taking candy from a baby.
- throwaway0477 10y agoyeah people running China are so smart. SO SMART that they - have destroyed their water/air/land for money that was printed out of thin air by other countries, and those money are now fleeing China to US, Canada, Australia, etc. - have leveraged their debt level to 300+%. not including shadow lending - have built rails to nowhere or barely used, built cities that are not lived, or barely lived, and have to maintain them all - have managed to piss off most of their neighbors (Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Vietnam, India, etc) - have a crashing economy that needs capital outflow restrictions just to barely survive - have not managed to create any global brands - have managed to not create any innovations - encourage its members to flee to US, Canada, Australia
- pyre 10y ago> have managed to piss off most of their neighbors (Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Vietnam, India, etc) Just like how the US is not pissing off its neighbours right now with treats to dissolve NAFTA? Or how the US wants to build a border wall and make their neighbour pay for it, even though they end up with no say in things like who will build it or how much it will cost? Yes. The US is doing a stellar job of things. Not a single bad thing to speak of...
- mistermann 10y agoDespite popular opinion, the US hasn't just recently started behaving badly. Who Owns the World? (Noam Chomsky) https://chomsky.info/20121026/ https://chomsky.info/20121026/
- pyre 10y agoI'm not claiming that it's recent behaviour, but if I start dredging up old things, then people can claim "oh, well that was in that past, not now."
- mistermann 10y ago- have destroyed their water/air/land for money that was printed out of thin air by other countries, and those money are now fleeing China to US, Canada, Australia, etc. Everyone "destroys" their environment while they develop. The earth is incredibly resilient. - have leveraged their debt level to 300+%. not including shadow lending Yawn. - have built rails to nowhere or barely used, built cities that are not lived, or barely lived, and have to maintain them all Let's see how it turns out, I suspect they know what they're doing. - have managed to piss off most of their neighbors (Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Vietnam, India, etc) Because they don't have to care what they think, they only have to manage opinions of Americans. Managing others would be polite but inefficient. - have a crashing economy that needs capital outflow restrictions just to barely survive Where have I heard this before? - have not managed to create any global brands Let's revisit this in 10 years. - have managed to not create any innovations True, but why innovate when 90% of the innovators deliver their technology directly to you? - encourage its members to flee to US, Canada, Australia Wouldn't you? Even if I move to China, I am going to retain a very strong allegiance to Canada. Despite what the PC crowd tells you, this is natural and normal. China's leadership acts quickly, but also thinks very long term. One of us will be proven right in the end, your extreme confidence to me suggests you perhaps don't have a terribly open mind on the topic, which tends not to be beneficial when predicting how the future unfolds.
- yequalsx 10y agoGiven where China was in the 1970s they've progressed rapidly. The situation there is much better on average than it was when Mao was in power. Both in terms of economic freedom and political freedom. Currently they are making major investments into cleaning up the environment. They've tried to limit population growth. They've invested tremendously in public transportation. None of these things the U.S. is doing right now. Currently the U.S. government argues that is can kill American citizens without trial (as long as they are overseas), imprisons people without trial, silences reporters, imprisons a higher percentage of it population than China, wages war in multiple countries, and massively pollutes and consumes more than its fair share of resources.
- mistermann 10y agoThis is the YouTube channel of a South African vlogger who has been living in China for quite some time, I think most westerners have a pretty antiquated view of what life is really like in China. https://www.youtube.com/user/serpentza https://www.youtube.com/user/serpentza
- Maultasche 10y agoI can't say whether China will be a better steward, but I want to point out that the United States was very much like this 100 to 150 years ago, when it was rapidly industrializing. Its free speech and judicial record was generally better, but in World War I, people were jailed without trial simply for speaking out against the war. I suspect that 100 years from now, things will be different for China. Cheap wages will have gone away, manufacturing will be outsourced to places like the Phillipines or Africa, people will be wealthy enough to care about things besides money, particularly the environment. The authoritarian government and the class of ultra-wealthy may or may not still be there, but what China is going through looks a lot like what the US and european countries were experiencing during their industrialization phases. One interesting difference is that China so far hasn't shown much interest in politically and militarily dominating other parts of the world. So far, it seems to be interested in dominating the east Asia region. I wonder if that will remain so, or if China will eventually be interested in getting involved in other parts of the world in non-economic ways. China is very involved in the African economy, so that could very well progress to Chinese puppet states in Africa if their economic interest is great enough.