3 ms·
Just speaking from Julian Barbour's The End of Time perspective: When they say time isn't real, they mean something more like "not ontologically fundamental" -
by SilasX 10y ago
Just speaking from Julian Barbour's The End of Time perspective:
When they say time isn't real, they mean something more like "not ontologically fundamental" -- i.e. you can produce a model with no explicit reference to time, and it can produce all the same predictions as a "timeful" model -- of course, you'd have to do some final transformation at the end to express the time values if you want it to compare to a timeful one.
Yes, you can measure it, but that measurement is wholly implied by all the other (ontologically fundamental) ones.
Compare to a word in which people used four dimensions to describe space. In that case, you could correctly argue that, "hey, space is only three dimensions. Yes, you're measuring a fourth one, but that's redundant with the first three; once I know the first three, I can tell you what your measurements of the fourth one will be."
Barbour's argument, then, is that you can derive the laws of physics in terms of a rule for "which universe configurations are possible", and make that your primary model; time then just becomes a label for a measure you apply between different configurations (the "Machian distinguished simplifier"), but is wholly implied by them.
- Koshkin 10y agoEven if time is an emergent phenomenon, it does not mean that it is not real or somehow "less real". I mean, yeah, we ourselves are "not ontologically fundamental", since we are built from atoms, but I dare to say we are real nonetheless.