9 ms·
I thought this article was very good - not perfect, but a fairly reasonable high level description of what possibly is, or may come to be an extremely large pro
by mistermann 10y ago
I thought this article was very good - not perfect, but a fairly reasonable high level description of what possibly is, or may come to be an extremely large problem for western nations.
The interesting thing to me is, whenever an article of any kind on this topic comes up (on HN and elsewhere), those who disagree seem to disagree entirely, as if the entire premise is completely wrong, and there is literally no negative effects of globalization.
To me, simple thought experiments show several areas of risk both short and long term, and if you look at actual on the ground reality, there sure seems to be a lot of visible damage as well as a large increase in risk and "precariousness" where there used to be security. I don't by any means believe that globalization is a complete disaster or the end of the world, indeed it has been beneficial in many ways to both sides. But this seemingly very popular opinion that there is literally nothing at all to worry about, that when China with a combination of technical sophistication, developed local economy, and sheer population reaches parity and then surpasses the US as the new leader of the world, that all will be well. I think there are many good reasons to believe that China might be a better steward of the world, but there are also many reasons to think otherwise.
As it is now, "the west" enjoys world leadership, a high standard of living, and control their own destiny. I would rather pay a little more for manufactured goods and retain at least that last item.
I probably didn't communicate this very well, but this accelerating new world order seems at least worthy of public discussion, rather than being dismissed as racist conspiracy theory. If more people could at least even consider some of the mentioned risks as plausible it would make me feel better, but even that seems unlikely.
- ng12 10y ago> as if the entire premise is completely wrong, and there is literally no negative effects of globalization. Well, sure. If you're a skilled professional in a coastal metropolis globalization is great. Your company is making record profits and you can buy all the cheap gadgets you want. And then Trump gets elected and you can't even fathom how or why.
- mistermann 10y agoI can understand how one can believe that it will all work out fine, after all one can easily form mental experiments (and find supporting evidence) supporting either outcome. But this absolutely steadfast refusal to even consider the possibility that once it is China who holds all the cards and it is them who are making the big decisions for the world that perhaps, just perhaps, life may not work out quite as nicely as before. Perhaps I'm a bit jaded from my experience living in Vancouver, but historically Canadians had the option to move here and accept a somewhat lower standard of living in exchange for the nicer climate we enjoy. That option is now largely gone, and I expect it to be completely gone within 10 years, and after that it will be the other most desirable locations in the rest of Canada. It is simple economics. Aussies and New Zealanders among others are experiencing the same thing. Of course, detractors can easily point to government "statistics" (that completely ignore blind corporations, proxy purchases, etc) showing foreign activity in real estate to be <5%, but I suspect the main reason most everyone (or at least voters) chooses to "believe" this obviously fake data is because a lot of people are making a loooooot of money from this shift in world order. For now. Let's see how happy are when it is their (and their children's) turn to pay the piper. You made a couple million bucks on your house? Great! Better hope you have only one child, because you cannot buy a home in Vancouver with earned income any longer. Oh sure, you can get a condo, for now, but soon even that option will be beyond reach. Luckily for Canadians we have a near infinite amount of beautiful land (weather, not so much), so there will always be somewhere for us to go, other countries I'm not so sure are similarly blessed. But either way, I'd have rather we retained our sovereignty. I hope I'm wrong, but I don't think so.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nerfhammer 10y agoSo float the housing market. People are willing to place huge bets on the local polities never, ever allowing housing prices to fall. If there were some risk the housing supply could ever increase enough to meet demand this behavior would instantly disappear. Market distortions attract speculators.
- nullnilvoid 10y ago
- hiram112 10y ago> If you're a skilled professional in a coastal metropolis globalization is great... Might want to modify that to a 'skilled professional under 35'. The H1B, offshoring, and the race to the bottom with younger and foreign workers is something that you'll think you won't have to worry about for a while. And then you get older. With a family, kids, mortgage - a life full of things that leave little room for the next JS package manager or version of Angular.
- fineline 10y agoI am older, have family and mortgage, time and financial pressures. But I still get excited about new developments in my trade as a primarily front-end dev, including package managers and frameworks. And the experience, capabilities and track record of success that I bring to the table act as a differentiator between me and my younger colleagues. Not to discount your point, just to say there's more than one way to look at it. For some, they reach a point in their lives / careers where constant change is wearisome. Others continue to adapt and thrive. I have no idea what underlying factors would cause this.
- throwaway0477 10y agoYou think China, an authoritarian government run by a dictator and billionaire party members, that farm its own people out for cheap wages and horrendous pollution, and suppresses free speech, silences reporters and jails people without trials, is A BETTER STEWARD OF THE WORLD???!! My god, what has this world become
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> that farm its own people out for cheap wages and horrendous pollution I feel it bears reminding that this is all done so that the west can have lots of cheap stuff. You should blame China for being the factory of the world no more than you should blame western companies (big and small) for outsourcing manufacturing to China. As for the other things, the West does more-less the same, just with slightly different methods.
- Cyph0n 10y agoHe said that it might be. No need to get worked up mate.
- mistermann 10y agoActually yes, I think they very well might be a better steward of the world. I don't think it would be terribly difficult to put their historical behavior on the world stage up against that of others and conclude that they are a more ~moral culture. Indeed, they are in many ways sacrificing (working to death and discarding) a couple generations of people in exchange for world dominance, but they are doing an incredible job of it in my opinion. During the last election in /r/the_donald there was this recurring them of Donald playing chess while everyone else was playing checkers. Whether or not that was true (he did win the election), I feel the very same thing is playing out on the world stage. But really, it isn't that complicated when everything in the west is run by corporations that have no concern for anything but themselves, and a typical time horizon of a few quarters. Western society seems to me to have the tendency to completely ignore long term ramifications in exchange for short term benefits (see: the environment). Meanwhile, "racial guilt" from past transgressions is such that it's near impossible to even have a conversation about some of these issues. Despite what the majority of the west believes, the people running China are fucking smart, but you don't even need that when you're taking candy from a baby.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y ago> I would rather pay a little more for manufactured goods and retain at least that last item. If you're in the bottom third, living paycheck to paycheck, and forced below the poverty line by ACA premiums you don't have much of a choice but to fuel the race to the bottom by spending on the cheapest goods and services available which will invariably stem from globalized production.
- PKop 10y agoThe assumption in the premise, though, is that these people would get better jobs than they have now, and therefore offset some increases in costs.
- pyre 10y ago> when China with a combination of technical sophistication, developed local economy, and sheer population reaches parity and then surpasses the US as the new leader of the world I don't think that this is a foregone conclusion. In the 80's, Japan was going to take over the world too. While the situations aren't entirely equal, China has followed quite a bit of the Japanese playbook.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoI sincerely hope China doesn't follow Japan's trajectory. It has a large military and strong authoritarian, nationalist tendencies. Japan's conservatives certainly would have liked to "war" their way out of stagnantion (Abe Shinzo is still trying to do this), but their right to a military was largely dissolved as a client state of the US post-WWII. No such checks exist on China.
- lacampbell 10y agoJapan's conservatives certainly would have liked to "war" their way out of stagnantion (Abe Shinzo is still trying to do this) What war is Abe Shinzo trying to start? Is there some planned amphibious invasion of the Kurils I'm unaware of?
- alphonsegaston 10y agoAbe Shinzo has been explicitly trying to rehabilitate Japan's imperial legacy the entire time he has been in power. He's tied to Nippon Kaigi, a group who believe, “Japan should be applauded for liberating much of East Asia from Western colonial powers, that the 1946-1948 Tokyo War Crimes tribunals were illegitimate, and that the killings by Imperial Japanese troops during the 1937 ‘Nanjing massacre’ were exaggerated or fabricated.” I think you can predict someone with that view of history's ambitions pretty clearly. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/13/opinion/tea-party-politics-in-japan.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/13/opinion/tea-party-politic...
- hiram112 10y ago
- nullnilvoid 10y agoGo ahead and take all these low paying, blue collar, manufacturing jobs back to the U.S. China does not want them. You can assemble your own iPhones. These Chinese workers work hard from dawn to dark, in a sweat shop, with no health care, no retirement benefits, for peanuts. Americans can assemble and consume your own iPhones.
- mistermann 10y agoShould the workers themselves have a say in deciding whether they will or will not assemble iPhones?
- nullnilvoid 10y agoAbsolutely. Same with consumers. They should be able to decide what to buy depending on the price, manufacturing location etc.
- mistermann 10y agoThat's a fair argument, but you could also argue that: a) they aren't making an informed (of the long term consequences) decision (and that they aren't informed isn't accidental) b) considering the cost advantages of offshore manufacturing and economic hardship due to job losses, there really isn't much choice remaining I don't fault Chinese citizens or even Chinese leadership in any way, they are simply acting in their best interests. It is western political and corporate leadership that I think are acting incredibly negligently/selfishly.
- dbmikus 10y agoThe idea that one could "pay a little more for manufactured goods" to retain "world leadership, a high standard of living, and control [of] their own destiny" is not necessarily true. It assumes that other nations cannot progress without our economic input. Now, I'm not saying that the opposite is true, either. It's enough of a nuanced issue that I can't give a good or complete explanation. But "protectionism ==> prosperity" is a hotly debated issue and not necessarily true (or false).
- mistermann 10y agoCompletely agree, but I was only saying you could retain the 3rd item, control of your own destiny. Unless they stumble, China will undoubtedly be the world leader before too long (<20 years is my guess), yet other nations would still control how things operate in their own countries, until China decided they wanted control of that as well and decided to forcibly take it. If it was me, I would precede that with some healthy immigration to strategic locations first in order to facilitate a smooth transition, perhaps without having to even fire a single shot.
- hiram112 10y ago> pay a little more for manufactured goods That's only part of the equation. The real issue is that the US elites are going to have to trade some of their profit margins - based on global expansion, market access, lack of tariffs, US military protection of trade routes, etc. - for gains going back to the rest of us. The charts are clear. US capital owners have done quite well. The rest have not. Either something gives or the guillotines become fashionable again.
- Clubber 10y agoStrange that this was down voted. Do people honestly not think armed insurrection is not a possibility in the US? It won't be grand, but it could certainly happen in pockets of desperation.
- stickfigure 10y agoI'm apparently old enough (just 44) to remember this exact same narrative spoken about Japan, and then Korea. I just don't buy that $NEW_DEVELOPING_COUNTRY is going to eat the world, for all the reasons that it didn't happen before - as countries develop, it gets a lot harder to grow, and cheap labor stops being cheap. China has a massive population climbing out of poverty in a single generation. For every steel worker who loses his job in the US, there are thousands of human beings going from subsistence life to one that you and I might merely consider unexciting. I think this is pretty healthy and I wouldn't call it a "negative effect of globalization" - sure, it's not a pareto improvement but it's clearly positive overall.
- 1_2__3 10y agoI'm your age and to draw comparisons between the fear of Japan and the real threat of globalization is laughable.
- hiram112 10y agoAgreed. Japan is the size of California, demographically dying, and can't even feed itself as it's a net importer of food / energy. It's also basically a protectorate of the US. Globalization, the rise of China, and the dismantling of the West's manufacturing (and now intellectual) supremacy in exchange for quarterly profits is a real problem.
- refurb 10y agoAgreed. I remember seeing on the new Americans smashing up Japanese VCRs on the Whitehouse lawn. Japan is going to take all of our jobs! In 20 years they'll be 4x the US economy. Turned out different huh?
- mistermann 10y ago> I just don't buy that $NEW_DEVELOPING_COUNTRY is going to eat the world, for all the reasons that it didn't happen before Other than Japan, when did it happen before? This isn't exactly a common historical occurrence.
- intended 10y ago
- clairity 10y agothe article raises a couple interesting points, but it utterly lacks a coherent argument (and basic editing). it starts with a tantalizing quote: "It enriches industrializing poor countries, impoverishes the semi-affluent majority in rich countries, and greatly adds to the incomes of the top 1 percent on both sides who are managing the arbitrage." and then goes on to blame globalization, as if it caused the greed that led us to the situation we're in. no, globalization was merely one of many convenient mechanisms to exploit. globalization is simply beside the point. so why does it point the finger at globalization? just like immigration, attacking people in far-flung countries spares us a painful inward reckoning. our own greed let us overlook the looting of the middle class, in the secret hopes that we could each become part of the looting class. we let capital get a decisive leg up on labor, and its greed decimated our overall prosperity. the genius of capitalism is that it channels greed for the greater good, but we forgot that it needs to be actively channeled and molded. let's institute laws that level the playing field and guard against economic looting so that we have a functioning middle class again.
- ThomPete 10y agoAnd just like that the parents point was proven. 95% of the jobs created since 2009 are temp jobs, the actual way the us defines a job was changed under Bush and kept under Obama. The number of new jobs created have gone down decade after decade since ww2. The middle class cant come back because their jobs are those most affected by technology and globalization (service industry for instance) the only reason why there is a large group of people working with transportation is because we dont yet have automated cars. Once those get introduced the biggest industry in the US will implode. This has nothing to do with capitalism or globalization in a vacum, this is a discussion about technologys effect on globalization and capitalism and thus the job market.
- stupidhn 10y ago95% of the jobs created since 2009 are temp jobs, the actual way the us defines a job was changed under Bush and kept under Obama Do you have a source for this? 95% is hard to believe...
- flexie 10y agoThrough my work as a lawyer I have dealt with manufacturing of consumer electronics quite a few times, usually when things go wrong. Most European companies have their products manufactured (assembled) in China. In a small gadget, there are easily 200 little parts that are produced by dozens of different Chinese companies. As always in business, there are regularly problems with quality or delays or price hikes, and then the client considers moving production back home to Europe. But such considerations always strand on a number of troubling reasons, and it's not that the gadget would be more expensive in Europe. Actually, the price increase nowadays would be less than one might think (for example from 10 euros to 15 euros on products that sell to stores for 50-100 euros and part of that extra cost would be recouped in not having to ship the products so far). The real reasons are that there are almost no manufacturers in Europe who have the required knowledge, that European manufacturers cannot deliver as fast (they are smaller and have much less manpower) and that European manufacturers are not able to source the components in Europe anyways. Maybe we could get part of the components in Europe, but surely not all 200. In China, they are produced locally and can be delivered in hours or days. In Europe, we would have to have them shipped from China. I don't believe production of the current consumer electronics will be moved back to the Western World. Phones, pads, monitors, flat screen tvs, laptops etc. will continue to be produced in Asia. After all, that's where the manufacturing infrastructure and knowhow is. What we can hope for is that the next generation of products will be mass produced here; robots, electric vehicles, drones etc. But I doubt it. Salaries in China have been at the level of the cheapest countries in Europe for a while but manufacturing has not returned in scale. Your next 3D gadget is likely going to be produced in Shenzhen or Malaysia, not in Romania, Portugal or Michigan.
- golergka 10y agoTo talk about `positive` or `negative`, we first need to establish the fact that these things mean the same to all of us. That we have the same shared interests, overall. Personally, I just don't believe that to be true. I do benifit from globalization, and my interests directly collide with first-world factory workers, for example. It's a normal and common situation - we have a lot of institutions that are working on balancing this conflicts in peaceful and productive way, from capitalism to democracy. But to pretend that we all really want the same thing and the problem is just in intellectual disagreement over what is the best path of action is just silly.
- dcosson 10y agoYes, it sucks that parts of the manufacturing economy are shrinking, but we're between a rock and a hard place. Our only hope is to create new jobs, which actually seems to be working pretty well. I would also support efforts to get creative to make up the inequality gap, such as universal healthcare, potentially a wealth tax or basic income. I don't think many people are actually saying "there are literally no negative effects" of globalization, just that the alternative is clearly worse. It also doesn't help that the anti-globalization rhetoric (like every modern republican platform) is now often mixed in with a lot of anti-intellectualism and xenophobia, and that makes it hard to pick out any good points there might be in the argument.