3 ms·
Given that we can measure time, how can we think that we measure something that may be not real?
by Koshkin 10y ago
Given that we can measure time, how can we think that we measure something that may be not real?
- GavinMcG 10y agoWe can't measure time, at least not in the way that we measure anything else: the measuring device necessarily moves in that dimension in direct relation to whatever is being measured. Analogously, we can use a yardstick to measure space in a "static" way, but don't have a timestick – we have to actually step off each unit.
- contravariant 10y agoBut we do have a timestick? Sort off anyway. The Caesium 133 atom turns out to oscillate at a very consistent frequency, effectively marking equidistant points in time, similar to how a yardstick marks equidistant points in space.
- Koshkin 10y agoWell, the clock's precision plays a very little role here. Still, you are correct, a clock moving through time (while measuring it) is wholly analogous to having to move a yardstick through space in order to measure distance.
- GavinMcG 10y agoYou're right about the equidistance. But we can't measure that oscillation, or anything else that takes place in the dimension of time, without moving through it ourselves. That's what I was getting at with the yardstick analogy: we can plop a yardstick down and look at the number representing the length. We don't need to actually position ourselves at point 0 and move ourselves to point N. That's not the case with time – when we take a measurement, we must start at point 0 and actually move along the time dimension to the point at which the measurement stops. (As a teacher it's always so fun seeing how an example gets interpreted entirely reasonably in way other than you intended.)
- SilasX 10y agoJust speaking from Julian Barbour's The End of Time perspective: When they say time isn't real, they mean something more like "not ontologically fundamental" -- i.e. you can produce a model with no explicit reference to time, and it can produce all the same predictions as a "timeful" model -- of course, you'd have to do some final transformation at the end to express the time values if you want it to compare to a timeful one. Yes, you can measure it, but that measurement is wholly implied by all the other (ontologically fundamental) ones. Compare to a word in which people used four dimensions to describe space. In that case, you could correctly argue that, "hey, space is only three dimensions. Yes, you're measuring a fourth one, but that's redundant with the first three; once I know the first three, I can tell you what your measurements of the fourth one will be." Barbour's argument, then, is that you can derive the laws of physics in terms of a rule for "which universe configurations are possible", and make that your primary model; time then just becomes a label for a measure you apply between different configurations (the "Machian distinguished simplifier"), but is wholly implied by them.
- Koshkin 10y agoEven if time is an emergent phenomenon, it does not mean that it is not real or somehow "less real". I mean, yeah, we ourselves are "not ontologically fundamental", since we are built from atoms, but I dare to say we are real nonetheless.