3 ms·
> In special relativity, the time directions are structurally different from the space directions. In the timelike directions, you have a further distinction in
by threeseed 10y ago
> In special relativity, the time directions are structurally different from the space directions. In the timelike directions, you have a further distinction into the future and the past, whereas any spacelike direction I can continuously rotate into any other spacelike direction.
This is something I've never understood about including time as just another dimension.
- whatshisface 10y agoWhen evaluating the coordinate-invariant length of [x,y,z,t] (where time is just another number), we use the minkowski metric: xx+yy+zz - tt, where time is treated differently with the minus sign. (By xx, I mean x*x=x^2.) So, that's essentially where, "time is a dimension" comes from, and that's where it goes. Aside, if you're wondering what coordinate-invariant length really is: just think about the fact that looking at a house from different angles will not change the distance between the doors. This length is calculated with the Pythagorean theorem involving xx+yy+zz, and when you extend it to lengths which are also invariant under different choices of the time coordinate you arrive at xx+yy+zz-tt. To complete what has turned into a brief introduction to SR, note how differences in the most natural choice of the direction of time might arise: We want the path of a stationary object to involve no movement through space, only the required advance into the future (through time). So, we note that time is parallel to the path of a stationary object. However, people moving relative to each other will disagree about which objects are stationary. Therefore, they will end up thinking differently about which way time points. Returning to my earlier analogy, this disagreement about which direction time points can be compared to the different viewers of the house, who may disagree about which direction forwards or left points. It isn't too unnatural when you think about it, which is a good thing because it is, well, natural.
- renox 10y agoDon't forget the twins paradox, it shows quite nicely that time and space (as one twin accelerate through space he ages slower than his twin) are linked, however counter intuitive this may be..
- Ono-Sendai 10y agoTime is not quite treated as 'just' another dimension in special relativity (SR). As whatshisface mentioned, the sign of the time coordinate is different when computing the interval. What this means in practice is that you can't 'rotate' from a motion forwards in time to backwards in time. Instead you get what is basically a shearing transformation. The amount of rotation is limited by the speed of light (c). So SR, I think, doesn't really say that time is just another dimension like the spatial dimensions. But it does mix the two together with a shearing transformation. In fact, I would say that special relativity doesn't have much in particular to say about what time is. It merely specifies the mathematical transformations between reference frames, including between the local times in those frames. You have to go to metaphysics to say what this really means. In this sense it's a bit a like quantum mechanics.
- justinpombrio 10y ago> This is something I've never understood about including time as just another dimension. There's actually a trilogy by Greg Egan based on the premise that time is just like a spacial dimension (i.e., where the Minkowski metric is instead xx+yy+zz+tt). It radically changes physics and chemistry, and the books are set in this different universe. http://www.gregegan.net/ORTHOGONAL/ORTHOGONAL.html http://www.gregegan.net/ORTHOGONAL/ORTHOGONAL.html