5 ms·
Does the study suggest any mechanisms of action? I'm wondering if there's an insulin response to a carbonated drink?
by mrfusion 10y ago
Does the study suggest any mechanisms of action?
I'm wondering if there's an insulin response to a carbonated drink?
- mipmap04 10y agoBased on the information in the link: "This is due to elevated levels of the hunger hormone ghrelin and thus greater food intake in rats drinking carbonated drinks compared to control rats." It looks like it's the increase in desire to consume as a result of ingesting carbonated beverages that increases the rate of weight gain.
- mark-r 10y agoYes, but what's the mechanism that links carbonation with increased ghrelin?
- cloverich 10y agoComment above suggested it triggered by pressure on the stomach, caused by the CO2 gas as it transitions out of bicarb, which seems reasonable.
- mark-r 10y agoIt doesn't seem reasonable to me. Increased pressure would normally come from greater food intake, which should decrease the amount of the hunger hormone. Is this pure speculation, or is there something in the study to back it up?
- mattkrause 10y agoAs the (real) title says, they think it is linked to ghrelin, a neuropeptide associated with hunger. Drinking something carbonated causes more ghrelin release (or less suppression of ghrelin released, actually) than drinking a still beverage. More circulating ghrelin leads to more hunger, which leads to more eating, which leads to weight gain. The mechanism that allows CO2 to act on ghrelin isn't really clear. They suggest that the bubbles push on the stomach wall, which in turn increases ghrelin release. The whole ghrelin pathway isn't known, but I thought pressure on the stomach walls would suppress, rather than induce ghrelin. There are a few other odd things too. For the rat experiment, they show weight gain curves (weight vs. time) for four groups: rats drinking a) water b) sugar soda c) degassed sugar soda d) diet soda. As you might expect, rats drinking water end up weighing the least, rats drinking (sugar) soda weigh the most. However, the rats drinking the degassed (sugar) soda weigh significantly less than those receiving diet carbonated soda. They take this as support for their theory, but it seems odd that this effect would totally dominate the actual calories in the sugary soda. Similarly, the carbonated (sugar) soda vs. carbonated (diet) soda groups also aren't different.
- WorldMaker 10y agoThis is pure conjecture, as I don't have the links on hand and quick searches don't turn them up, but I saw a study also on HN at one point theorizing that there are pathways for CO2 sequestration as fats/fatty acids in many animal species. (In the terms of the paper that I think I recall, an hypothesis was the increasing levels of atmospheric CO2 due to climate change/industrial outgassing/car exhaust were potentially implicated in the cross-species overweight/obesity epidemic of most species living in human cities.) I wonder if a follow up study into this surprising ghrelin reaction that increased CO2 pressure in the stomach induces it rather than suppresses it may implicate just that sort of carbon sequestration process?
- cperciva 10y agoI'm wondering if there's an insulin response to a carbonated drink? This sounds very plausible to me. The small intestine, in response to being stretched by food, releases hormones which trigger the production of insulin; this is effectively a preemptive strike against the blood glucose increase which usually occurs from a meal. (The pancreas also releases glucagon in order to ensure that the insulin release does not result in hypoglycaemia, resulting in something called the "Chinese Restaurant Effect" in type 1 diabetics: Eating a large meal can trigger a sharp increase in blood glucose even if the meal in question does not contain any carbohydrates.) While this particular effect has only been measured with food, not gas, I'd assume the same physiological cause would trigger the same hormonal effect.