3 ms·
No offense but I hear this a lot "Why not public transportation?" Well, why not a car if people wanted to have a car? With Tesla and new E.V.s hitting the marke
by csomar 10y ago
No offense but I hear this a lot "Why not public transportation?" Well, why not a car if people wanted to have a car? With Tesla and new E.V.s hitting the market, the primary reason (pollution) is gone.
- chx 10y agoCars take a lot of space though in the form of roads and parking lots.
- csomar 10y agoSo? Car owners will pay that bill from car taxes, parking tickets, etc... Why does that bother you?
- giobox 10y agoThe idea that roads and related infrastructure is paid entirely or even largely from taxes on road users is a huge myth that persists in a large number of western nations. In most of them, car owners merely contribute to the cost of roads via the taxes you mention, the bulk of the monies to pay road related costs still comes from other sources unrelated to roads or cars at all. Last I read on the subject, in the USA the breakdown was supposedly closer to 50% road related taxes, 50% general taxation paying for roads. I'm not that bothered personally, but I can absolutely understand why this might bother some - car owners are effectively subsidized by all tax payers to a large extent.
- csomar 10y agoIn that case, I might agree with you. But the parent poster was not complaining about that. You should also be aware that roads are being used for transportation (public or of goods); which practically most people use (though this might mean just direct taxation of these means).
- sib 10y agoWhile this is true, in most cases, public transportation is funded at an even lower rate by fares / fees and more by general taxes.
- Markoff 10y agothose taxes don't really resolve congested roads
- antisthenes 10y agoIf space was really that much of an issue, they would be using stacked parking lots like they do in NY. I assume on the Apple campus most of the parking is multi-level & underground. In that case, what's the issue?
- Tiktaalik 10y agoNegative externalities of car use are the issue. Cars take up so much space on the road that they congest the roads and slow down other traffic. Cupertino and Apple are doing nothing to change this status quo. With the status quo maintained, car use is mandatory for Apple workers in Cupertino and traffic will continue to increase. Bay area taxpayers can look forward to paying more for new road expansion projects to attempt (and fail) to alleviate congestion.
- briandear 10y agoOk, so Apple makes zero parking spaces. Now what? Are they supposed to single-handedly solve everything dealing with transportation? If they built their HQ in downtown San Francisco, then someone else would be complaining about that. You really can't win.
- megablast 10y agoOh, you know, drivers kill over a million people are year. But you are right, why is that a problem? Driving is the single most dangerous thing most people will do at any time. It is a ridiculous, barbaric thing to do.
- valuearb 10y ago730,000 people die in the US every year. Only 35,000 are killed in car accidents. Individually it wouldn't rank in the top ten causes of death. Auto fatalities per million miles driven have dropped by 95% since the 1920s, 86% since 1950, and over 50% since the 1980s. If people don't drive, all those million miles of transport will be taken up by Buses, Trains, Bikes, Walking, etc, all of which have their own death rates per million miles. It's unlikely the death rate will decline in any noticeable way even if we banned cars. And we are on the verge of eliminating the vast majority of accidents, not just self driving cars, but even simpler existing mechanisms such as automatic brakes and lane change monitors will make massive reductions in accident rates as they continue to become more common.
- maaaats 10y agoIf people walked or biked, one would however save hundreds of thousands of lives because of lifestyle issues.
- valuearb 10y agoIf people stopped eating red meat... You can always find ways to save lives by making living suck more.
- Thrymr 10y agoDepending on how you bin it, motor vehicle accidents are one of the largest causes of death, particularly of younger adults [0]. > we are on the verge of eliminating the vast majority of accidents That is purely speculative; in fact motor vehicle accident deaths are going up, not down, in the past couple years [1]. [0] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/accidental-injury.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/accidental-injury.htm [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/15/business/highway-traffic-safety.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/15/business/highway-traffic-...
- maaaats 10y agoWith electric cars the pollution is just elsewhere. And asphalt dust is a major hazard in most big cities. Btw, my argument was that people want a car because that's what has been made the most convenient. I think the correlation is that way.