7 ms·
Labour is right–Karl Marx has a lot to teach today’s politicians
- CriticalSection 10y ago> The problem with Marx is not that his analysis is nonsensical, as Mr Gauke maintains, but that his solution was far worse than the disease. What solution did Marx propose? In the afterword of Capital, Marx notes "The Paris Revue Positiviste reproaches me in that...[I] — imagine! — confine myself to the mere critical analysis of actual facts, instead of writing recipes (Comtist ones?) for the cook-shops of the future". Also Marx wasn't worried that CEOs were paid well as The Economist and "shareholder advocates" seems to be. At least that would be paid to someone who showed up for work. Marx was more concerned in noting the dividend checks that went out quarterly, if joint-stock company dividend checks went out quarterly in those days. The Economist is being indirect in stating Marx's concerns. I'd guess more out of ignorance than malice. Even the first chapter of Capital is famously a hard slog to get through. I doubt the young Economist author made it through Anti-Dühring. More importantly, Marx thought the various contradictions of capitalist production would lead to economic crises that the world saw in the 1930s (outside the USSR, whose economy was booming at the time). Eventually, the companies which are too big to fail really would fail. Capitalism's taxpayer bailouts of big business that worked in 2008 will in some future crisis not work, according to Marxian thought. He also noted how various world economies and societies were swept aside by new ones over the past ten millennia - hunter-gatherer bands for slave societies, slave societies for feudal societies, feudal societies for capitalist societies. In the red flags and worker's councils of the Paris Commune, he saw the hazy, nascent harbinger of the social relations and forces of production of those cook-shops of the future.
- crdoconnor 10y ago>What solution did Marx propose? He didn't, really. His proposals were pretty vague. 99% of what he wrote was a (pretty spot on) critique of capitalism. Needless to say most of the propaganda attacks on his ideas are based upon guilt by association.
- peatmoss 10y agoAs far as the Russian Revolution was concerned, Chernyshevsky was seen as influential in terms of developing a prescriptive remedy: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=What_Is_To_Be_Done%3F_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=What_Is_To_Be_Don...
- dragonwriter 10y ago> > What solution did Marx propose? > He didn't, really. His proposals were pretty vague. 99% of what he wrote was a (pretty spot on) critique of capitalism. The Communist Manifesto was fairly detailed and prescriptive. It's true that Capital was mostly description and critique of capitalism, but that's not all Marx wrote. > Needless to say most of the propaganda attacks on his ideas are based upon guilt by association. Specifically, most are based on association with Leninist vanguardism, which is a fairly radical departure from Marxism prescriptively.
- Jabanga 10y agoMarxism is quack economics. Marx's arguments were an attempt to massively defraud society as a whole. As for recognizing the presence of rent-seeking, that's not exclusive to Marxism, and oversimplifies what Marxism argues. Marx considered all profit from financial investment to be economic rent, unjustly misappropriated from workers. This is nothing more than demagogic quackery, that's now given an air of legitimacy by modern day demagogues in the media and British politics. In my opinion, politics as a whole is mostly an exercise to defrauding the public, which is why Marx's theories are so appealing to so many politicians.
- ue_ 10y ago> Marx considered all profit from financial investment to be economic rent, unjustly misappropriated from workers. No, Marx considered profit made from the value added to commodities by labour, this profit arising from purchasing of labour-power, to be exploitation. Although you may disagree with his theory of value, as far as I know the theory of exploitation comes directly from his theory of value. As Engels put it: "Whence comes this surplus-value? It cannot come either from the buyer buying the commodities under their value, or from the seller selling them above their value. For in both cases the gains and the losses of each individual cancel each other, as each individual is in turn buyer and seller. Nor can it come from cheating, for though cheating can enrich one person at the expense of another, it cannot increase the total sum possessed by both, and therefore cannot augment the sum of the values in circulation. (...) This problem must be solved, and it must be solved in a purely economic way, excluding all cheating and the intervention of any force — the problem being: how is it possible constantly to sell dearer than one has bought, even on the hypothesis that equal values are always exchanged for equal values?" You've asserted that Marxism is demagogic quackery multiple times, without really saying why. Why do you think this is the case?
- spangry 10y agoWhat you've highlighted is what I've always thought Marx's primary criticism of capitalism was: that the surplus value (roughly: revenue - wages - cost of capital) from industrial production is deemed the exclusive property of the owners of capital. Following from this was the prediction that this surplus value would be used to attain additional capital which would accumulate in the hands of the capital owning class until capital entirely replaced labour in production. In the context of the industrial revolution, IMHO Marx's predictions were ultimately incorrect. It turns out that steam is not intelligent enough to run the machines, and so production still requires the employment of labour. Consequently, up until this point, capital has enhanced the productivity of labour, not displaced it. Some of this productivity gain has even been captured by labour in the form of increasing wages. I wonder if recent the advances in machine-learning will, in time, be viewed as the start of the 'next industrial revolution'? More disturbingly, I can't help but think Marx might be proven right this time around...