7 ms·
Signed up, wandered around, here are my impression. * Nothing fancy, nothing new, nothing impressive. I wouldn't spend time on this site. * The graphical desi
by znpy 10y ago
Signed up, wandered around, here are my impression.
* Nothing fancy, nothing new, nothing impressive. I wouldn't spend time on this site.
* The graphical design wasters most of my screen estate.
* The side panel overlaps with the content when the window is not in full-screen.
* If you register without an email, it is impossible to add one.
* Did I mention that 60% of my screen estate is wasted ?
* Reddit is open source, this is not.
- gressquel 10y agototally agree with you, in addition: the site should really show its content at first page instead of hiding it behind login or signup.
- aphextron 10y agoI agree it's not perfect but we seriously need a reddit alternative. The community there is simply too toxic and I've had to quit it. If there were a HN like community centered around regular news aggregation I would be sooo happy. As is, it's impossible to find a news feed I trust anymore. Google news is infiltrated with fake clickbait nonsense, and I wont even get started on Facebook.
- azernik 10y agoSince this is project is coming out of the voat.co community, I expect the community will be more toxic than Reddit's, not less. EDIT: The article implies a connection, but as cracell pointed out, there is in fact no association, even historical or in personnel.
- cracell 10y agoLead developer says it has nothing to do with voat here https://www.reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/5qhz99/votenco_a_realtime_reddit_alternative_that_doesnt/dczh192/ https://www.reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/5qhz99/... 'The whole thing is based on voting which is why it has "vote" in it. It has nothing to do with voat.co. I guarantee that'
- djsumdog 10y agoVoat has a couple of issues. First, it took in a lot of people from banned subreddits (/r/coontown, fatpeoplehate, etc.) Unlike the great Digg 4.0 to Reddit migration, they didn't a huge chunk of Reddit. They just got the most controversial. Second, It tried to be a full Reddit clone with tons of subverses. Reddit started out with just a few categories and slowly expanded out to user generated subreddits. That has to grow slowly over time with your userbase. Since Voat started with that, it has a ton of abandoned subverses that one one posts in anymore. Voat is a pretty bad cespool of hatred right now. There's occasionally good stuff on there, but a lot of it is conservative garbage. People who have tried to turn it around are so outnumbered that they just leave. With that said, Voat is open source (written in C# I believe), just like Reddit.
- sf_rob 10y agoThe problem is a "Reddit alternative" will naturally attract the groups that no longer feel at home on Reddit. It seems inevitable that any alternative will be more toxic and/or hyper-moderated.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoScott Alexander recently covered this phenomenon here: http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/05/01/neutral-vs-conservative-the-eternal-struggle/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/05/01/neutral-vs-conservative... (see in particular section III of the article)
- mowenz 10y agoVoat is actually far less moderated, though, and honestly, almost nothing is censored there.
- CM30 10y agoAs will almost any site specifically marketed as an alternative to a major one. You market your site as a freer, more fair alternative to another social site, and yes, you'll likely draw in the people that were hated/seen as controversial on the original. See also a lot of Twitter alternatives (like Gab) if you want other examples.
- giarc 10y agoI think the problem is that anytime a group gets that large, it's going to have pockets of toxic users. So unless the plan is to forever jump ship from one product to the next, best bet is to find yourself smaller subreddits to make your home.
- xxxssszzz 10y agoDon't see how this even on the way to being a viable alternative. It appears to have started by already replicating many of the same toxic subs and doesn't appear to be doing anything systematically different which could help prevent build a less toxic community.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> The community there is simply too toxic and I've had to quit it. Which community? There are thousands of subreddits. Are you talking about the people who use the default front-page subreddits?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ehsankia 10y agoAll of 4chan is one community. All of Twitch is one community. All of reddit is one community. Youtube sucks because it has videos that pander to kids. Twitter sucks because it because it's because talking about their mundane life. Facebook sucks because it's people sharing fake news. In social media, whenever you're having a bad time, it's most like your fault. When you say X sucks, You're really saying that your friends / the people you're following / the communities you visit suck.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThat's like saying a nation is one community. It's not. It (usually) shares a language and some common values, but otherwise there's greater diversity within a nation than between nations. Still, there's a lot of truth in "When you say X sucks, You're really saying that your friends / the people you're following / the communities you visit suck". It literally takes seconds to join or leave an on-line community. On the Internet it's more true than anywhere else that you get the communities you deserve.
- skinnymuch 10y agoFYI That's OPs point. They are saying all those social media sites are the same to prove the point that they aren't. As evidenced by their next paragraph.
- nailer 10y agoI use the front page because I'm interested in what's popular. But someone's angry "f--k (politician here)" rant isn't my idea of entertainment, even if I don't like the politician, likewise various violence/creepy stuff that makes the front page. Reddit doesn't let me block subs.
- nailer 10y agoI have no idea if it's entertaining and they want me to sign up before I can know. No thanks.
- ehsankia 10y agoI get 2.5 stories on my laptop screen... This has to be a cruel joke. On reddit I can see up to 10. Although I've been hearing things about reddit wanting to revamp their UI. I really hope they don't, their minimal simple UI is the main thing I like about reddit and hackernews. And not being able to browse news without account means it'll never pick up.
- RivieraKid 10y ago> I get 2.5 stories on my laptop screen Still better than Google+.
- yonkshi 10y agoGenerally agree. But correct me if I'm wrong, Reddit hasn't been open source for a long time?
- CJKinni 10y agoThey certainly have private code, but this seems to have been recently updated: https://github.com/reddit/reddit https://github.com/reddit/reddit
- iblaine 10y agoToo many graphics. Too much wasted real estate. Sorry Voten.co, no thanks.