3 ms·
> This is patently false unless you listen on bad audio gear (bad DAC, bad cans). Double blind tests suggest this is true for somewhere between 128 kbit and 25
by Fnoord 10y ago
> This is patently false unless you listen on bad audio gear (bad DAC, bad cans).
Double blind tests suggest this is true for somewhere between 128 kbit and 256 kbit (256 kbit is CD quality, while 192 kbit is near CD quality, and the difference between 128 kbit and 192 kbit is miles compared to 192 kbit and 256 kbit; hence I suggest 192+ kbit. However, its 2017 and 320 kbit or lossless isn't a huge issue anymore; its even OK over 4G). Also, my quote is from 2000; ever since we swapped to LAME and ABR > VBR > CBR; ABR isn't even a static (constant) bitrate.
Quoting r3mix.net from 2000:
Facts:
128 kbit/s is not cd quality
256 kbit/s is cd quality (x) (in case of Lame or some Fraunhofer, not Xing)
In february 2000 c't magazin organised a blind listening test. 300 Audiophiles were involved, finalists tested 17 1-min clips from different artists (classic and pop):
original CD recording
128 Kbit/s Joint Stereo [MusicMatch (FhG) v4.4] encoded PC decoded Mac
256 Kbit/s Joint Stereo [MusicMatch (FhG) v4.4] encoded PC decoded Mac
all on cdrs and played in a Recording Studio on:
B&W Nautilus 803, Marantz CD14 with amp PM14 (Straightwire Pro
cabling and extra's) [DM30000- so bit more than $15000]
Sennheiser Orpheus Electrostatic Reference-headphones with tweaked accompanying amp (digital and analog out) [>$10000]
Conclusions:
90% of the 128 Kbit material was picked out
MP3@256 was rated to have the same music quality as cd!
If you find MP3@256 to be of inferior quality compared to the original cd, you're very likely to be doing something wrong with the test (correct decoder, no objective double blind testing, DSP filters distorting the process, ...) Maybe this is something for you. You can always read the article in the german c't 6/2000 on p92.
The treshold of mp3 transparency lies somewhere between 128kbit/s and 256kbit/s, depending on the kind of music and your hearing and equipment.
- em500 10y agoEnglish translation of the c't article: https://web.archive.org/web/20140217151727/http://www.geocities.ws/altbinariessoundsmusicclassical/mp3test.html https://web.archive.org/web/20140217151727/http://www.geocit...
- lightedman 10y ago"If you find MP3@256 to be of inferior quality compared to the original cd, you're very likely to be doing something wrong with the test" Try running that 256kbit MP3 through a pitch shifter. The quality loss becomes very apparent very quickly.
- jrimbault 10y ago"Try playing a random binary blob as a video file, it might play, it might not" Mp3 is a clever compression algorithm made for consumption. It isn't intended to be pitch shifted...
- lightedman 10y agoFLAC claims to be lossless/archival yet the same artifacting appears when pitch-shifted.
- qb45 10y agoListening through a pitch shifter is wrong, unless you are evaluating the codec for the purpose of listening through a pitch shifter. That's the thing - in normal use, high bitrate MP3 still sounds "the same enough" a lot of the time.