9 ms·
Scientists discover evidence for a habitable region on Saturn’s moon Enceladus
- teslaberry 10y agobill gates on space. http://www.businessinsider.com/bill-gates-on-space-exploration-2013-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/bill-gates-on-space-explorati...
- rzzzwilson 10y ago"a force of 800 miles per hour" It's Newsweek, but still...
- ge96 10y agoslugs
- ancarda 10y agoI couldn't read this on iOS as I kept being forcibly thrown into the App Store by some advert. If anyone else is having trouble, you can read the article here: https://archive.is/tPvTT https://archive.is/tPvTT
- timthelion 10y agoSounds like a bug in iOS...
- throwanem 10y agoPurify is an excellent ad blocker for Safari on iOS. I recommend it without reservation.
- rrm1977 10y agoNothing definite in here, just theories needs more research. Just a shinny news title
- speps 10y agoBetter link : https://phys.org/news/2017-04-scientists-evidence-habitable-region-saturn.html https://phys.org/news/2017-04-scientists-evidence-habitable-... By the way, it's already a month old, there's nothing new since Cassini's last trip. Also, can't believe Newsweek did a mistake like that if not for clicks... "Update: An earlier headline read that signs of life were found on Enceladus. We regret any misunderstanding this headline may have caused. NASA has discovered that Enceladus is habitable, not inhabited."
- ekianjo 10y agoYeah well you cant trust nothIng out of newsweek anyway. Its been as reliable as reading the Daily Mail for most of it.
- Animats 10y agoSo there's this big hydrogen vent in a moon of Saturn. Where's the energy coming from to drive that? Too far from the sun. Enceladus is tidally locked to Saturn, so there are no tidal forces. Enceladus has very low orbital eccentricity, a near-circular orbit, so there are very low tidal forces from that. Some phenomenon must provide energy for the hydrogen jet.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- foota 10y agoCouldn't it just be pressurised hydrogen?
- mcv 10y agoHow long has it been tidally locked? Maybe the core is still hot. Or maybe other moons pass close enough to exert enough tidal forces to keep it warm.
- scallycat 10y agoOrbital eccentricity gives rise to tidal forces in this case.
- Animats 10y ago
- Numberwang 10y ago"Update: An earlier headline read that signs of life were found on Enceladus. We regret any misunderstanding this headline may have caused. NASA has discovered that Enceladus is habitable, not inhabited. " Wow. Maybe basic transport is not the first area where intelligent machines will make their human counterpart superfluous. I'm sure machines can do better than this.
- Cthulhu_ 10y agoNope, machines would optimize for number of views / clicks, not for correctness.
- Pica_soO 10y agoIm sure, if we had better telescopes, we could see a tentacle-frozzen alien Galileo drifting in the gas fountain, who until his last moment exclaimed "the sky beyond the sky is not solid".
- mcv 10y agoThis article seems written to sound as spectacular as possible while hiding anything that might lead to real understanding. "Habitable" makes it sound like we could move there and live there without too much trouble. That's not true. What has been discovered is that microorganisms might be able to live there, near hydrothermic vents that seem to create free hydrogen, which could support primitive life. That life could be similar to life living around hydrothermic vents on the bottom of the Atlantic Ocean. No sign of life itself, though, just a process that could theoretically sustain life without requiring sunlight.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mirimir 10y agoRight, about as "habitable" as areas around mid-ocean ridges. Quite the temperature gradient there. Probably similar are Europa and Triton.
- em3rgent0rdr 10y agoHN needs to adopt a [clickbait] tag to flag articles like this with misleading titles.
- shimon_e 10y agoEven better, HN should hide the real title until hover to reduce the number of clicks clickbait articles get.
- ekianjo 10y agoEven better, ban newsweek which is nothing but a tabloid these days.
- Arizhel 10y agoIf you're going to ban anything that's basically a tabloid these days, doesn't that mean there won't be any news sites left?
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoReuters is still pretty good.
- ekianjo 10y agoI don't really like the NYT that much, but I don't think you can classify it as being a tabloid. At least it's usually well researched and substantiated for a good amount of articles.
- ekianjo 10y agoNothing new at all the same thing was said almost word to word about Titan 20 years ago.
- libeclipse 10y agoThis is quite old news, not sure what it's doing here now, and with a clickbait title too.
- em3rgent0rdr 10y agosurvival of the clickbait-est.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bluedino 10y agoEven if it was habitable, isn't most of the problem with going to Mars the fact that it takes a half of a year to get there - not a couple days like the moon? Saturn is YEARS away. Like 4-7 depending on where the planets are at.
- Symmetry 10y agoYeah, a Hohmann transfer to Saturn would take a very long time. The trip is long enough, though, that it would make a lot of sense to spend months accelerating under an electric drive in order to achieve a faster transfer. But it is 10 km/s even for Hohmann burn and once you get there you need to shed 4 km/s. In theory you could aerocapture but that isn't something we have the technology for right now. Well, we know how to aerocapture straight into a descent so you could go that route if you're headed to Titan but not anywhere else around Saturn.
- philipov 10y agoOkay, so it's simple: first we build a base on Titan as the transportation hub for the Saturn system, and transfer there to get to Enceladus [autocorrect wants to change this to Enchiladas]. Wouldn't it make sense to have a methane mining base on Titan anyway?
- Symmetry 10y agoRefueling on Titan might make a lot of sense. Getting methane is pretty much just a matter of piping it or freezing it out of the atmosphere. Getting oxygen from the CO2 in the atmosphere would be an industrial process and require considerable energy but it beats having to carry the oxygen with you.
- jerf 10y agoI figure that until we build one of the various nuclear-powered boost options that have been proposed, we're not going very far in the solar system. Either we get over our fear of launching OMGNuclear!!!1! stuff, or perhaps we can loft a booster and figure out a way of launching the fuel in enough smaller launches that nobody freaks out at the idea of a few dozen pounds of uranium being dropped into several quadrillion gallons of ocean, or something. Because the numbers just don't work for chemical rockets. The already-harsh rocket equations get even worse when you have to carry along the mass to feed, water, and breath, too.
- dmitrygr 10y agoA lot of articles like this overlook a lot of physics that actually matter a lot. Not only would it be incredibly difficult to get humans up there, much more so than Mars, but even once we get there we have serious problems. Just like Mars, we can solve many problems with electricity. We can create water and many chemicals, provide shelter and even ways to grow food. On Mars you can get electricity vs solar, which is perfectly doable. You can take some solar panels with you, over provision for damage, and build-out capacity over time. Saturn is too far for solar to be of any use. The only power source there is probably geothermal, unfortunately there's no lightweight way to convert geothermal energy into electricity. At least there isn't any that I'm aware of. This is quite a problem, as without electricity most modern conveniences cannot be bought. In fact, modern human life might be very difficult without electricity on a place that is not earth.
- mitchty 10y agoNuclear reactors still work fine for producing electricity.
- jerf 10y agoI'm really sort of surprised that nobody is seriously discussing how to build a nuclear reactor in space yet. I just don't see how space civilization can get going without nuclear power. Fusion would be way cooler, but fission should do. (Fusion would require not just that some small-city-sized installation works on Earth but that something small enough to usefully fit in other structures can generate power. We know we can put fission reactors in spaces small enough to run submarines, so that is almost certainly feasible.)
- devnonymous 10y agoJust a thought for everyone discussing human settlement - habitable doesn't necessarily imply humans should go there, robots growing stuff far far away would be great as well. I'd say having farming planets (or in this case moons) is worth a sci-fi book at least.