4 ms·
> What's your experience level with other languages? ~15 years experience across C, ARM assembler, Javascript, Lua, Ruby, Python, Erlang, Go, and Rust. Mostly
by derefr 10y ago
> What's your experience level with other languages?
~15 years experience across C, ARM assembler, Javascript, Lua, Ruby, Python, Erlang, Go, and Rust. Mostly doing Elixir these days.
Admittedly, I've never used an IDE; I write all my C in vim.
> ...you write compiled unit tests and/or test programs to poke around at the API.
That assumes you can get your tests to compile; or that the compilation errors are at-all helpful when they don't. If you've got a library that
1. ships as a binary blob + header files, and
2. most of its functions take handles to structs that are declared opaquely in the SDK headers; and yet
3. nothing you do with the badly-documented "create handle" parts of the API is giving you a struct that the "consume handle" parts of API will do anything with but crash...
...then you'll really wish that you had a REPL; or rather, a language runtime that enforced some level of introspect-ability on everything, so that a REPL could show you what's in the struct and whether your calls so far have failed to touch some obviously-necessary-to-fill-in part of it.
Without such support, you will have to rely on reading the decompilation results of both ends of the API to figure out what's really going on.
- photojosh 10y ago> then you'll really wish that you had a REPL Yes. I write roughly equal amounts of C (microcontroller firmware) and Python (overall system control, running on embedded Linux). I absolutely wish I had a REPL for C. When implementing with a new library in Python, I'll usually use iPython to explore it, and if I need to run a decent amount of data through, I'll use a Jupyter notebook. I'd put the difficulty of grokking a C library somewhere between 10x and 100x harder.
- yorwba 10y agoI use gdb as a C REPL. You attach it to a binary that has the functions you need, then you can use them with the `p` (or `print`) command. Loops and new function definitions are not possible, but sometimes it's still good enough.
- pjmlp 10y agoThat is how I once developed a B+ Tree library for low level disk blocks back in 1996, it was quite helpful tracking down how the nodes were being used.
- RhysU 10y agoGdb as REPL is a nice trick. Beaker Notebook might give the notebook parent wants for C work.
- photojosh 10y agoThanks. It won't since all my C work is embedded and mainly systems programming rather than algorithms. But I'll keep it in mind for the next time I have to translate my Python explorations over to C for production.
- photojosh 10y agoGood point. I've only been working with AVRs for a few years since I've been at this job, but looks like it might be doable. Thanks for the tip.
- pjmlp 10y agoC has had REPLs since the 90's, one just needs to search for them, and eventually buy them. They were quite common advertising in The C User's Journal and Dr. Dobbs.
- zzalpha 10y agoor rather, a language runtime that enforced some level of introspect-ability on everything And now we get to the real meat of it. It's not a REPL you want. It's reflection. It just so happens that the latter is frequently paired with the former. And I agree, that feature, which separates C#, Java, Ruby, Perl, Python, etc, from legacy languages like C make them significantly easier to use as a developer as the compiler, debugger, and IDE can do a much better job. But as a feature it's orthogonal to a REPL.
- derefr 10y agoReflection isn't orthogonal to a REPL; it's synergistic with a REPL. When you have a static language, yes, REPLs don't add much; reflection by itself is all you need and an IDE will suit you fine. But when you are working in a language with runtime code generation—one where objects can build themselves new runtime-native function handles in response to messages—then a REPL will be able to do things for you that an IDE cannot†. A REPL in a dynamic language (that takes advantage of its dynamicity) can be used to "explore" down CORBA/DBUS object trees; or fluently walk REST or SOAP endpoints without needing pre-baked WSDL descriptors to guide you to them. Heck, an Erlang REPL can hot-upgrade remote nodes. :) † Or, at least, not a traditional IDE. You would need an IDE connected to a "live session" of your project—essentially a hybrid IDE-REPL. (Examples: Light Table; Emacs' CIDER extension for Clojure.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pjmlp 10y agoLisp, Smalltalk and Mesa XDE at Xerox PARC are the genesis of what an IDE is supposed to be. Two dynamic and one static languages.