3 ms·
Pretty much. This is pretty much a classic analysis of execution risk. The company spends so much time in development that the market passes them by. One of my
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Pretty much. This is pretty much a classic analysis of execution risk. The company spends so much time in development that the market passes them by. One of my favorite poster children for this is Plastic Logic.
I have no direct knowledge of anything that Magic Leap is doing so I can only speculate. My speculation is that they have raised too much money, and as a result they lost their edge. People are naturally more productive when a deadline is looming, especially if it is an existential one, and startups typically have a limited amount of cash before they have to raise more or die. But sometimes startups get enough money that they can operate for years before they die, and then their delivery deadlines seem to ooze out to years.
It can happen easily enough, if you have to deliver next year, and your schedule it tight, then you start narrowing the scope of your delivery. That naturally prunes the things that are less critical to your success from the delivery and focuses the team on the critical bits. If your delivery is in two years, there often is pressure for some "quick wins" which are features which are not critical to the product but easily completed to show progress. As a result you make lots of progress on things which are not part of the critical path. It can make an engineering team feel good ("Hey, look at all this stuff we got done!") but it pushes off the question of whether or not they can even do the critical bit.
One unexpected side effect of this I saw in a company I advised was that the group working on the critical bits were penalized in terms of recognition for not getting more done (even though their part of the problem was much harder) and some key members of the group left, putting the critical pieces in still more jeopardy.
What I'm trying to say is that taking a big funding round is exceptionally risky for people who haven't managed through the sorts of ups and downs a startup has to weather. Magic leap took in a lot of money early on. That sets the stage for disaster. Not that the problem will actualize; People go out sailing on the San Francisco Bay without enough life vests for the people on board every day and that situation only occasionally intersects with an event that results in the loss of life. But once you've left the dock without enough vests, you have just increased the importance of the competence and abilities of your crew without necessarily realizing it. So to with startups that take too much money, they increase the importance of having a management team with exceptionally good discipline.
We will get to see how it turns out for Magic Leap.
- kken 10y ago>One of my favorite poster children for this is Plastic Logic. Basically the entire organic transistor community has a solution in search of a problem. Not really an issue limited to Plastic Logic.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoAgreed, but PL had an excellent product, the flexible e-ink display, that had they sold it as a component[1] they could have funded any number of future products. Instead they felt they had the funding and runway to build the entire experience and dominate the e-reader market with a more durable, less expensive, and larger format product. The interesting bit was that they were not wrong, if they could do all those things they could have dominated the market. But they had too much money relative to the market window. As a result they spent way too much time working through product issues that were completely unrelated to their game changing display and once full color tablet readers were a competitive threat they had too much margin pressure to recoup any of their development costs. [1] And yes, I met with their VP of Marketing/Product Development and explained this to them when they had time to take the advice, but they did not.
- kken 10y agoI agree, they tried to do more than they should have. A general issue I see, however, is that the real world need for flexible displays is far more limited than earlier projections suggested. If you switch to a rigid display, there is no reason to use an organic transistor back plane - that's where things start to unravel. PL were not even the first company in that space. There also were Polymervision and a couple of others.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoIt is quite difficult to predict exactly the road not taken, I realize that PL's demise may have been written long before they chose the path they chose. That said, I could see other markets, markets that have yet to be exploited, which they might have reached. One was the 'flimsy', a bare bones e-reader so simple it could be sold very cheaply if its display was built using roll to roll printing technology. It was the 'e-reader as printer' something that sat perhaps in a network connected cradle with the 'smarts' and you printed to the display and then could detach it and take it with you. With a flexible display you could feed in a new display like you would a sheet of paper, with either a set of contacts along one edge or the driver in the surface on which the sheet rested. Lawyers carry around literally pounds of paper for trial, putting all of those in a dozen e-readers so that you could have all the interesting pages up to read at the same time. That would be something. The key though is cost. A slam dunk product would cost what the Boogie board does ($30) have 200dpi+ resolution and let you write on it with a simple stylus.